|
On February 09 2015 01:47 Eden1892 wrote: Wait a minute wait a minute wait a minute.
10 people left. 2 shot scum vig 2 other mafia. Scum shoots 2 town. 4-3 Town lynches scum. 4-2 Scum shoots 2 town. 2-2 scum wins.
This doesn't make sense anymore Good point. IF there are 2 other mafia.
|
Yeah, yeah you are right, Eden.
|
On February 09 2015 01:50 batsnacks wrote:Show nested quote +On February 09 2015 01:47 Eden1892 wrote: Wait a minute wait a minute wait a minute.
10 people left. 2 shot scum vig 2 other mafia. Scum shoots 2 town. 4-3 Town lynches scum. 4-2 Scum shoots 2 town. 2-2 scum wins.
This doesn't make sense anymore It does if breshke got lynched... which he does without the vig claim. Also not a bad point. Hm.
|
On February 09 2015 01:50 rsoultin wrote:Show nested quote +On February 09 2015 01:47 Eden1892 wrote: Wait a minute wait a minute wait a minute.
10 people left. 2 shot scum vig 2 other mafia. Scum shoots 2 town. 4-3 Town lynches scum. 4-2 Scum shoots 2 town. 2-2 scum wins.
This doesn't make sense anymore ummm I think you're forgetting koshi in your numbers, eden? unless you think there are four mafia this game @.@ which would make hts kind of evil lol actually I don't know where you're getting the number 10 at all? 10 people after the lynch and 2 modkills. Before Koshi was shot.
|
On February 09 2015 01:52 batsnacks wrote:Show nested quote +On February 09 2015 01:51 Eden1892 wrote:On February 09 2015 01:50 batsnacks wrote:On February 09 2015 01:47 Eden1892 wrote: Wait a minute wait a minute wait a minute.
10 people left. 2 shot scum vig 2 other mafia. Scum shoots 2 town. 4-3 Town lynches scum. 4-2 Scum shoots 2 town. 2-2 scum wins.
This doesn't make sense anymore It does if breshke got lynched... which he does without the vig claim. Nah. For one I'm not sure Breshke was getting lynched over Koshi d2. For another even if he were, you shoot to put town in LYLO in that situation all the time I would argue that breshke was almost certainly getting lynched up until the moment he claimed. Idk. One would think scum could at least make a different teammate (Koshi) get lynched even if they didn't manage to achieve a mislynch instead.
|
Maybe I should townread Eden because of "mindmelding " -.-
|
Maybe it is just me but I still think my HF/rsoultin theory sounds pretty good. Will go eat dinner now and see who we lynch after that.
|
On February 09 2015 01:57 Eden1892 wrote:Show nested quote +On February 09 2015 01:54 rsoultin wrote:On February 09 2015 01:51 Eden1892 wrote:On February 09 2015 01:50 rsoultin wrote:On February 09 2015 01:47 Eden1892 wrote: Wait a minute wait a minute wait a minute.
10 people left. 2 shot scum vig 2 other mafia. Scum shoots 2 town. 4-3 Town lynches scum. 4-2 Scum shoots 2 town. 2-2 scum wins.
This doesn't make sense anymore ummm I think you're forgetting koshi in your numbers, eden? unless you think there are four mafia this game @.@ which would make hts kind of evil lol actually I don't know where you're getting the number 10 at all? 2 shot scum vig + 2 other mafia. sorry for lack of clarity and 10 people after the modkills oh, you're right 10 is 7 and 3? 2 shot town is 5 and 3 town lynches koshi or bresh 5-2 if it's bresh that brings it to 4-2 then kosh nah man, your math is off I think oh. hmmmmmmmmmmmm yep it wouldn't be auto fsdghwg
|
|
On February 09 2015 01:58 batsnacks wrote:Either one is okay imo. Same outcome. breshke can't shoot and do factional kp in the same night can he? Usually mafia players can use their role and carry KP.
|
Where is HF in all of this?
|
On February 09 2015 02:14 LightningStrike wrote:Show nested quote +On February 09 2015 02:11 rsoultin wrote:On February 09 2015 02:10 LightningStrike wrote: I been asking who we lynch today because I still confused as hell about this game esp with bats claiming cop. If one of bats or Breshke fake claimed we might be fucked..... okay, that's true, so which one do you think fake-claimed, if any? My guess would be bats since he claimed so late but he also did this under some pressure. I also don't like how Breshke claimed Vig at N1 and it still finding it odd. Bats was under 0 pressure. 0.
|
On February 09 2015 02:00 Eden1892 wrote:Show nested quote +On February 09 2015 01:57 rsoultin wrote:On February 09 2015 01:53 Eden1892 wrote:On February 09 2015 01:51 Eden1892 wrote:On February 09 2015 01:50 batsnacks wrote:On February 09 2015 01:47 Eden1892 wrote: Wait a minute wait a minute wait a minute.
10 people left. 2 shot scum vig 2 other mafia. Scum shoots 2 town. 4-3 Town lynches scum. 4-2 Scum shoots 2 town. 2-2 scum wins.
