Campus Mafia (New/Newish Players Welcome) - Page 118

On October 26 2014 09:23 Superbia wrote:
Some other thoughts:

Both newfriends (FF/Elvis, now Marv) are probably town. Explained Elvis already. FF is being sarcastic and funny. He isn't really doing anything but he also doesn't seem scared of being lynched. Last game I played he was scum and became serious as soon as people (I) were (was) pushing on him.

Damdred is leaning scum for me atm. Only noticed this post:
+ Show Spoiler +
in which it becomes clear he's definitely not scum guys! None of his other posts made it into my (death) note book, which is a bad sign.

Liancourt is also leaning scum for me at the moment. I liked his initial meta-read on storr (it was wrong, but it seemed townie). He then gets townread because he’s happy and carefree and proceeds to do fuck all the rest of the game.
Shit like this also feels scummy to me:
+ Show Spoiler +
Good question, why is rayn being townread by thrawn (drparnassus) and slam? Pressure is being put on Parnassus (lian should be happy) and then he’s like:
+ Show Spoiler +
“Where’s this one afker guys???” Why are you diverting attention when someone is being pressured who you were questioning? Feels scummy and possibly aligns lian with Parnassus.

GlowingBear is leaning town for me. Had some decentish posts. Specifically liked his case on lian.

Kushm4sta is null for me atm. I only recall his short overview (list) post of which the shortness felt townie to me (i.e. mafia would’ve probably put in more effort), but I can’t really recall what was in it.

Holyflare is mafia for me at the moment. I liked his initial reaction to parnassus’ opening post, that’s it. Two posts stood out to me:
+ Show Spoiler +
Feels like a lot of information but is actually a complete air post. Saying literally nothing here, and made me suspicious. Then comes this (le) gem:
+ Show Spoiler +
Absolutely no need to defend FF here. The pressure was mediocre at best at this point in time. Seems like mafia trying to get free townie points here. Town would’ve just asked FF for his points on lian without taking away the pressure. Yeah, he pushed (and voted) on bats early on, but I don’t recall him contributing much to the push during the EoD. Also I would’ve probably bussed badsnacks if I was his partner too.

IamRobik is leaning town to me. Most of his posts feel townie (though different from last game I played with him).

Justanothertownie is slightly leaning town to me. Had a tryhard and pushy opening, followed by some straightforward neutral townposts.

DrParnassus is leaning scum to me. I loved his first post, and don’t recall any of his other posts. Strong opening followed by weak play is probably scum. Also this recent post really ticked me off:
+ Show Spoiler +
This feels like mafia trying to salvage losing a team-mate d1 (i.e. trying to get something positive out of the lynch, which the lynch is already very positive for town is scummy).

On October 09 2014 03:23 Superbia wrote:
I have the ball rolling already dude. We're also not lynching a lurker. They get modkilled or replaced. It's a waste of a lynch.

My circles:
town:
abuse

leaning town:
loaf
fecalfeast
Rad

null:
Elvis!
dusts

scum:
The_Zen_Man
breshke

On November 04 2014 00:37 Superbia wrote:
Ha! You have all underestimated Superbia's Digging Company!

The play is pretty straightforward. Experienced town is never going to take the contract for these reasons:
- If I'm town, I'll be wasting my time tunneling on a townie (from their perspective)
- If I'm mafia, I'll have a great excuse to go hard on them all day.

Scum, however, is more likely to take the contract for the following reasons:
- WIFOM
- I'm not afraid of being watched, I swear!
- Easy fallback on "Wow I can't believe you actually tunneled me, you're dumb as shit"

Since Sentinel is an experienced player (apparently), I'm pretty sure he's mafai here. Him following the badsnacks pressure train (and FF/kelsier's push) on me doesn't help. Why agree and then go against it?

##Vote: [UoN]Sentinel


Some other thoughts:

Batsnacks - I'm okay with bats at the moment. His push on me seemed like the typical "push for info" I expect to see at the start of d1. Leaning town for now.

KelsierSC -


Was an incredibly weak read at best. Feels more like a pocket or possibly (dare I hope) aligned scum. Scumlean on Kelsier. Townpoints to breshke for pinging him out for it. Also does the exact same thing as FF (see below)

Fecalfeast -


Why are you pushing someone for something that hasn't even happened yet? If you were really looking to catch scum you would wait for me to follow up and then evaluate from here. Pushing on someone for something insubstantial is pretty scummy: it's a losing strategy for town, and an easy way to get town-read as scum. Scum-lean on FF.

