|
On January 14 2015 18:38 sicklucker wrote:Show nested quote +On January 10 2015 16:16 liancourt wrote:
The amount of defense on LS and obi is overwhelming. Even if it's mafia defending town it'll mean they're town and mafia wouldn't defend their own this hard so I'll reluctantly ignore them for now.
Eden is prolly town for trying to at least figure out the game when the thread was in stalemate.
Although I don't think oats is playing greatly like the aggressive town player he is there are others who are very unmemorable for example, drparnassus and breshke or even lala.
Town
Bats
Me
eden
ls
obi
oats
hts
sl
mderg
scum
drparnassus
lala
breshke
i'll look into one of these 3 later Like lians town guys lol. There was no reason to bus breske at this point of the game alot of people were town reading him btw. Good shot
Putting somebody in your mafia pile and literally never interacting with them or trying to get them killed is a bus? You're making the point even better with this, if anything putting someone who is mafia but widely townread as a suspect and then never interacting with them is more suspicious not less.
On January 14 2015 18:39 sicklucker wrote:Show nested quote +On January 12 2015 14:59 liancourt wrote:
it's 6-3 day 3
day 4 4-3 lylo
lets not get to lylo. mafia have an advantage on that day. 4 town literally needs to consolidate on 1 person to lynch mafia. Impossible. If a townie votes townie and 3 mafia pile on their votes it's game over. So day 3 is vital if we want to win.
If a cop has a red check or at least 2 green checks they should claim tomorrow. If you claim on lylo then mafia are going to take that 50/50 chance and counter claim it.
I really dont like how lala has been piggybacking on reads and using other ppls posts to seem like he has some kind of original content when everything has been basically a summary of somewhat. he isnt pushing any reads and has done nothing to figure the game out. The most lala has been talking about was me but didn't even push or vote at the end of the day. I literally thought lala was getting mod killed with 1 page filter on day 2 so i moved my vote to drp but i was wrong lala comes back posts another list post covering no content whatsoever. Guys lala is mafia. Oh ya this is the post where I town read him. Like mafia would never say this.
Why not?
On January 14 2015 18:43 sicklucker wrote:
Ok like holy crap that didnt take long and im even more sure that im right. Lian is doing his normal play I have no idea how hes gotten 4 votes I think your feelings are just hurt.
How about reading the fucking case on him and addressing it? God you're a donkey sometimes. You still haven't bothered to look at it, have you?
|
On January 14 2015 23:56 liancourt wrote:
eden ur thoughts on mderg and drp
and u keep fencing bats read, but u always end as leaning town or slight town.
and u really really really hard hard hard defended that lala is town through vote analysis alone. Yes SL has also mentioned this. You put a lot of effort into defending lala but didnt mention lala content wise at all...ever in the game.
ur only ever scum read was oats and me. Considering i'm scum in ur eyes who is the remaining one. And when i flip town who is the hypo scum team left?
Already given thoughts on mderg and DrP. If you're town they're probably both mafia by POE. Neither of them seem all that suspicious to me, but with SL/LS/lala/me as town, the only other possibility is batsnacks, who...
I haven't hedged my bats read, I thought he was mafia #2 yesterday afternoon/evening but his posting after that was pretty good IMO. He's probably town, I don't think I'm going to kill him.
I haven't mentioned lala contentwise because I didn't have time to play during d2 when s/he finally said something and the vote results + Breshke's flip pretty much cleared him/her. I haven't had to.
This kind of questioning is a decent example of why liancourt is mafia. Aside from the lala point it's all just asking me to rehash what's already in my filter; the lala point looks like a decent question on the surface but actually isn't; and none of it seems to be leading anywhere useful. It's like I'm being quizzed to test my knowledge of my own reads.
On January 14 2015 23:53 DrParnassus wrote:
one more
i need to see more stuff from eden before I can decide on the lynch so please get some stuff out of him between now and deadline.
goodnight.
What more stuff? I've produced the most meaningful content this phase. My reads are pretty easy to find in my filter. What's your hangup with lynching liancourt, if you have one, and if not why not vote for him?
|
|
|
Nvm work is dead lol
And my manager today is more lax on phone use
DrP's recent activity doesn't particularly impress me. He flip-flopped on me for no reason I can see; just last night he says I'm probably town because my reads conflicted with prevailing sentiment, now he says I'm mafia because ???
He hasn't done anything in his recent set of posts to make me think he's town, so he's still in my POE kill pile
|
I'm not refusing to read their content. It just hasn't left a strong impression alignment-wise.
Lets do it this way. If you don't like me POEing the game, which of the following townreads am I wrong on?
