I think the mafias in

Sandroba - Hes got a cop check which hes in a cell with and hes not trying to solve the game are you kidding me?
Slam - Thinks im scum too easy Im putting up a hell of a defense
Kurumi - Just making distractions hes not chezuni. Scum slipped about foolishness being the mafia spirit.
Onegu - Way too believing in sandroba I think he should be somewhat skeptical as town
Ls - Literally ignored me and has not contributed anything except a list post at eod when he was up for a shot.
Keirathi - cant remember anything hes said all game
Hts - Super lurky and everyone cant be wrong about her

Bats has a chance too because I have no idea what hes doing

Half the Sky

Germany9029 Posts

March 06 2015 02:08 GMT

#2230

Here's where I stand. I know he's got a green check, but after tone reading/comparing Onegu, I feel better that he's probably town. I re-read his Hammertime filter, and I wasn't seeing as much of the easygoing posts I was in Horn of Africa and the current game, first few pages of his filter I think draw that distinction. Onegu's filters compared to some other folks' town metas aren't a shining beacon of townieness but I think there's distinction enough to have a town lean on him.

I'm voting Sandroba. After filter diving him, Sandroba wasn't acting towny enough D1, loads of tone reads, but nothing in the ways of more detailed scumhunting or critical thinking for what I can tell, I know he had to backtrack on one post, but that was pretty much it. YM had called him out on his gameplay. Finally, today Kita asked him questions on findings from his filters, and he's answered mine (save the RB followup) but not his even though he followed up my questions despite Kita asking again prior. What conclusions did we have from those filters?

Granted this copcheck is a one-time ability, but I also feel his explanation for a copcheck play is something that any veteran who knows how to copcheck can say. In fact I recall how geript mentioned after Student V that the ones with questionable/sparse filters should be how cops check.

I'm about a third through Sicklucker's filter and I've accounted for the AFK part for D1. I still need to take a harder look at D2 and check for inconsistencies, I know that's how HF cracked SL in Void from the Obs QT.

It's 2am so I need to go to bed, so I will wrap that up tomorrow. But as it stands, I don't feel Sandroba's overall behaviour makes sense for what he's doing now. Voting him.

Half the Sky

Germany9029 Posts

March 06 2015 02:11 GMT

#2231

SL, I will tell you the same thing I told Breshke and Toad. My approach to large games is less spammy, a lower post-count compared to the minis. I spend more time filter diving and analysing with more people in the game, particularly with the players that I have not played with before.

Also had a work-related event that ran late, so not as active yesterday as I'd have liked to. Take that as you will.

LightningStrike

United States14277 Posts

March 06 2015 02:13 GMT

#2232

Sorry for not posting much and a update on reading Sandro's past games and will come up with stuff for tomorrow and sicklucker paranoia went through my head sorry and now seeing some light that you are more likely town than Mafia. Tomorrow I will present my findings on Sandro's past games as both alignments and present everything I have on him.

batsnacks

United States4466 Posts

March 06 2015 02:14 GMT

#2233

Okay I read three of the 4 filters and made my decision.

##vote Tubesock

Half the Sky

Germany9029 Posts

March 06 2015 02:16 GMT

#2234

On March 06 2015 10:52 sicklucker wrote:
Keirathi - cant remember anything hes said all game

Have you actually read his filter? If so, what sort of reads are you getting from it? Because I recall others having different conclusions using different critieria.

Half the Sky

Germany9029 Posts

March 06 2015 02:18 GMT

#2235

On March 06 2015 11:14 batsnacks wrote:
Okay I read three of the 4 filters and made my decision.

##vote Tubesock

Elaborate what you think is town on Sandroba please.
Sicklucker is also not very easy to read, generally speaking. Where did you think he was town?

Half the Sky

Germany9029 Posts

March 06 2015 02:18 GMT

#2236

Alright, the bed beckons. Good night.

Onegu

United States9699 Posts

March 06 2015 02:20 GMT

#2237

On March 06 2015 10:37 Mocsta wrote:
I dont know who to vote for.

I'm really disappointed sandeoba and onegu peaced out.

I dint want to vote for tube

I'm here now

Onegu

United States9699 Posts

March 06 2015 02:26 GMT

#2238

On March 06 2015 10:52 sicklucker wrote:
I think the mafias in

Sandroba - Hes got a cop check which hes in a cell with and hes not trying to solve the game are you kidding me?
Slam - Thinks im scum too easy Im putting up a hell of a defense
Kurumi - Just making distractions hes not chezuni. Scum slipped about foolishness being the mafia spirit.
Onegu - Way too believing in sandroba I think he should be somewhat skeptical as town
Ls - Literally ignored me and has not contributed anything except a list post at eod when he was up for a shot.
Keirathi - cant remember anything hes said all game
Hts - Super lurky and everyone cant be wrong about her

Bats has a chance too because I have no idea what hes doing

I'm town and then as one of the most vocal players is pushing my lynch. I get put in a cell and then a cop claims he got a green check on me. Why would I be skeptical of that? And you just got finished saying it's extremely unlikely that I am GF or was framed. So which is it. I'm town a few posts ago and now I'm scum? You aren't making sense. And now with the town spirit thing in your filter I am fairly certain you are the scum in the cell.

Onegu

United States9699 Posts

March 06 2015 02:32 GMT

#2239

Also Keir is most likely town for his vote on me. Makes zero sense for mafia to vote me at this point, they know the green check on me is real as.they know I'm town. Or the 1% chance I'm scum (I'm not), why would a.scum Keir bring attention to me, and a bus would make little.to no sense as if I flipped red at some point him being on me when there was a green check stinks of TMI.