Student Mafia V - Page 7

On January 22 2015 10:24 rsoultin wrote:


Eh, I was lazy :/ I'll admit. Have you had a chance to go back through the game, bring anything new to the table?

On January 23 2015 14:49 rsoultin wrote:


Okay, what makes him more scummy than anyone else? What part of his posting gives you the "formulaic" feeling?

On January 23 2015 15:17 rsoultin wrote:


I have read his filter. Have you read his fit at GB and Damdred? Doesn't seem fake to me.

The more relevant question I suppose is what makes Shining more scummy than LM? Or LM more townie than Shining?

On January 23 2015 15:22 rsoultin wrote:


The read of yours I called bad? lol

Calling him town for changing his vote when it was brought to his attention that his read on Bresh was based on complete misinformation? Anything else making you think he's town?

On January 23 2015 15:37 geript wrote:
Other than posting less which I brought up. But idk if that makes any difference.

On January 23 2015 15:59 rsoultin wrote:


Is it? You've made it clear you don't want to lynch LM and would prefer Shining, yes. But what about the rest of the game? The vote switch onto WW? Why not JJB? While most of us seem to be talking out our reads, I get the impression you're trying to consolidate yours with his, particularly Day 1.

Your filter seems very townie, it's true. I still think that. I like most of your analysis this game. Even your push on GB. But you really have been buddying up to geript and I think he's in the best position to evaluate whether or not that play is normal from you.

On January 23 2015 16:03 Breshke wrote:
RSo do you disagree with DP's read on the shining? I think it is fairly similar to what we were discussing before when i said his filter is hard to read. I just don't seem to interpret as being as scummy as DP is.

On January 23 2015 16:07 Breshke wrote:


I think some newbie towns are also careful with what they say not that anyone should get a pass for being new.

What do you think of me and RSo DP? Especially me, you seem more inclined to think LM is town and he scum reads me do you agree?

On January 23 2015 16:08 rsoultin wrote:


I do. I agree Shining is hard to read, however I did make the effort to read it and I'm not interpreting it as careful like he is. The rage against Damdred and GB, then the effort to make reads on geript and myself to determine which one of us is scum (when we're both generally townread and very vocal) do not seem like careful plays to me, even if he did townread us anyway after going back through.

More to the point, I do not understand his LM read at all. He's not making an effort to sell it to me. If he really thinks LM is town and going to be mislynched, you'd think he'd try harder, even with us dumb noobs, to get us to see what he's seeing xP

On January 23 2015 16:29 geript wrote:
Hey DP, let's play a pretend world. Let's say LM is mafia, who's his most likely partner? Let's say Damdred is mafia, who's his most likely partner?

On January 23 2015 20:20 Breshke wrote:
DP can you explain how LM is trying to solve the game. I can't see it, the only read he has substantiated is the read on me and he has 5 nulls whose alignments he doesn't seem interested in. Two of those nulls he had promised to look into and still isn't leaning either way on them. How can you call that trying to solve the game.