|
On November 27 2014 12:56 batsnacks wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2014 12:51 meatpudding wrote:
bats what do you think of kush right now? I haven't really agreed with his reads yet or seen anything from him to put him in my town pile. But you seemed to switch to a town read on him fairly easily. How do you feel after the flip? I think kush is town. Even if you don't think he's town he shouldn't be considered for the lynch tomorrow. This requires operating under the assumption I'm town, but mafia kush wouldn't move a lynch off of me and onto dick, because mafia kush would know we're both town and it wouldn't matter to him which one of us got lynched. If anything I think mafia kush would have been happier to lynch me because I was posting more.
I like this alot. Altho I think mafia kush would bus you;p
|
On November 27 2014 13:05 sicklucker wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2014 12:56 batsnacks wrote:On November 27 2014 12:51 meatpudding wrote:
bats what do you think of kush right now? I haven't really agreed with his reads yet or seen anything from him to put him in my town pile. But you seemed to switch to a town read on him fairly easily. How do you feel after the flip? I think kush is town. Even if you don't think he's town he shouldn't be considered for the lynch tomorrow. This requires operating under the assumption I'm town, but mafia kush wouldn't move a lynch off of me and onto dick, because mafia kush would know we're both town and it wouldn't matter to him which one of us got lynched. If anything I think mafia kush would have been happier to lynch me because I was posting more. I like this alot. Altho I think mafia kush would bus you;p
I'm positive mafia kush would bus me,
If I were mafia with mafia kush.
|
This game is so easy if we know bats alignment. Try to be active budday
|
On November 27 2014 13:08 sicklucker wrote:
This game is so easy if we know bats alignment. Try to be active budday
That post you liked about kush also applies to damdred, you know. 
|
On November 27 2014 12:50 Oatsmaster wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2014 12:48 rsoultin wrote:
Yeah, I'm not for pushing bats if the only reason is to see if Damdred is guilty or not by association, not if people don't think bats is mafia. Giant waste of time. If you think Damdred is the more likely scum, go after him. If you don't really think either are, we should be looking at other players. like who? Why are you using the word "we"?
I'm using the word "we" because me, myself and I am not enough, and I can scream into the ether all I want; doesn't matter if no one listens.
As to who...lord friggin knows. LS bugs me because of the multiple references to being cop before early on, but I don't think he's necessarily scum for it. And his explanation for not wanting to lynch vote made sense in the context of his last game.
Kush...he gave a few small reads and made a few comments but I don't feel he's made any significant contributions to the game.
The ones who are leaning more town for me are you, Trfel and Breshke...and SL to a lesser extent. Doesn't mean I agree with their reads 100% but I don't think any of you guys are scum.
Damdred I'm on the fence on. Experience says town...but since that was a different context and the experience I'm talking about is maybe 4 games, I wouldn't go out on a fence for him as town based on solely that.
Bats I don't like because he's not explaining himself well, and sometimes completely ignoring questions directed at him while goofing off. Yet those of you who have played with him before seem to think that's normal for him, despite Trfel's attempt at a metaread based on his prior games.
Still not happy with Alakaslam's nonsense then disappearance and last-minute vote. No strong scum read on him in particular, but until I get one, getting rid of useless is fine by me, as I said before.
Meatpudding is leaning more town for me than scum. He seems to be genuinely trying to probe for scum.
This is all based on memory, and the feels I'm getting, not specific quotes though if you want deeper reads I can find where the impressions came from. To be honest, though...I'm hoping to get something out of who mafia kills tonight.
|
On November 27 2014 13:03 batsnacks wrote:
Oats if you focus on what I mean instead of what I say I guarantee I'm not scummy.
What's that supposed to mean.
|
On November 27 2014 13:08 batsnacks wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2014 13:08 sicklucker wrote:
This game is so easy if we know bats alignment. Try to be active budday That post you liked about kush also applies to damdred, you know.
How so. I mean their basically the same thing is that what you mean?
|
|
|
On November 27 2014 13:09 Oatsmaster wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2014 13:03 batsnacks wrote:
Oats if you focus on what I mean instead of what I say I guarantee I'm not scummy. What's that supposed to mean.
It means I love you and you should town read me so we can actually win this game.
|
but didnt you just say to ignore everything i say you jerk =[
|
On November 27 2014 13:11 sicklucker wrote:
but didnt you just say to ignore everything i say you jerk =[
That's because me/damdred and me/kush as scum don't make sense.
|
I can agree with one of those. I really hope we have a cop. I still think damdred is more likely town so thats good for you.
|
On November 27 2014 13:02 Oatsmaster wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2014 13:01 meatpudding wrote:On November 27 2014 12:58 Oatsmaster wrote:
man fuck this game, there are like 6 scummy dudes.
