|
On November 25 2014 09:22 Damdred wrote:Show nested quote +On November 25 2014 09:20 sicklucker wrote:On November 25 2014 09:08 Damdred wrote:
SL tell me what you think of Half the Sky.
And since you are so good at reading breske give me a preliminary read (especially since you are fond of fast reads) Like hes the only person in the game ive given a read on yet. Why do you keep asking Because your read is half ass'd and at one point you say that he defends you when he never does and in almost his very next post he says "Oh nvm i'll vote him and keep my eye on him" basically.
Ive given a preliminary read and im still giving it. Hes still mostly null for me but I do find it strange. Infact im trying to question him but your getting in the way...
|
meatpudding we just vote scum we dont policy anything. Someone policy voted me in the final 3 of the last student game and of course they were wrong.
|
Like the post after it doesiny matter. First posts are what matter. Hes questioning why were doing it rather then ignoring it and going with the flow as any mafia would do. Later if he agreed with breske thats not what matters. Its the fact he qeustioned it that I formed my as I said (SLIGHT) town read
|
Ive given my breske read as well. I pretty much just said its weird but hes null . If I wanted to push him id push him. Hes one of the few players I know so I want him to stick around soI can read him more.
|
Do people not know what a slight first reaction read is? Its not an all telling read im going to give alot of impact going forth on. Its the start of day one
|
On November 25 2014 10:01 Damdred wrote:
I'm glad you said that SL, you now have a town lean for me after all of this. But when i ask you for a comprehensive read on breske that you are sure you can give and youdon't i will instantly vote you
Well I basically just repeated things I already said. The fact you didnt see them is the reason I was suspicious
|
Well from what I understand kush is the worst scum player ever and doesint try. And he hasint posted yet so as it stands ya id lynch him.
|
Still haven't heard from alot of people feel free to introduce yourself and hopefully more!
|
To encourage them to post. They have like 3 posts your very intimidating to new players =]
|
Ouch but its early so ill let it slide. Well the idea with the kush policy lynch is more because we can crack him very easy. If we dont crack him we dont vote him
|
On November 25 2014 13:02 batsnacks wrote:
First person to vote LS for suggesting sleep is mafia.
This isint lylo like before so I wont 
|
On November 25 2014 23:20 Half the Sky wrote:
My reads so far...
Breshke - Leaning town, now that I understand his vote to be a joke vote.
sicklucker - Not sure. His subsequent posts were okay, but I still don't understand what he was trying to do with the whole afk thing.
LS, alaka and DSMI - Nulls, couldn't tell either way.
Bats - I don't like the timing of the policy vote, I could understand if it were closer to the deadline but not now. Both him and kush are veterans, and enough veterans in the game to take note if kush had afked more. Vote on Oats looks like retaliation. Grasping for straws?
Oats - Town lean so far.
TLDR: Nothing strong on anyone. The SL AFK and the policy vote timing/explanation are what aren't sitting right with me at the moment.
His vote was not a joke. He just played the I want to get him talking card after I started talking and he looked bad
|
On November 26 2014 01:49 batsnacks wrote:
I don't think LS is mafia based on his posting being highly similar to last game (he was cop)
I agree and one of his posts was really townie that came up i can do more of it when i catch up.
|
On November 25 2014 13:00 LightningStrike wrote:
I just got back from playing Pokemon Trading Card game with some friends and went to a late dinner at Red Robin so sorry about my activity T_T
Breshke just seems to be mad at sicklucker for what happened in our previous game :O
Batsnacks lost his mind or he is scum trying to go after kush but kush didn't post anything just yet so I don't got a read on kush.
Oatsmaster is town in my eyes as he is being very constructive on the agenda for Day 1.
Are we allow to sleep on anyday because I remember in my last game we had slept for 1 day and I wondering if we are allowed to becausee personally I don't think Day 1 lynching is a good idea because of possible afks or just having horrible reads.
Very good observation. The reason im finding breskes vote weird is because he could be mad at me.
Hes pointing out the new players which is a town trait. Mafia would be all over burying them (like they buried Ls on day one in the last game)
|
Him rescinding doesint mean much to me. I defended myself very well and even had a pregame set plan that I pulled. Its more mafia if anything.
|
im saying its a mafia trait to unvote me so fast. A very small one dont take much from it
|
Kush and bats are lovers thats just meta that I kind of agree with. Both are kinda townie to me atm
|
Not sure how I feel about someone whos never played with him making a meta case on him. However hes so town for writing this up. Whats your mafia experience Trfel you said youve played on another site with damd.
|
rsoultin should be are lynch so far
##vote rsoultin
I have another scum read that I wont talk about at this time. I hate the scum reads on Dicksmash Mcironcock of all the new players the one that seems nervous to post his views is rsoultin. I think its a dead giveaway
|
On November 26 2014 08:25 Trfel wrote:
I stated my mafia experience earlier. I haven't played on any other sites, and I've never played with Damdred before.
I'm not saying you guys should agree with me, I'm saying, here's the evidence, and here's what I think of it. Feel free to look up more info by yourself, and reach your own conclusions. I want to know what you guys think, that's why I posted.
I don't feel like you need to play with someone to be able to have some ability to read them. All of the posts are saved... just by reading a game, you can get a good idea for what's going on.
O ok your the most obv town atm. I barely read your post yet ( I will) but the fact you made such a huge post tells me your comfortably town. Im getting the opposite read from rstoulin
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
