Linux Mini Mafia - Page 2

On February 01 2015 06:47 rsoultin wrote:


That post from FF caught my eye, too, because it's practically describing a good scum play...sheeping strong towns, especially those on the wrong track.

Personally, though, I'd find it very weird for FF to just say he was going to do that if he was scum, so it's not actually something I'd scumread him for and he's still a policy lynch to me, and one I frankly don't care to pursue.

On February 01 2015 09:33 Damdred wrote:
Hf is more worried about being right than doing anything, he might be Scum.

On February 01 2015 09:39 Palmar wrote:

Et tu, Brute?

On February 01 2015 12:59 Trfel wrote:

Yeah, you gave more than one line. Yesterday. A lot of stuff has happened since then.


This is your old view on Holyflare. Then you changed it with the only explanation being something like "Holyflare isn't concerned with solving the game, just being right." Can you provide examples to support this?

On February 01 2015 06:47 Eden1892 wrote:

I tentatively townread rsoultin pending further catching up.

The Damdred read is what I would expect from town!rsoultin. When she and I were working together in Student V, there was a lot of stuff that I wanted to recommend to her to do that I felt like I couldn't because I'd be hydraing instead of coaching. I kept some of my reads and whatnot at arm's length and spent most of my time asking her questions to help her focus her thought process. She pays close attention to detail and picks up on a lot of apparent contradictions in others' posts and questions them to find her answers. Regardless of whether you think the Damdred read is especially compelling, the structure of it certainly fits that mold. And while I admit I haven't seen her play mafia sided, I think she would probably struggle to pay the same attention to detail for her first few outings, because it's natural for newer mafia sided players not to be as attentive as they normally are, since they don't have any answers to find.

I think she's town, and separately I actually do like her comments on Damdred, whose flip on Palmar was completely unexplained from a quick search of his filter. I get why he'd like Palmar's jokes and not want to lynch him, since that's where I'm at. I also get why he would view Palmar as a policy lynch, because that's where I was on d1 of Hammertime. I don't get how he could go from one to the other when Palmar's behavior doesn't change at all, and it doesn't help that he doesn't explain.

I think Damdred is a good lynch right now.