Damdred
Bats
Meatpudding
Lightningstrike
rsoultin
slam Why do you think rsoultin is scummy? he is super depressive and just makes cutting comments at people. Not interested in finding scum or lynching scum posting for the sake of posting. Telling town to do things while not doing things.
The first is true enough. I'm caustic.
The second I can understand, even though I have been making an effort, with first Meatpudding (questioning his timing), then LS (questioning why he didn't want to lynch anyone first night). It's part-arrogance, admittedly. Since it's not clear to me (and obviously isn't clear to most of the rest of you with all the hopping around I'm seeing) who scum is, I'm not hugely in favor of bussing someone I don't feel strongly about. I could make up some hogwash if you like, but I don't feel that's constructive in the long run.
The third is your opinion, so I won't argue it one way or another. Everyone can decide that for themselves.
As to the fourth...that's where I'm lost. What are you referring to?
|
rsoultin to the best of my knowledge bussing is when mafia votes a mafia so if your town i would stop using that word to refer to your actions
|
Ah. Thanks. Believe that's the first time I've used it, but I know I've used pushed a few times. Is that one too?
|
On November 27 2014 12:48 rsoultin wrote:
Yeah, I'm not for pushing bats if the only reason is to see if Damdred is guilty or not by association, not if people don't think bats is mafia. Giant waste of time. If you think Damdred is the more likely scum, go after him. If you don't really think either are, we should be looking at other players.
I was talking about this post.
You did post a list post after that so meh.
|
On November 27 2014 09:55 Breshke wrote:
Because I wasn't going to take the vote off of dicksmash. Yes i thought he could have been town but you had a good case and he hardly even tried after that. Yeah he was the doctor but he didn't even try to defend himself I was happy with that lynch going though but i would have been happier with a bats lynch. Bats has been more involved though so im not going to try and force the lynch onto someone that will give stuff lateer in the day over someone who wasnt even trying.
Why did you specifically say i had other questionable actions yet you cant pinpoint anything else?
I didn't want you to think i was dodging you so I figured i should answer you now.
Your lead up to your vote, vote and then actions around deadline were questionable to someone who thought that they were on the higher percentage lynch candidate.
Besides that you seemed ok today, you didn't go hard at me for no answering you on your read questions though when you probably should of pressured the hell out of me at that point.
|
On November 27 2014 14:20 Damdred wrote:Show nested quote +On November 27 2014 09:55 Breshke wrote:
Because I wasn't going to take the vote off of dicksmash. Yes i thought he could have been town but you had a good case and he hardly even tried after that. Yeah he was the doctor but he didn't even try to defend himself I was happy with that lynch going though but i would have been happier with a bats lynch. Bats has been more involved though so im not going to try and force the lynch onto someone that will give stuff lateer in the day over someone who wasnt even trying.
Why did you specifically say i had other questionable actions yet you cant pinpoint anything else? I didn't want you to think i was dodging you so I figured i should answer you now. Your lead up to your vote, vote and then actions around deadline were questionable to someone who thought that they were on the higher percentage lynch candidate. Besides that you seemed ok today, you didn't go hard at me for no answering you on your read questions though when you probably should of pressured the hell out of me at that point.
I appreciate you going back and answering this.
Probably should have but I thought you were trying to get newbies to make reads first so they werent sheeping you then you ended up making a case anyway.
|
Well I was trying to let things develop and some of the scum reads made me laugh pretty hard tbh damdred asked 16-17 questions he's so obvious scum. But the thread was kind of stagnant with no cases so I figured I should push the scummiest person.
What do you think of oats bresh
|
On November 27 2014 14:33 Damdred wrote:
Well I was trying to let things develop and some of the scum reads made me laugh pretty hard tbh damdred asked 16-17 questions he's so obvious scum. But the thread was kind of stagnant with no cases so I figured I should push the scummiest person.
What do you think of oats bresh
MM he has been focused on bats a fair bit but mentions reads on other people every know and then but everything seems to come back to bats for him. I agree with him on bats though and see why he is pushing it and like that he kept pushing it even though no one was really jumping on. I don't like that he wasn't around at EoD because if he has a strong mafia read id think he would try make himself be so he can push his read. This can probably be attributed to time zones though.
So i think he is lleaning town this could be biased because he is also reading bats scum but I am happy to see him as town for now.
The fact that im reading him as town and also reading trefel as town reinforces my feeling that bats is mafia because him and meatpudding were the only ones to not have their votes on Dicksmash at EoD and i think that while possible it is unlikely all three mafia stacked on him.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