Breshke - This is a different Breshke from what I'm used to (he's way more proactive than before). His questions are spot on and the mindset behind his posts feels very town. The fact that he's more proactive only adds to to the towniness. Top town at the moment.

Elvis! - Elvis made sense and seems to have the same viewpoint as I would have on my post. Leaning town.

Grackaroni - Defends me, and I'm not sure how I feel about this. On the one hands his arguments are valid and logical, on the other hand, why defend me? Don't feel like the thread was stagnating at that point in time, and there was still information to be gained. Grack, why did you defend me?

Immaterial - Null. Not sure if newbie town or mafai. Sheeps Kelsier, which is horrible. Gets pinged out for faulty logic (which is by extension Kelsier's faulty logic), but keeps his vote on me regardless, which feels a little more like town pressuring than scum sheeping. Would like to see more content from him before I make up my mind (his prose is also pretty decent).

LightningStrike - Leaning mafia. Sheeps the vote for me but doesn't really seem to have a real opinion on the matter. This post screams mafia trying to insert themselves into a push/conversation:



In conclusion: I feel like Sentinel is the most likely hit at the moment, followed by Kelsier and then FF or LightningStrike. At least 2 in those 4.


Need to get opinions/content from the following people:
- Serejai
- Cricketer12
- kushm4sta

On November 12 2014 06:53 Superbia wrote:
If you're already dedicating 2/3 lynches to myself and FF I feel there's a pretty fucking high chance we'll lose the game.

On November 12 2014 06:48 Superbia wrote:
Are you fucking serious rayn? This is what you got out of my filter? That you have no idea where my votes have been or what I have done to get my lynches lynched? Let me spell it out for you:

d1: Was going on Sentinel and my read starts solidying, then I come home during 2nd half of the day to see two cop claims fighting it out.
d2. I want to lynch sent or kelsier. As day goes by it becomes obvious that kelsier needs to die that day or will probably be alive for the rest of the game, so I push hard for kelsier's lynch.
d3: Lynch was really straightforward.

On November 12 2014 06:54 sicklucker wrote:
Rayn do you agree that if im the solo mafia I NEVER kill you and I would kill serejai 10/10?
I feel like you should come out and say that im confirmed town if your voted out because no ones going to listen to me.

THERES NO WAY IN HELL I WOULD NIGHT KILL THE ONLY PERSON KEEPING ME IN THIS GAME.

On November 12 2014 06:59 raynpelikoneet wrote:

Yeah right, this is just what i talked about.

Oh man, you pushed this scum (you are now trying to take some credit of lynching -- apparently) so hard!!!
So hard, everyone must remember how hard you pushed Sentinel as mafia on D1 and D2.

/end sarcasm

no, you didn't push him which to me means you didn't want to lynch him.

On November 12 2014 07:09 Serejai wrote:


And you don't see how this post makes you scummy as shit?

"If rayn dies town then I am 100% confirmed town too because he thought I was town" - WRONG

"if i were mafia I wouldn't kill the guy that thinks im town" - WRONG. You would do exactly this because then nobody would suspect you, since you would also be "confirmed town" and all.

"you should come out and say im confirmed town" - WRONG, because that's not possible for him to do. You will never be confirmed town until you actually flip green, regardless of how many times you make up these random-ass reasons for why you have to be.

On November 12 2014 07:12 sicklucker wrote:


No your scummy as shit for posting that . I used very sensible logic. Ask yourself this If im mafia do I have anychance winning if both you, ff and elvis are tunneling? Nope thats 3 votes I have to kill one of you tonight. Where as rayn is staking his mafia reputation that im town. I would not lynch him as mafier...

On November 12 2014 07:14 Serejai wrote:


But you said yourself that if rayn dies it confirms you as town, so as scum wouldn't you want to be confirmed town? You're contradicting yourself.

On November 12 2014 07:16 Breshke wrote:
Sick lucker let me try run you through this before people get mad

So as mafia you wouldn't kill rayn because he is the only person reading you town.

Therefore if someone else dies it is probably you who is mafia

Therefore as mafia why wouldn't you kill rayn so people don't think you are mafia.

Understand?