- batsnacks
- sicklucker
- LightningStrike
- lalalipop
If it's batsnacks like you say then who's the other partner and why? And why do you think batsnacks is more mafia for his posting of late?
|
B/c to me it seems like batsnacks is actually trying to figure out the game now. He wasn't on d1 from my recollection and not as much on d2. His last 20 hrs has been more inquisitive than the rest of his game so far
|
Plenty? Pretty sure the thrust of it is "I'm not sheeping Eden," which I'm not sure I'm inclined to believe since he explicitly sad he was a couple times. I don't normally mind sheeping but:
(1) I haven't caught a mafia yet so there's nothing definitively distinguishing town from mafia. It's easy for mafia to sheep town onto town, harder for mafia to sheep town onto mafia.
(2) I have so many strong town reads that someone who isn't one of them and whose reads are in large part sheeped from me is more likely than normal to be mafia sheeping me.
|
Anyway you didn't answer my question. Which of my townreads is/are wrong and why?
|
Yo batsnacks what's your case on DrP?
|
My commute is rough, catching up now
|
We killed DrP? Ick. Had him in my POE pile but his last 15 minutes of life were pretty town. Wish y'all would have voted liancourt.
And what's with the pessimism? We still have liancourt dead to rights. Game's not over yet.
|
On January 15 2015 07:11 sicklucker wrote:
So if lians mafia just blame doctor for not hammering a mafia to save himself and never vote lian out.
You need to stop spewing bad advice, if lian is mafia we lynch him. End of story.
You still vote your most likely mafia no matter what day it is. But you need to stop with this defeatist shit and reread the game for once before it's over. You have been riding your reads without any serious consideration of alternatives. You still have yet to address the case I made on liancourt, which some of your other townreads have said was solid. Now you're telling us that with MYLO looming that we're supposed to crown this guy town mayor? Fuck that. We're not doing that.
If anything you crown LightningStrike town mayor since he's confirmed town.
|
On January 15 2015 07:19 liancourt wrote:
I'm looking at ppl who didnt give a damn whether it was me or drp
i'm looking at primarily eden and mderg
How do these go together? I was incredibly vocal about wanting to kill you.
|
On January 15 2015 07:29 liancourt wrote:Show nested quote +On January 15 2015 02:09 Eden1892 wrote:
Nvm work is dead lol
And my manager today is more lax on phone use
DrP's recent activity doesn't particularly impress me. He flip-flopped on me for no reason I can see; just last night he says I'm probably town because my reads conflicted with prevailing sentiment, now he says I'm mafia because ???
He hasn't done anything in his recent set of posts to make me think he's town, so he's still in my POE kill pile u thought he was scum too and if i died today you would have pushed for his ml tomorrow. which would end in a scum win
How does that make sense? I have him in my POE kill pile. That's not the same as having him as my top mafia read. You're my top mafia read. I pushed hard to get you killed and DrP ended up going last minute because of shenanigans. How in the world do you interpret my behavior as being apathetic to which of DrP or you died?
|
On January 15 2015 07:30 sicklucker wrote:Show nested quote +On January 15 2015 07:17 Eden1892 wrote:On January 15 2015 07:11 sicklucker wrote:
So if lians mafia just blame doctor for not hammering a mafia to save himself and never vote lian out. You need to stop spewing bad advice, if lian is mafia we lynch him. End of story. You still vote your most likely mafia no matter what day it is. But you need to stop with this defeatist shit and reread the game for once before it's over. You have been riding your reads without any serious consideration of alternatives. You still have yet to address the case I made on liancourt, which some of your other townreads have said was solid. Now you're telling us that with MYLO looming that we're supposed to crown this guy town mayor? Fuck that. We're not doing that. If anything you crown LightningStrike town mayor since he's confirmed town. No you dont understand. Your my mafia you always have been. Ive told town to kill you and your partner. They choose not to listen Im going to die all I can do is hope they listen
You didn't read what I said. You need to stop pushing this because you're definitely wrong about me and possibly wrong about mderg too. You are wrong, and you are leading town off a cliff because you are loud in your wrongness.
|
On January 15 2015 07:32 liancourt wrote:
day 1 u go for VA
day 2 u go oats
day 3 u go for me and drp
u keep on not discussing about mderg
i cant find anything in ur filter that mention mderg.
Then you didn't look at my filter, because I've definitely talked about mderg, in direct response to our Q-and-A session a few hours ago.
Which, by the way, you never did finish.
On January 15 2015 03:20 Eden1892 wrote:
Anyway you didn't answer my question. Which of my townreads is/are wrong and why?
|
On January 15 2015 07:35 sicklucker wrote:
This game is pretty simple if you think bats is town. Then mderg is always mafia.
