|
On January 07 2015 14:21 Breshke wrote:Being fully caught up why do you direct questions to three other people yet not me who you think is scum Also lian did answer eventually Show nested quote +On January 07 2015 12:25 liancourt wrote:On January 07 2015 12:20 Breshke wrote:
It was a bit less active at the start than i am used to but i have no reason to think this game will be harder than any other nor did i say it would be. Thats why im interested in why you think it will be harder? More or less what u think And the fact that there is no clear vet to lead town this game. More defensive players than aggresive players Not sure what was gotten out of delaying the answer so long and getting me to answer first though.
Oh, no. I noticed his answer, and I wholeheartedly agree that him answering was a complete delay.
Also, I was gonna follow up with a question on him on why he cared what you think, and why the information on how the game will be harder is even relevant in terms of finding scum.
I'm also disappointed in the fact that I was gone for 9 hours, and we only have one page of posts since.
Now Breshke. What is your view on Lian?
Do you agree with some of the cases that have been thrown around?
|
Bad early town list - bats lian bunnies
bad early scum list - Eden hts
|
Just bad list - Oats, n breske
|
Okay, here's another post from me. I was hoping others would be around so I could get some back and forth going, but eh.
First things first + Show Spoiler +
I really like that there are already basically two wagons going on SL and Lian. Good job possible towns, we might actually get something accomplished today!
Town
HTS- I'm really liking her day 1 reads. She seems thoughtful, and the reads are backed up by evidence in the thread.
Leaning town
Eden- Ive been in a game with him when he was mafia. The final 3lylo he was talking about I'm sure. So he is definitely on my watch list because in that game he came out super townie, and stayed super townie. But for right now, I've liked what he has contributed, and he wont be definitive town yet.
Leaning Scum
Mderg- I'm not really liking mdergs posts this game. One, I'm just not a big fan of oneliners. Two, Im curious as to his pressure on HTS for "obvious shitposts" or something like that, but then he turns to put pressure on lian over her. @Mdeg, what do you think of HTS now that she has given reads?
Breshke- what weirded me out most about breshke was his entrance to the thread. I mean I guess if you are gonna go hard, immediately call two people scum. Interesting entrance, but his tone (very challenging) is similar to the last game we played where he flipped mafia (that shot though). The only thing that would make me place him as town is if SL flipped scum tbh. I don't think they could be scum together.
Lian
SL
Oats?- more so for his questioning on what the point to my post was. Eden got the point. Or atleast answered.
Scum
None definitively at the moment.
I need to read more into Lian and SL, but here are my thoughts so far.
And oats needs to come back
|
On January 08 2015 00:19 sicklucker wrote:
Bad early town list - bats lian bunnies
bad early scum list - Eden hts
Curious, why Eden and HTS as scum?
|
lian is town.
bunnies is posting completely pointless posts.
Why did you feel the need to sum up like 8 pages Bunnies?
Im a fan of lynching DrP because his tone is off.
|
Oats why is Liam town I don't see it?
Bunnies you said that you are happy with the two wagons on Liam/SL, then you said they were town and didn't give any reasons? What happened there?
|
For now I town reading Oats and Lian since Oats seemed much more like himself from Student Mafia IV and Lian posts being genuine about his stuff on me. I finding that sicklucker early town read kind of questionable because I not done anything townie yet he giving me a very early town read. Unless he's basing off of meta he should have no reason to town read me this early.
|
I cant explain my hts read at this time im waiting for her to come back and interact
|
On January 07 2015 23:38 sicklucker wrote:
Eden might be mafia. Scum reading me for this is bad but voting me for it is terrible. He didnt early vote in are last game together
Well, that's false. I voted Chyz about 2 hours into that game.
You planning to address my concerns, SL? You know I'm more than capable of being fair in interpreting your responses, but I can't even begin to work with you to understand where you're coming from if your response to my questions is deflection and lies. The vote stands.
|
On January 08 2015 01:35 LightningStrike wrote:
For now I town reading Oats and Lian since Oats seemed much more like himself from Student Mafia IV and Lian posts being genuine about his stuff on me. I finding that sicklucker early town read kind of questionable because I not done anything townie yet he giving me a very early town read. Unless he's basing off of meta he should have no reason to town read me this early.
I dont read you town man. Infact im scum reading you now for ignoring my qeustion
|
Ebwop nvm bunnies I didn't see the "leaning scum" section.
|
Your concerns are bad eden like what do you want me to adress? I love when we play 21 qeustions
|
On January 07 2015 23:25 sicklucker wrote:Show nested quote +On January 07 2015 10:41 Breshke wrote:On January 07 2015 10:21 sicklucker wrote:
I see a big leak in his town game. I roll town its a good time to fix that and increase my chances of winning If I roll scum I dont want him to know.
