|
On December 20 2014 05:49 27ninjabunnies wrote:
Everyone give their top 3 town/ Scum reads outside of me.
This is a fair amount of repeating myself so I'm putting explanations in spoilers.
scummy pile
damdred + Show Spoiler +there's plenty on him in my filter.
previous post also
kush + Show Spoiler +He promised to be more active this game at the start. Then after 24 hours he said On December 17 2014 22:30 kushm4sta wrote:
dont plynch me bros. i was just kinda busy yesterday This should imply he's going to be more active. But he hasn't been. Broken promises of activity is scummy.
coag + Show Spoiler +
process of elimination. He's basically null and everyone else looks townier. I honestly would not be surprised if damdred and kush are the remaining scum, but if either of them is town my money's on coag for the 4th.
townie pile
palmar + Show Spoiler +I've played with town palmar 3 times. He feels similar to all 3 town games and I don't think he's good enough at scum to fool me.
Also, I really doubt marv would have consented to being bused by Palmar like that D1. I think what Palmar said was accurate: marv would have been more motivated to play if Palmar was his scummate.
I guess that argument doesn't preclude Palmar from being SK. Now that I think about it, maybe Palmar could be SK but I really don't think he is mafia.
LightningStrike + Show Spoiler +
there's some stuff in my filter on him. I also have more stuff in my notes if you want it but the underlying assumption is that he does not seem like devious enough of a person to post the way he has as scum
SL and VE are in between these two groups. I have some reasons to think they are town but I'm not as confident as I am about Palmar or LS. And sicklucker's attitude recently is not comforting.
Going to reread some filters. I'm feeling really hopeful that we can just lynch damdred, kush, coag, and win ezpz.
|
It's a small game, we have two mafia down. We literally only should have three power roles, with the numbers in such town favored power roles should claim especially if they are fringe lynched today.
It's the right play unless you think we have 4 power roles. Scum wouldn't shoot me anyway
|
wait you want are medic or other power role to claim? Thats kinda scummy...
|
There should be no other pr unclaimed we have flipped cop vet and big shot claim
|
Canada11355 Posts
It has come to my attention that the win conditions in my OP are unclear.
In order to win as metalheads you have to eliminate all threats, including both posers AND any third party that may be in the game.
The win condition for posers is the same; in the event that the number of posers equals the number of any other aligned player, the posers win. This includes a situation where the last remaining players are 1 poser and 1 Serial Killer.
The win condition for third party (serial killer) is to be the last one standing.
|
On December 20 2014 07:13 Damdred wrote:
There should be no other pr unclaimed we have flipped cop vet and big shot claim
Well that's all well and good from your perspective if you're town but we don't know if you're telling the truth. For all we know, we have a medic and he doesn't want to claim for obvious reasons and you are lying.
Also, did you really work all this out in the 60 seconds after the day post? You saw hm OK cop flipped vigi shot, so I'll claim veteran because we can't have a medic. Furthermore, I'm sure that I'll never get shot by either SK or mafia. It just seems hard to believe.
I just don't see the town motivation for the claim. How do you think your claim has helped town?
|
Hell even if we don't have a medic I'm not sure there's any guarantee we have 3 power roles. Does every 13 player mini have 3 power roles?
|
...honestly if another pr Claims the game gets even easier since one should be lying.
Its not hard to deduce from the nightkills in this case what's going on with the setup
|
Generally I've found three power roles to three scrum is balanced. But meh
|
Normally there is 2 power roles in a mini setup at least on Student/Campus Mafia. My guts telling me we only got 2 power roles but I hope we got more.
|
ls is the scummiest person ive seen in this thread in a while
|
sorry i didn't include a why:
just by virtue of lack of involvement
hm why do people want to lynch coag over me?
|
|
|
On December 20 2014 08:04 kushm4sta wrote:
sorry i didn't include a why:
just by virtue of lack of involvement
hm why do people want to lynch coag over me?
On December 17 2014 23:51 LightningStrike wrote:
Tbh I scum reading kush because in pregame he said would put more time in this game than the other games he was involved in and his first reply he said he liked the songs from Coag which came in like 5 hours after the game started and was reading the thread to catch up and he didn't give his reads or anything insightful in his next post claiming don't Pynch him and I waiting for a reason he's not scum at this point.
|
On December 20 2014 00:46 Palmar wrote:Kush is actually kinda scummy Show nested quote +On December 19 2014 09:33 kushm4sta wrote:
damdred looking so town imo from that one post i read a while ago Basicallly he has done nothing this game, so why on earth even bring this up. It's not like he actually has any worthwhile conclusion that anyone would ever listen to. It feels like he felt the need to bring up a read on at least one person. Shooting kush sounds like a good plan.
good effort palmar.
Granted, I would probably null or scum read me if I were you.
Why did I call damdred town? I come to the thread every now and again and read some of the stuff. I had read a damdred post that I thought looked town. The detail in his reads made him look town to me.
Why would I not say that I thought damdred looked town as town? I believed my conclusion was correct. Maybe no one is going to listen to it, but it did accomplish two things.
1 bragging rights if people lynched damdred
eg. "lol i knew he was town u noobs"
2 declaration of my intention to not vote damdred
|
[QUOTE][B]On [QUOTE]On December 17 2014 23:51 LightningStrike wrote:
Tbh I scum reading kush because in pregame he said would put more time in this game than the other games he was involved in and his first reply he said he liked the songs from Coag which came in like 5 hours after the game started and was reading the thread to catch up and he didn't give his reads or anything insightful in his next post claiming don't Pynch him and I waiting for a reason he's not scum at this point.[/QUOTE]
ok this is legitimate and actually it makes me townread you.
The explanation is simply that I've been busy. Just because I thought I was going to have time is no guarantee that I will.
When I said I liked coag's songs, I already knew that I wasn't going to be able to keep up. The game was already too big for me to read it. So yes, I was unmotivated at that point and indulged my inner coag.
|
and to the people who say "go look at filters"
im kind of unmotivated to do that as well since this is a wash. participating in this defensive manner is both easier and funner.
However, I may do some filter diving at some point later. Probably not, but it could happen!
|
I hope this modicum of activity has made me a less desirable lynch than coag.
|
On December 20 2014 08:29 kushm4sta wrote:
I hope this modicum of activity has made me a less desirable lynch than coag.
It certainly doesn't hurt. Thx for ur time Kush.
|
We're lynching Damdred unless he can explain how his claim has helped town.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
