Metal Mini Mafia! - Page 3

On December 21 2014 14:19 sciberbia wrote:
OK boys listen up. I think VE is scum and we should lynch him.

coag and kush now look like they are willing to play the game, so it is no longer the correct play to policy lynch them. If they are town they can help us.

Here is why I think VE is scum

His defense of my first case is scummy and insufficient

---

This is misrepresenting both what happened in the thread on D1 and my original case on VE. In the quotes above, VE is trying to tell a story that goes like this:

1. He had a town read on marv
   
2. He defended marv, his townread, from bunnies
   
3. Later, marv claimed scum, and that is when VE voted for him
   

Now that story sounds fine (besides the fact he TR a scum I guess). But this is NOT an accurate story. It's twisted and does not answer to the core of my first case. In between points 1 and 2, VE made a post saying that he "could be convinced to vote for marv" --> implies he thinks marv could be scum. Therefore, when he was arguing against bunnies logic for voting marv, he was not arguing against lynching his townread, but rather his ???/scum read.

Furthermore, VE voted marv in the game thread BEFORE marv gave up. His reasoning for doing so is not explicit in the thread. All he said about marv is that marv stood him up. And remember, he voted KUSH in the voting thread rather than marv.

Only later after marv had clearly given up did VE vote for him.

He seems infinitely more concerned with not getting lynched himself than finding scum

---

Since Breshke was shot, the last mafia is a lone wolf. That means that their goal during the day is to get anybody lynched but themself. Let's see how VE has approached D2.

votes kush and also calls damdred likely scum
+ Show Spoiler +

He hasn't been scumhunting today. There's no evidence that he's reading filters. In fact the whole game I 've felt he's been slightly subdued for VE, but didn't think much of it until now.

Now look what what happens when he thinks he's in danger of getting lynched. All of a sudden he explodes. The majority of his energy today has been used berating people who think he is scum.

+ Show Spoiler [defending himself] +

Just look at all those posts. The monstruous disparity between his passion in scumhunting (relatively low) and passion in defending himself (extremely high) is the biggest reason I think he is scum. He has not worked that hard today to show why kush is mafia. He hasn't been going out of his way to drill kush in the thread. But he'll go to hell and back to defend himself from my original case, which if you'll notice didn't even have a vote.

Scumslip?

---

VE has refused to lynch anyone but kush all day. He acts as if he is very confident kush is mafia



Now look at this post


Looks like a scumslip. What do you guys think? If VE really thinks kush is scum, then being scum is plenty of reason to vote for a town VE. What is this about backstabbing in Big Brother? It makes no sense.

Furthermore, he is saying kush has no excuse for voting VE. If VE truly thinks kush is mafia, it doesn't make any sense to say whether kush's vote is excusable or inexcusable. Mafia votes cannot be criticized on logic the same way town votes can.

---

VE if you're town I'm sorry and I'm gonna feel really bad but my gut says you're scum. And I don't think I'm wrong.

##Vote: VisceraEyes

On December 22 2014 03:49 VisceraEyes wrote:
The case is not okay. The case is literally "He thought marv was town, he thinks kush is mafia, he doesn't like when people accuse him"

That's literally the worst case I've ever seen.

On December 22 2014 06:53 Palmar wrote:

No. You made us wait through an entire day last time you were the one remaining mafia.