Hearthstone Mafia - Page 3

On November 02 2014 04:04 GlowingBear wrote:


^ this.

I'm killing damdred. See you guys in 25 hours.

On November 02 2014 04:24 jaybrundage wrote:

This is the worst post in the thread. Plz grow up.

On November 02 2014 04:53 jaybrundage wrote:
@Dramdred If I read the OP correctly "Each character role will have a predetermined set of spells and abilities that are available for their use. These spells may be revealed at the start of the game or become available at certain points in the game." Everyone will be a blue/have some type of ability. Just cause you used your power and claimed, IT does NOT exempt you from being mafia. So stop mentioning it like it is a good defense.

@VE: In regards to Dramdred, Bad Town or Scum.

The Town case felt pretty heavy-handed. And I'm pretty sure he cleaned up his notes before posting, not that it actually matters.

The use of the power seems normal. As scum or town he felt the thread sentiment going towards his lynch and felt he more time would be helpful so he could insure he wouldn't get lynched. The claim seems pretty clear cut. No clue what the issue is here.

Also I feel like your hung up on that fact that it changes to a majority lynch. I don't see the big deal. Maybe its cause most of the games I have played have been Majority lynch. But your really over reacting to the switch in voting. Why they hell would the town collectively let a No-Lynch happen? Any town worth its salt wouldn't let that shit happen.

We get more time to discuss which is good for town. Although I was looking forward to lynching someone tonite but we have more time to type and we should try to use wisely. [Aside]: And by wisely I mean discuss and try to figure things out and not get tunnel visioned and refuse to consider alternate possibilities /Aside]


I think Dramdred's case will be an important factor. Looking forward to it.

On November 03 2014 01:25 Holyflare wrote:
How can you say he's absolutely town but then want to lynch him if he doesn't do something lol

On November 03 2014 05:05 Seuss wrote:
Hello again.

The timing of Damdred's vote-extension is scummy as hell. Almost immediately after GlowingBear began asserting that he'd caught Damdred in a lie, Damdred breadcrumbed his role and shortly thereafter that Follow the Rules happened. This play screams, "Shit I've been caught, better use my power to save myself." I'd expect a Town player to expend far more effort trying to preserve their useful power than just blow it on themselves the moment they get in trouble.

On that note I'm suspicious of LordTolkien because of his defense of Damdred. I think there's a pretty good that he's scum if Damdred is. At best LordTolkien is oblivious to the scrutiny Damdred was already under, and at worst he's trying to reframe events to make Damdred's desperate act of self-preservation seem Towny.

I'm a little suspicious of Obiwan as well but it would be pretty horrible play for two scum to come out with the same bad/oblivious "what's the scum motivation" defense when there's such an obvious scum motivation.

On November 03 2014 05:05 Seuss wrote:
Hello again.

The timing of Damdred's vote-extension is scummy as hell. Almost immediately after GlowingBear began asserting that he'd caught Damdred in a lie, Damdred breadcrumbed his role and shortly thereafter that Follow the Rules happened. This play screams, "Shit I've been caught, better use my power to save myself." I'd expect a Town player to expend far more effort trying to preserve their useful power than just blow it on themselves the moment they get in trouble.

On that note I'm suspicious of LordTolkien because of his defense of Damdred. I think there's a pretty good that he's scum if Damdred is. At best LordTolkien is oblivious to the scrutiny Damdred was already under, and at worst he's trying to reframe events to make Damdred's desperate act of self-preservation seem Towny.

I'm a little suspicious of Obiwan as well but it would be pretty horrible play for two scum to come out with the same bad/oblivious "what's the scum motivation" defense when there's such an obvious scum motivation.

On November 03 2014 05:39 risk.nuke wrote:
If Viscera actually just activated a double lynch he's going to flip red.

On November 03 2014 05:39 risk.nuke wrote:
If Viscera actually just activated a double lynch he's going to flip red.

On November 03 2014 08:01 Holyflare wrote:
He said he can't play till next cycle so why not lynch the guy that could and has been completely awful? (lt)

On November 03 2014 08:04 risk.nuke wrote:
jrkirby, I came out because I saw something worth commenting on and had time to do it. And I didn't say the ability was scummy, I said the timing and way he used it was scummy because it was being used so sub-optimally.

Viscera, Following the thread is so I'd be aware if anything big happens, It's basically skimming the thread. I haven't had time to look for mafia. I didn't see any danger in myself getting lynched today because it is stupid to lynch someone day1 when he's promised to be active day2. Like that is the optimal mafia agenda. Push the innocent guy as a lurker before he gets a chance to play. If what you say is true, that I'm scum just trying to get away with doing nothing it will be evident day2 and you can lynch me then. I don't understand how you can go like, no, it so SOOOO important to kill me today instead of after I've had a chance to post reads. Your post feel like such bullshit.

On November 03 2014 08:04 risk.nuke wrote:
jrkirby, I came out because I saw something worth commenting on and had time to do it. And I didn't say the ability was scummy, I said the timing and way he used it was scummy because it was being used so sub-optimally.

Viscera, Following the thread is so I'd be aware if anything big happens, It's basically skimming the thread. I haven't had time to look for mafia. I didn't see any danger in myself getting lynched today because it is stupid to lynch someone day1 when he's promised to be active day2. Like that is the optimal mafia agenda. Push the innocent guy as a lurker before he gets a chance to play. If what you say is true, that I'm scum just trying to get away with doing nothing it will be evident day2 and you can lynch me then. I don't understand how you can go like, no, it so SOOOO important to kill me today instead of after I've had a chance to post reads. Your post feel like such bullshit.