EPT
Slytherin Mini Mafia - Page 40
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
LightningStrike
United States14277 Posts
| ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
On February 09 2015 10:54 gobbledydook wrote: no bueno i wake up to a wagon on me first that 'why are u not voting damdred' thing is wrong, i can always vote whenever so long as i do it before deadline, i could put my vote on him and that would be as noncommittal as putting it anywhere else or not putting it anywhere. damdreds showed up since i went to sleep. hes started thinking which is good. im taking him off the scumlist. obi is pretty useless, but hes always pretty useless with a few scattered gems of brilliance among the uselessness and i lost my last game scumreading his uselessness when he was town, so i dont know any more. how do u read him? lonemeow needs to say more stuff lightning strike is pretty interesting, so what hes been doing is: 1) make a pretty general and boring list of one-sentence reads of everyone, that it doesnt seem like hes thought much about it. 2) makes excuses for not posting 3) sheeps damdred 4) asking simple questions about what X thinks of Y this betrays a lack of deep thinking, i think its likely he scum tryna get an easy mislynch without doing much This is a pretty bad post for a catch up post I think. Firstly totally avoids the case on him never even tries to answer any of the points that I brought up. Instead talked about why he didn't instantly vote on me which wasn't really a point that was brought up I believe in my case or in some of the questions asked. Avoided Kei question about Linux mafia. Also you say you have a scum list but looking in your filter you had me as scum but now you are backing off of it. And now you are putting scum on LS without really showing us much of why he is scum or looking at his previous games to see if this is in his scum or town wheel house which is really important when dealing with LS. Also #3 isn't alignment indicative at all, all townies should be able to sheep a good case. And I have a good case, not every game can every person be a shepherd sometimes they have to be sheep to the slaughter. Also if you scum read LS for #1 then you should be scum reading FF for it also as he did the same thing but you didn't make mention of him here. Overall i'm really not understanding how 1-4 make someone mafia. Its not really alignment indicative. This post says a lot without answering a lot of the things brought against him and still lacks the depth of scum hunting and thoughts that a town would use. Lynch with fire | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
Also one of the reasons i'm kind of lagging behind on doing your list post LS is that I realize I have one to many town reads currently and I need to figure out who i'm most likely wrong on. | ||
Fecalfeast
Canada11355 Posts
On February 09 2015 11:15 LightningStrike wrote: FF you still didn't answer my question On February 09 2015 09:39 Fecalfeast wrote: I have not really made a read on geript, sorry I skimmed your post. I will have a look if it's important to you | ||
|
Onegu
United States9699 Posts
On February 09 2015 11:48 Damdred wrote: This is a pretty bad post for a catch up post I think. Firstly totally avoids the case on him never even tries to answer any of the points that I brought up. Instead talked about why he didn't instantly vote on me which wasn't really a point that was brought up I believe in my case or in some of the questions asked. Avoided Kei question about Linux mafia. Also you say you have a scum list but looking in your filter you had me as scum but now you are backing off of it. And now you are putting scum on LS without really showing us much of why he is scum or looking at his previous games to see if this is in his scum or town wheel house which is really important when dealing with LS. Also #3 isn't alignment indicative at all, all townies should be able to sheep a good case. And I have a good case, not every game can every person be a shepherd sometimes they have to be sheep to the slaughter. Also if you scum read LS for #1 then you should be scum reading FF for it also as he did the same thing but you didn't make mention of him here. Overall i'm really not understanding how 1-4 make someone mafia. Its not really alignment indicative. This post says a lot without answering a lot of the things brought against him and still lacks the depth of scum hunting and thoughts that a town would use. Lynch with fire These are actually really good points Damdred. I am happy with a gobble lynch also. Gobble come back and answer. | ||
|
Fecalfeast
Canada11355 Posts
| ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
Geript is possible scum as well I think. Any thoughts on that? | ||
|
Keirathi
United States4679 Posts
On February 09 2015 12:21 Damdred wrote: Geript is possible scum as well I think. Any thoughts on that? Hmm, not really sure I buy it. I think scum geript could have/would have pushed my lynch rather than defend me. ESPECIALLY if rayn is town. If they are scum together, maybe not so much, but for now I'm still okay with rayn being town even though he hasn't posted in over 24 hours. Anyways, my point is, with rayn on my wagon without any sign of stopping, scum geript could have pushed me pretty easily without much fear, and likely gotten the second most experienced player in the game lynched for free. Why would he pass up that opportunity? What makes you think he is scum? | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
On February 09 2015 12:37 Keirathi wrote: Hmm, not really sure I buy it. I think scum geript could have/would have pushed my lynch rather than defend me. ESPECIALLY if rayn is town. If they are scum together, maybe not so much, but for now I'm still okay with rayn being town even though he hasn't posted in over 24 hours. Anyways, my point is, with rayn on my wagon without any sign of stopping, scum geript could have pushed me pretty easily without much fear, and likely gotten the second most experienced player in the game lynched for free. Why would he pass up that opportunity? What makes you think he is scum? A few things are really bothering me about him over all, besides that I will say that the wagon on you at the point of geript entering the thread was pretty strong and there wasn't much fight against it. So fighting against it is a bit wifom but could gain town cred being right etc., Besides that, I think Geript lacks follow up to some of his posts and lacks a real thread presence at this point. For example in some of his original postings he asked questions that have just disappeared in the ether. In no way has he followed up on any of it, he had a scum read on me a good bit has came from then and he did not even mention anything really about the case but he attacked obi for no reasons and then when he got asked questions he disappeared again. I'm not saying hes definite scum, or that i'm as sure as I am on gobble. But I think he looks scummy, especially his push or lack of push and follow up at points. | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
