VII Titanic Mini Mafia: I Have a Cunning Plan... - Page 5

On February 15 2015 08:47 prplhz wrote:

how long has it been going on for?

On February 15 2015 08:51 Fecalfeast wrote:

While I do care about slam and his problems, is this really the best thread?

On February 15 2015 08:57 ritoky wrote:
alright FF, let's play a fill in the blanks game!!!!!!

your turn:

robik is filled with rage because he sees the hag also he smells like FUCK THAT FUCKING FUCK FUKC

On February 15 2015 10:10 liancourt wrote:
i'm just throwing this out there. Has anyone played d1 without opening their pm?

On February 15 2015 12:45 prplhz wrote:
can anybody explain this hts miller business to me because i don't understand it at all

On February 15 2015 13:04 Town Puppy wrote:

She claimed miller right off the bat. I think it makes her pretty clearly town due to this chain of logic:

(1) Hosts don't typically run multiple millers in a game. Therefore, claiming miller is in effect claiming something like named VT.
(2) If there is a miller in the game, and HTS is not the miller, then HTS will almost certainly be lynched as mafia (possibly d1, if not then d2).
(3) Thus, HTS's only hope in fakeclaiming miller is that there isn't a miller in the game to cc her, because if there is she basically just gave herself up.
(4) HTS is traditionally not a high-risk player (in my estimation), which makes her an unlikely candidate to have attempted such a high-risk strategy as mafia.
(5) Thus, it is likely that HTS's claim is genuine.
(6) HTS is town.

I think the only thing in that chain that can plausibly be falsified is (4) - maybe she's a higher-risk player than I'm aware. No one has attempted to do so, though. 1-3 is ironclad and 5-6 follow from 1-3 + 4, so unless someone can demonstrate that HTS is reasonably likely to have attempted a high-risk play like this, there's really no reason not to take her claim at face value and go from there.

What's bothering me most is that there are multiple people in the thread - rso and LS are the ones who come to mind, but they aren't alone - who more or less accept this reasoning (because they just played another game where this scenario occurred), and who aren't contesting (4), but still are finding reasons not to townread HTS. (There's other people, like rayn, who scumread her as well, but I'm less inclined to be worried about that because his reasoning had nothing to do with this logic at all, and I'm reasonably certain he hasn't seen this argument before. rso and LS have.)

On February 15 2015 13:36 Half the Sky wrote:
Looking into some of Rayn's quotes after he questioned me on my reads, there are a few quotes of his that have me scumreading Rayn.

I have never played with him so I am disregarding meta.



How does he know for a "fact that LS is town"? If he's town, he wouldn't know this for a fact.

Next quote: Possible buddying of Palmar? I don't understand as a veteran why he cannot figure out some of these players (other veterans) himself. I have heard in QTs he's a good player (correct me if I'm wrong on this)

Now I know BH has been around, I don't know who he means by Robert, and it would appear prplhz has also been around TL a bit. It seems like it could be a way to use an incorrect Palmar read for a potential mafia agenda.



I also read further on the post that Rasputin mentioned on the flip-flop. I don't understand why he'd ask Palmar for help on reading someone and then through a single post, he not only is confident enough to agree with someone he previously might have needed help reading but then retracts someone he was willing to work with.

Additionally I got a very bad vibe from this as well:



Like he's trying to push me when I'd already answered his questions. Looking at the timestamps there were 12 minutes in between I answered his last question and when he said that, so it's not like he missed my questions. It seems like he's trying to reach to call me scum based on this.

On February 16 2015 06:57 ritoky wrote:


when you unlock the eye of the CHUPAZI everything becomes clear.

On February 16 2015 07:03 KelsierSC wrote:
luckily this day's lynch is settled so I can go to sleep. No shenanigans please and just lynch BH, he has conceded at this point.

I think Ritoky is mafia aswell, he got caught out by trying to throw scum on hts for voting on BH, his reason was super contrived like "hts just wants to get off rayn" despite there being no evidence of this.
Now BH is mafia it is pretty clear hts had a good vote and rit was trying to make the lynch appear scummy.

I still think prplhz is mafia.

On February 16 2015 07:28 ritoky wrote:


I kinda thought it was from SWATCATS