The reason I don't think marv would be a good shot is that I am 100 % confident that I could read him if we tried to lynch him tomorrow which is not necessarily the case for LS or rsoultin.

justanothertownie

16318 Posts

February 09 2015 21:13 GMT

#5073

Of course marv is a way better shot than me so if that is your only other choice then go for it.

justanothertownie

16318 Posts

February 09 2015 21:16 GMT

#5074

Like for me there are 2 scum between those 3 so if you hit one of them tonight we have a 2/3 chance of being able to kill all 3 of them and just win.

justanothertownie

16318 Posts

February 09 2015 21:24 GMT

#5077

Eden... there is absolutely no world in which I am scum with marv. Not only because I am town but also because I could never ever townread marv if he was my scumbuddy. Never.

justanothertownie

16318 Posts

February 09 2015 21:26 GMT

#5078

Also it makes no sense for marv to call for a shot on me if we are mafia together.

justanothertownie

16318 Posts

February 09 2015 21:28 GMT

#5079

If you can't function otherwise then fine. Shoot marv. I don't think it is the optimal play but he could totally be mafia. If that is the case I will defend myself against a mislynch tomorrow.

justanothertownie

16318 Posts

February 09 2015 21:33 GMT

#5082

On February 10 2015 06:30 Eden1892 wrote:
Then let Breahke shoot marv. If he's mafia you can be town. If he's town I know my gut was wrong

It's not like I could make Breshke shoot anyone he doesn't want to shoot. I would shoot LS. But marv is not the worst shot either and certainly a much better one than me.

justanothertownie

16318 Posts

February 09 2015 21:36 GMT

#5085

On February 10 2015 06:33 Breshke wrote:

Show nested quote +

What changed from the first post to the second? First you are "clueless" then you basically have the scumteam on lock.

If you didn't notice I did some digging in the morning, I put in a shitload of effort today thinking about this game/trying to solve it. And if you look closely my reads didn't even change that drastically.

justanothertownie

16318 Posts

February 09 2015 21:37 GMT

#5086

The only big difference between the 2 posts is that I am more certain about bats being town now.

justanothertownie

16318 Posts

February 09 2015 22:05 GMT

#5087

Do you have more questions Breshke?

justanothertownie

16318 Posts

February 09 2015 22:14 GMT

#5090

On February 10 2015 07:09 Breshke wrote:
You have played with LS before havn't you? Do you think it is impossible this is his towngame?

I played one game with him where I was shot night1. I remember townreading him pretty early day1 and never really changing the read. I am not getting that read here. I am not an expert about his meta/did not read any of his scumgames but I feel like this game looks different from his towngame in general and some things he does/says just don't make sense from a town POV. Is it impossible for him to be town? Probably not 100%? But I deem it very unlikely and he is my best bet for scum.

justanothertownie

16318 Posts

February 09 2015 22:16 GMT

#5091

He just went with whatever lynch was popular all game long. Never taking a stance, never forming an own opinion never really trying to figure the game out. He has been constantly bluehunting though.
Add to this the things I brought up today.

justanothertownie

16318 Posts

February 09 2015 22:19 GMT

#5093

Also he was the first one to call my case on HF good and now he says I haven't been trying to solve the game. Does not compute.

justanothertownie

16318 Posts

February 09 2015 22:24 GMT

#5097

Don't ask me. This is the weirdest marv game I have ever seen and I have seen quite a few.

justanothertownie

16318 Posts

February 09 2015 22:30 GMT

#5099

On February 10 2015 07:24 Eden1892 wrote:
OK here's my totally selfish and bullshit reason to shoot marv. You should shoot marv because I don't trust myself / the town to lynch marv tomorrow.

If marv flips mafia though I think LS almost certainly gets lynched at some point, if not tomorrow then at 3p LYLO.

it's actually the exact opposite of JAT's earlier argument, lol. Rather than remove the lynchbait suspect from the pool, I think it's better to remove the suspect who can argue himself out of suspect status, because if marv does manage to do it he won't be lynched ever.

You know my opinion on this.

justanothertownie

16318 Posts

February 09 2015 22:31 GMT

#5100

On February 10 2015 07:29 Breshke wrote:
JAT which of these is least likely which is most

Marv/LS
Marv/RSo
LS/Rso

Marv/Rso is the least likely I think.

Not sure between the other 2 scenarios.

justanothertownie

16318 Posts

February 09 2015 22:32 GMT

#5101

I mean there is marvs refusal to let a LS wagon happen day2.