Student Mafia V - Page 16

On January 27 2015 17:15 rsoultin wrote:


What makes you scumread breshke, geript?

On January 27 2015 18:12 rsoultin wrote:
DP, legitimate question assuming you're town.

I see you calling Damdred scummy throughout your filter for this or the other while he generally ignores you, which is kinda strange imo...but now you're certain he's town over a town mislynch?

On January 27 2015 18:21 rsoultin wrote:
I don't see how his behavior at EoD was enough to completely townread him, is the point, and it troubles me that someone who has managed to do so throughout his filter just went oh okay, he's town now. Full speed ahead.

On January 27 2015 18:24 rsoultin wrote:


...So, rather than considering the possibility that you could be wrong, which you just yelled at me for, you're going to ignore the simple logic that it's to the benefit of a player to shenanigan onto a player not them regardless of alignment and say he's definitely town.

Despite the entire rest of he game?

Lol, and people call me stubborn.

On January 27 2015 18:26 geript wrote:
Best case 2015

On January 27 2015 18:28 geript wrote:

Fixed that for you

On January 27 2015 18:29 rsoultin wrote:
Well, I'm going to give Damdred until...I guess not long from now @.@ the few hours I have left to sleep to answer the questions I've posed him.

His voting and just disappearing does not exactly instill me with confidence.

I'm willing to lynch Shining if Damdred can help me make sense of some of those things, cause Shining doesn't seem to give a shit either, and if town doesn't give a shit we're screwed anyway. But I do think Damdred's the lynch here.

I just don't see a Breshke/Shining scumteam unless they both just got overconfident and decided not to come play at EoD. Possible I guess, but it doesn't seem likely.

On January 27 2015 18:32 geript wrote:

No I hated you because you were an asshat that didn't give me any respect. You've fixed the not giving me any respect part and I really don't give a major fuck about you being an asshat. I mean it's not like I fakeclaimed vigi and pushed you saying I was going to shoot you regardless of what anyone else said or thought on the matter for idk practically 24hrs straight just so I could get a read on you. Then once I got the read I kept that shit up just to piss you off. I'm pretty sure we're even. Like even if you're mafia here I don't really care. It's my bad read.

On January 27 2015 18:34 rsoultin wrote:
Well, all I know is, the ones who don't seem to care right now are Shining and Damdred.

And you, DP, if you're town...you're right, stylistically I am not a fan of your play. I'm also not a fan of being yelled at constantly by you xP Bastard. This is a student game, after all. My brother was happy to be killed cause y'all aren't very newbie friendly. Just sayin.

On January 27 2015 18:34 rsoultin wrote:


Unless he's town? Then that would be...like...bad? xP

On January 27 2015 18:34 rsoultin wrote:
Well, all I know is, the ones who don't seem to care right now are Shining and Damdred.

And you, DP, if you're town...you're right, stylistically I am not a fan of your play. I'm also not a fan of being yelled at constantly by you xP Bastard. This is a student game, after all. My brother was happy to be killed cause y'all aren't very newbie friendly. Just sayin.

On January 27 2015 18:39 rsoultin wrote:


-_- You do realize if he gets modkilled as town the game is over, right? Or if you lynch me at all. -beats with a wet noodle-

On January 27 2015 19:04 Breshke wrote:
RSo i was thinking it was damdred and shining so that would mean DP would be the town of the three.

DP keeps calling me mafia for bad reasons that are especially bad since im town and i havn't really seen him consider otherwise. So that makes me think it is probably DP/damdred or maybe DP/shining. I wish shining was around at EoD because i probably would have been dead and LM could have probably convinced people today.

##Unvote
##Vote: DP

On January 27 2015 19:19 Breshke wrote:


Take it as a compliment. i dont think you would be this wronf as town

On January 27 2015 19:06 geript wrote:

Most hosts and the hosts I respect generally don't replace after the start of N2 and definitely not after the start of D3. Like it's too unfair to the state of the game and too unfair to the player coming in. There's a bit of an exception for newbie games because they're supposed to be more of a learning tool than anything else. Winning/Losing is far less of an issue. I really doubt BH would replace someone in now.

As a general rule what I use when I host is:
1. No replacements for souring a game. 99% of time it mod confirms town by someone being a complete jackass to other people.
2. No replacements after the start of N2. Very rarely can people catch up reasonably.
3. No replacements after 100+ pages. This is usually more applicable to large games. Often it's too unfair for the person replacing in to be able to catch up and it's quite hard for them to stave off the lynch.

My hardest experience in replacing in was in Greymist's Catastrophe game. I literally replaced in like 200 pages in. I actually ended up getting fully caught up, but both catching up and avoiding getting lynched there was practically impossible. It's really funny because the first thing I did while catching up was just read filters. I started at/around Keirathi's only to find out like he died N1. It was a terrible travesty. I was devastated.