OK, this is actually a pretty good point.
On January 15 2015 07:35 sicklucker wrote:
Who wants to kill mderg? Lian does. So lian is town and eden is the last mafia by poe.
But this is not. liancourt never wanted to kill mderg until it became his only option late. How come it can't be both of them?
|
On January 15 2015 07:30 sicklucker wrote:Show nested quote +On January 15 2015 07:17 Eden1892 wrote:On January 15 2015 07:11 sicklucker wrote:
So if lians mafia just blame doctor for not hammering a mafia to save himself and never vote lian out. You need to stop spewing bad advice, if lian is mafia we lynch him. End of story. You still vote your most likely mafia no matter what day it is. But you need to stop with this defeatist shit and reread the game for once before it's over. You have been riding your reads without any serious consideration of alternatives. You still have yet to address the case I made on liancourt, which some of your other townreads have said was solid. Now you're telling us that with MYLO looming that we're supposed to crown this guy town mayor? Fuck that. We're not doing that. If anything you crown LightningStrike town mayor since he's confirmed town. No you dont understand. Your my mafia you always have been. Ive told town to kill you and your partner. They choose not to listen Im going to die all I can do is hope they listen
Stop being a donkey and reread this game. If you don't, we both lose, and I'll never let you hear the end of it, because you're being a cocky asshole right now while still wrong.
liancourt has been suspicious all game and literally never made his vote count unless it was his life on the line. He's never pushed anybody, content to hang around in the background and not be involved in the game until he has to be.
You've repeatedly refused to entertain any notion of him being mafia. What is so damn hard about doing that? Even if you're so sure about me and mderg being mafia, you have at least 24 hours here to read one damn case and give an informed opinion about it. What the fuck is so hard about that?
|
On January 15 2015 07:44 liancourt wrote:Show nested quote +On January 15 2015 07:36 Eden1892 wrote:On January 15 2015 07:30 sicklucker wrote:On January 15 2015 07:17 Eden1892 wrote:On January 15 2015 07:11 sicklucker wrote:
So if lians mafia just blame doctor for not hammering a mafia to save himself and never vote lian out. You need to stop spewing bad advice, if lian is mafia we lynch him. End of story. You still vote your most likely mafia no matter what day it is. But you need to stop with this defeatist shit and reread the game for once before it's over. You have been riding your reads without any serious consideration of alternatives. You still have yet to address the case I made on liancourt, which some of your other townreads have said was solid. Now you're telling us that with MYLO looming that we're supposed to crown this guy town mayor? Fuck that. We're not doing that. If anything you crown LightningStrike town mayor since he's confirmed town. No you dont understand. Your my mafia you always have been. Ive told town to kill you and your partner. They choose not to listen Im going to die all I can do is hope they listen You didn't read what I said. You need to stop pushing this because you're definitely wrong about me and possibly wrong about mderg too. You are wrong, and you are leading town off a cliff because you are loud in your wrongness. who are the 2 mafia then? me and....? you've run out of targets if it's not mderg then who? Scum slip
Just said it was mderg, keep up. sicklucker made a good point after I posted this regarding batsnacks + mderg.
Why won't you answer any questions? You even accused me of ducking your questions with mine, but now the only one answering anything is me.
Why can't you address my case on you?
|
On January 15 2015 07:46 liancourt wrote:Show nested quote +On January 15 2015 07:37 Eden1892 wrote:On January 15 2015 07:32 liancourt wrote:
day 1 u go for VA
day 2 u go oats
day 3 u go for me and drp
u keep on not discussing about mderg
i cant find anything in ur filter that mention mderg.
Then you didn't look at my filter, because I've definitely talked about mderg, in direct response to our Q-and-A session a few hours ago. Which, by the way, you never did finish. On January 15 2015 03:20 Eden1892 wrote:
Anyway you didn't answer my question. Which of my townreads is/are wrong and why? no u didnt talk about mderg u talked about how scummy drp was
Holy shit do I have to quote our exchange BACK TO YOU? Did you even care about what you were asking me?
On January 15 2015 03:02 Eden1892 wrote:
Plenty? Pretty sure the thrust of it is "I'm not sheeping Eden," which I'm not sure I'm inclined to believe since he explicitly sad he was a couple times. I don't normally mind sheeping but:
(1) I haven't caught a mafia yet so there's nothing definitively distinguishing town from mafia. It's easy for mafia to sheep town onto town, harder for mafia to sheep town onto mafia.
(2) I have so many strong town reads that someone who isn't one of them and whose reads are in large part sheeped from me is more likely than normal to be mafia sheeping me.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