This doesn't make sense anymore It does if breshke got lynched... which he does without the vig claim. Nah. For one I'm not sure Breshke was getting lynched over Koshi d2. For another even if he were, you shoot to put town in LYLO in that situation all the time As an addendum I think if Breshke is mafia vig, there is no way he becomes the lynch d2. Koshi would absolutely be sac'd if needed to keep that 2nd shot. The resistance to killing Koshi + decision not to put town in LYLO if Breshke is getting lynched just doesn't add up Well, you're right here, it's true. No way mafia doesn't hard-buss koshi to protect their mafia vig. But at the same time, the safer play is not to rely on the town to get koshi lynched, I'd think? I don't know. I think we're just going to have to approach bresh like any other player and forget the claim, cause I can see it either way. I don't see how we can forget it though. There has to be a pretty compelling reason for him to shoot his partner. I really don't think that happened Imma be honest I'm on board the bats hypetrain. Dude has played to his town meta 100% and then claims cop with a scan that makes perfect sense with his reads so far. What if the mafia forgot to send in an RB target? That would be a solid blooper nomination.
On February 09 2015 02:03 rsoultin wrote:Show nested quote +On February 09 2015 02:00 Eden1892 wrote:On February 09 2015 01:57 rsoultin wrote:On February 09 2015 01:53 Eden1892 wrote:On February 09 2015 01:51 Eden1892 wrote:On February 09 2015 01:50 batsnacks wrote:On February 09 2015 01:47 Eden1892 wrote: Wait a minute wait a minute wait a minute.
10 people left. 2 shot scum vig 2 other mafia. Scum shoots 2 town. 4-3 Town lynches scum. 4-2 Scum shoots 2 town. 2-2 scum wins.
This doesn't make sense anymore It does if breshke got lynched... which he does without the vig claim. Nah. For one I'm not sure Breshke was getting lynched over Koshi d2. For another even if he were, you shoot to put town in LYLO in that situation all the time As an addendum I think if Breshke is mafia vig, there is no way he becomes the lynch d2. Koshi would absolutely be sac'd if needed to keep that 2nd shot. The resistance to killing Koshi + decision not to put town in LYLO if Breshke is getting lynched just doesn't add up Well, you're right here, it's true. No way mafia doesn't hard-buss koshi to protect their mafia vig. But at the same time, the safer play is not to rely on the town to get koshi lynched, I'd think? I don't know. I think we're just going to have to approach bresh like any other player and forget the claim, cause I can see it either way. I don't see how we can forget it though. There has to be a pretty compelling reason for him to shoot his partner. I really don't think that happened Imma be honest I'm on board the bats hypetrain. Dude has played to his town meta 100% and then claims cop with a scan that makes perfect sense with his reads so far. What if the mafia forgot to send in an RB target? gah I really don't know -_- forgetting to send in an RB target with a claimed vig though, eden...that's a stretch when there was an NK I agree.
|
On February 09 2015 02:08 Eden1892 wrote: Let's check off all the warning klaxons
- In the middle of a heated discussion about what the PR claims mean, this post says nothing about them. - The post also makes no attempt to discuss anything else meaningfully. - The post presumes a mislynch today but does nothing to discuss targets to prevent it - The post claims VT again for basically 0 reason Yes, it is really really awful.
|
On February 09 2015 02:18 Eden1892 wrote:Show nested quote +On February 09 2015 02:15 justanothertownie wrote: Where is HF in all of this? is he in the UK rn? i have found the sleep schedule i derived for him absolutely bizarre if he isn't in the Pacific/East Asia sorry for making excuses for him but that's my guess It is like 7 pm for him and the lynch is in a few hours...
|
On February 09 2015 02:20 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On February 09 2015 02:18 Eden1892 wrote:On February 09 2015 02:15 justanothertownie wrote: Where is HF in all of this? is he in the UK rn? i have found the sleep schedule i derived for him absolutely bizarre if he isn't in the Pacific/East Asia sorry for making excuses for him but that's my guess It is like 7 pm for him and the lynch is in a few hours... *5 pm I guess
|
On February 09 2015 02:20 Eden1892 wrote: let's try this.
does anyone see a good reason for Palmar to have been the choice of medic dodge besides "marv is mafia and was afraid he'd come around eventually"?
think about how well this played out for marv, Palmar mysteriously dies and no one can really explain why, Palmar tr'd marv before he died so marv is clear town because Palmar read him town
i understand it's not obvious logic and it relies on a couple of assumptions, but truthfully what isn't at this point? and does anyone have anything more plausible? Ok, more tin foil hat:
IF Breshke was scum then scum knows there are some blue roles hiding. Maybe they thought Palmar was blue. Otherwise I don't really have a good explanation.
|
In any case this thread could use some more marv.
|
On February 09 2015 02:25 Eden1892 wrote:Show nested quote +On February 09 2015 02:22 justanothertownie wrote:On February 09 2015 02:20 Eden1892 wrote: let's try this.
does anyone see a good reason for Palmar to have been the choice of medic dodge besides "marv is mafia and was afraid he'd come around eventually"?
think about how well this played out for marv, Palmar mysteriously dies and no one can really explain why, Palmar tr'd marv before he died so marv is clear town because Palmar read him town
i understand it's not obvious logic and it relies on a couple of assumptions, but truthfully what isn't at this point? and does anyone have anything more plausible? Ok, more tin foil hat: IF Breshke was scum then scum knows there are some blue roles hiding. Maybe they thought Palmar was blue. Otherwise I don't really have a good explanation. Well if Breshke is town even, medic dodge needed anyway. So maybe they thought Palmar was blue and didn't want just to shoot Breshke in the event of medic dodge. Yeah, true I guess.
|
On February 09 2015 02:25 Eden1892 wrote:Show nested quote +On February 09 2015 02:24 Holyflare wrote:On February 09 2015 02:22 Holyflare wrote: It's still possible it's framer/gf/goon and they medic dodged breshke which makes marv v likely mafia Actually no it makes marv the opposite ignore me why does it make marv anything? ^
|
|
|
|