Its not tmi your over thinking it. There is like probably 11/14 chance hes town. Thats really good odds
He claimed his role in everyone of his 4 or 5 games. Its a very bad thing to do im trying to lead town to victory!
So lets go to bed and get fresh heads and not graph at straws. Goodnight You can go to bed its fine don't feel like you need to stay here and interact theres plenty of time left but i have more to say. On January 07 2015 07:09 sicklucker wrote:On January 07 2015 07:03 LightningStrike wrote:On January 07 2015 07:01 sicklucker wrote:
You always out your role on game one, like in literally everygame. So please keep that to a mini Lmum its not good for town I only soft claimed on Carol on Day 1 then Day 2 I hard claimed. First game you claimed cop day1 second game you were mafia third game you claimed a role on day 1. You were like barely a role fourth game you claimed vt on day 1 (metal) fifth game ......... your 6th game please dont do it thanks. Coaching towns to victorys Here you clearly say he doesn't claim in his second game and his claim in his first was completely justified because he was getting and still got lynched. So he hasn't claimed his role in every one of his games. To me it looks like you tried to enter the thread by looking helpful with a warning to LS about something he most likely knows already. At not one point have you tried to work out alignments except saying ls has a 11/14 chance of being town . Even when i call you out you just call me terrible, am i terrible town or terrible mafia? Hey Ls I know you dont know this so can you verify this is new information to you? Also the one game he didnt claim day 1 he was mafia. He claimed in 4/4 games as town on day 1. So ya I have good reasons to ask him not too. Yes game 1 was not his fault but it was 4/4
The only time I didn't claimed yes was I was scum but it because we killed both power roles in the first 36 hours of the game. Game 1 it was sort for telling them it was Detective not Cop but it was because I got the role pm saying it was Detective and I was getting lynched and had to claim. Yes I claimed 4/4 I soft claimed at Carol on Day 1 but my role wouldn't matter though as kush claimed Scrooge Day 1 and made me useless even if I wasn't roleblocked -_-.
|
On January 07 2015 23:51 sicklucker wrote:
Hts whats your read on me? about the ls thing? why do you ignore this?
Sicklucker, clearly you aren't reading the thread...I wasn't ignoring it.
On January 07 2015 22:40 Half the Sky wrote:Show nested quote +On January 07 2015 09:59 sicklucker wrote:
Breske your terrible. Me wanting someone to fix a part of their game that they play incorrect makes me confirmed town.
If I was scum I would not coach the least confident town I would kill him
Silly silly Goodnight As far as this game is concerned, making general comments like that to me is not alignment indicative at best, could be scum behaviour for detracting from the current game.
On January 07 2015 23:39 Half the Sky wrote:Right now, from the posts I've seen so far, I'm leaning town on Bunnies for her post evaluating the 2-3 reads she did (she's trying, no?), leaning scum on SL (previously mentioned), leaning scum on LS (his posts are a bit of fluff, plus posts that detract).
I gave my read on you in the post literally before your question.
|
On January 08 2015 01:45 sicklucker wrote:
Your concerns are bad eden like what do you want me to adress? I love when we play 21 qeustions
How do you know LightningStrike is the "least confident" town? Seeing as this requires you to know who all the town are, you can understand why this interests me so much.
|
Ok thats a good answer by Ls. back to null. Everyone thinking I townread ls is funny. All I did was coach him to not do a mistake he just admitted to doing in EVERYONE of his town games.
I dont know wtf he is but since im town I dont want him screwing up this one too if hes town.
|
On January 08 2015 01:47 Eden1892 wrote:Show nested quote +On January 08 2015 01:45 sicklucker wrote:
Your concerns are bad eden like what do you want me to adress? I love when we play 21 qeustions How do you know LightningStrike is the "least confident" town? Seeing as this requires you to know who all the town are, you can understand why this interests me so much.
Ls is the least confident town player in this game. Hes probably the least confident mafia player in this game too but I dont know that for a fact.
I think ls's mafia game is probably good because he confuses people
|
On January 08 2015 01:49 sicklucker wrote:
Ok thats a good answer by Ls. back to null. Everyone thinking I townread ls is funny. All I did was coach him to not do a mistake he just admitted to doing in EVERYONE of his town games.
I dont know wtf he is but since im town I dont want him screwing up this one too if hes town.
You said LS was town more than once I thought, one of those times you said he was "11/14 town" or something. That's why I thought you were town reading him.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