| ||
|
Keirathi
United States4679 Posts
It really bothered me how his scum read on you was such a big deal in the thread, then he came back and was just "JUST KIDDING GUYS, I TAKE IT BACK" without ever explaining it. | ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
On February 09 2015 12:46 Damdred wrote: A few things are really bothering me about him over all, besides that I will say that the wagon on you at the point of geript entering the thread was pretty strong and there wasn't much fight against it. So fighting against it is a bit wifom but could gain town cred being right etc., Besides that, I think Geript lacks follow up to some of his posts and lacks a real thread presence at this point. For example in some of his original postings he asked questions that have just disappeared in the ether. In no way has he followed up on any of it, he had a scum read on me a good bit has came from then and he did not even mention anything really about the case but he attacked obi for no reasons and then when he got asked questions he disappeared again. I'm not saying hes definite scum, or that i'm as sure as I am on gobble. But I think he looks scummy, especially his push or lack of push and follow up at points. So you're saying the fact that I'm posting less makes me scum. That's a really dumb argument when it's clear from the start that I wasn't going to post as much. It's also rather ironic coming from you. | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
On February 09 2015 12:55 geript wrote: So you're saying the fact that I'm posting less makes me scum. That's a really dumb argument when it's clear from the start that I wasn't going to post as much. It's also rather ironic coming from you. I don't think you got the point at all. Posting less has nothing to do with what I said at all. | ||
|
ObiWanShinobi
United States8089 Posts
Gd did you actually read my filter or what? I've given reads on a large number of players but apparently you haven't put any stock into that at all. How do you not have a read on me? | ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
On February 09 2015 12:57 Damdred wrote: I don't think you got the point at all. Posting less has nothing to do with what I said at all. Except that it does. I can't follow up on things if I'm not posting as much or if, when I'm posting, I'm following up on other things which are actually more important at the time. Like OWS. I can't follow up on things if I'm playing D&D with my friends for idk 7-8 hours or if I'm sleeping. Like I could make a huge case about you posting less and shit, but it's NLA. I'd rather just let people do their thing while I do mine. | ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
On February 09 2015 13:02 ObiWanShinobi wrote: Did gd really call me useless? Gd did you actually read my filter or what? I've given reads on a large number of players but apparently you haven't put any stock into that at all. How do you not have a read on me? If the shoe fits... | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
On February 09 2015 13:02 geript wrote: Except that it does. I can't follow up on things if I'm not posting as much or if, when I'm posting, I'm following up on other things which are actually more important at the time. Like OWS. I can't follow up on things if I'm playing D&D with my friends for idk 7-8 hours or if I'm sleeping. Like I could make a huge case about you posting less and shit, but it's NLA. I'd rather just let people do their thing while I do mine. Actually my general filter as town or mafia is 4 pages by end of day one and i'm on page 5 I believe by now. So obviously that is a null argument either way. Secondly you are being really defensive. I am not saying you are scummy because you are not posting much, in fact if you look at student mafia which was linked a ton. You posted way less for most of d1 but you still had good follow up on things you asked or things you found interesting. However here, you dropped almost everything you talked about earlier and just focused on obi, you showed earlier in the thread that you can make huge posts talking about everything. But you didn't here you dropped most of the earlier stuff and just focused on obi without making a convincing case at all. | ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
| ||
|
Damdred
15669 Posts
| ||
|
geript
10024 Posts
On February 09 2015 13:07 Damdred wrote: Actually my general filter as town or mafia is 4 pages by end of day one and i'm on page 5 I believe by now. So obviously that is a null argument either way. Secondly you are being really defensive. I am not saying you are scummy because you are not posting much, in fact if you look at student mafia which was linked a ton. You posted way less for most of d1 but you still had good follow up on things you asked or things you found interesting. However here, you dropped almost everything you talked about earlier and just focused on obi, you showed earlier in the thread that you can make huge posts talking about everything. But you didn't here you dropped most of the earlier stuff and just focused on obi without making a convincing case at all. I haven't dropped Obi. We're fucking lynching his ass. Like I also haven't dropped some of the earlier stuff, but the threads been pretty dead and when it's not it's been pretty worthless. Like there really isn't much more to say since I was in this after noon. Like Obi's read on me plus his non-read on Keir plus his complete batshit crazy but not really batshit cray cray is amazeballs scummy. How do you not get that? Like he literally glosses over great points that he should agree with and support, two things which he doesn't do in any way, to focus on the most peripheral bullshit ever. Like it's completely hilarious. Why don't you want to lynch the fuck out of OWScum? | ||
| ||
