Student Mafia IV (New/Newish Players Welcome) - Page 7

On November 29 2014 18:59 meatpudding wrote:

Can you give an idea of why you think that?

On November 29 2014 19:19 meatpudding wrote:

Well yeah... but are you really saying that going afk under pressure confirms town?

On November 29 2014 22:18 Half the Sky wrote:


Neither individual is helping the town agenda (both have promoted policy votes over scum votes for example).
Looking at both Bats and Kush (as my current vote is on Bats) and using the above as a checklist for Kush:

#1 - Check. I had pointed out the D1 argument on page 51, but why does Kush expect any of us to think that D1 makes him a townie? Reads with the exception of the one Kush did on his phone have been weak/unsupported. Bats' voting D1 was a problem, but the gap between voting Damdred and then jumping to DSMI is even worse given the arguments he used to try and sell that vote. He pushed that vote well before Damdred did.

#2 - Check. Bats has dodged questions from three people this game (Oats, Breshke, myself). Kush isn't saying much of anything to begin with, but he dodged Oats on the Damdred read.

#3 - Check. Kush is way more sporadic than Bats, Thanksgiving is forgiveable, but afterwards, even Bats hasn't afked.

#4 - Check. At least I remember Bats for being overly defensive. Kush's filter on the other hand, I have had to filter dive three times in the last 12 hours.

I'd say he's topped Bats in the scum category.

##unvote
##vote kushm4sta

On November 30 2014 01:01 Half the Sky wrote:
Oats, I had drawn a few conclusions before I went to bed last night. I pointed to the inconsistency in Kush's D1 post when I made my top three scrum reads with Kush being one of them. I had bought in to Kushs argument based on the urgency from DSMI. After DSMI was proven town, I revisited his post and made the comparisons.

As for the overexplained part, I am making sure I can follow the logic used by others to go after Kush. I might not be the first one posting here but I failed to probe harder when Kush made his pitch for DSMI. I did not want to make the same mistake again for a vote on Kush. I spent more time filter diving for a reason.

I am scrum hunting and checking what is already being put out is right.

Which is why I used the above checklist as a guide. Does this make sense?

On November 30 2014 01:01 Half the Sky wrote:
Oats, I had drawn a few conclusions before I went to bed last night. I pointed to the inconsistency in Kush's D1 post when I made my top three scrum reads with Kush being one of them. I had bought in to Kushs argument based on the urgency from DSMI. After DSMI was proven town, I revisited his post and made the comparisons.

As for the overexplained part, I am making sure I can follow the logic used by others to go after Kush. I might not be the first one posting here but I failed to probe harder when Kush made his pitch for DSMI. I did not want to make the same mistake again for a vote on Kush. I spent more time filter diving for a reason.

I am scrum hunting and checking what is already being put out is right.

Which is why I used the above checklist as a guide. Does this make sense?

On November 30 2014 01:19 Damdred wrote:
##Vote Half

Look guys at his filter. He spends most of his time discrediting people for the push yesterday, spends a great amount of time on me but then never talks about me at all once he votes bat and doesn't even put me in his top scum list. I'm not even sure exactly why hes off of bats and unto kush besides that its the vote gaining the most traction.

Hes probably scum here

On November 30 2014 01:39 Half the Sky wrote:

Oats: It is equally probable that Kush is staying low to make you think he's not scum.

On November 30 2014 10:07 sicklucker wrote:
I doubt that man. Like how many lynches till lylo one? were in alot of trouble

On November 30 2014 10:11 sicklucker wrote:
The sketchy voting makes alot of mafia teams possible. Were gonna have to go with the most likely one. Oats didnt you do what you just accused your mafia team of doing?

On November 30 2014 10:43 sicklucker wrote:



Maybe Ls is town if bats is. Hes just following him around like a puppy. If bats is town I like ls. kts is town I dont like either.

On November 30 2014 10:48 sicklucker wrote:
Is he tho? Either way the one thing im sure of is Hopeless1der Is probably town for moving the lynch off of kush. He was the one who pointed out the thing about a tie break. Even this is a bit sketchy because he might think kush is getting mod killed. But I think experienced players know kush is gonna get replaced not mod killed. Can anyone add to this?