Hearthstone Mafia - Page 168

On November 11 2014 16:14 VisceraEyes wrote:
Damdred votes for me. If my tally goes up, lynch Damdred.

On November 11 2014 21:02 Chairman Ray wrote:
I think Damdred is town. He's a towny town if there ever was a town.

Damdred, when you get on gimme a town fistbump!

On November 11 2014 21:49 liancourt wrote:


don't try to misrepresent and twist my words hf. On page 77 slam said the same thing that u tend to misrepresent ppl to ur liking and that was like a breath of fresh air to me and it made me read him as town. I'm agreeing with slam about the mod confirm thing not complaining about it.

scum is damdred ray and jay.

i recall rit talking about jay and saying that his vote on lt was early and not significant at that point and i kinda agree so it could have been a possible bus, but his play so far has been pretty townie the way he is pressuring ppl so i'm really half n half, but through process of elimination hf, rit, me, ve, slam = town, damdred, jay, ray = scum.

On November 11 2014 16:04 ritoky wrote:
Damdred's day 2 misder read condensed:





Summarized: he thinks misder was trying to deflect off LT, thinks town having multiple vote manipulation abilities is imba and can't be town sided (hmmm yours would be the 3rd and 4th), didn't like posting/reads.

Damdred's d3 misder read:



You literally don't question him thoroughly on it at all, you're not confused by the function of the chicken; and you go from him being your top scum read and voting on him to not a mumbling word about him and accepting his claim as fact. Seems like a read progression that may come from a place of more information.

On November 11 2014 15:33 jaybrundage wrote:
What is this lol. Towards the first part of the game I was leaning bad town on you. You did dumb stuff like holding your notes for some dumb reason. Using your power before providing your notes. But whatever. Later on with you egging VE and HF on I began to see you as more of a scum read. But you were not someone I had as my top scum read. I had people that I thought were more scummy and would prefer to lynch over you. Lian was someone that seemed like someone that had gotten no heat. And seemed like scum trying to slip thru the cracks with out providing there own reads. He made that one big post regarding you being a his strongest lynch candidate.

Also Lian was not a weaker read at the time of me voting him. Why the hell do you think I would vote for a weaker read at the beginning of the day. I only changed to Misder who I stated was another scum read of mine previously. As well as me wanting to consolidate to make sure scum couldnt control the lynch as it was very close.


Like VE has been crawling up your ass the whole day. And after scum reading him pretty hard. You then decide because he keeps pushing you that he therefore can not be scum. What the hell is that about. You did the exact same thing with GB. But here is the weird part when you feel that no one is going to lynch VE you back off and say how's hes town. With no other reason besides the fact that you can't lynch him/get him out of your face.

But because I have been reevaluating my reads and thought that perhaps you might not be scum. You turn around and start calling me scum. It feels like you just want to make up reads. You just want to stick a read on someone and don't have any real substance or thought behind your reads.




Between Liancourt and Dramdred I feel like there is one scum. I think I have been wrong about it being Liancourt.
Dramdred 's weird as fuck power on VE in regards to taking away his vote. As well as throwing scum reads on whoever he feels he can get away with it on. Throwing a scum read on me just because I am not pressuring him. WTF is that? His complete backing off of VE for no reason besides the fact that VE wanted to lynch him and he couldn't get a lynch on VE feels so scummy.

VE I got you bro.

##Vote Dramdred

On November 11 2014 16:23 VisceraEyes wrote:
To clarify: if Damdred votes for me and my tally goes up then he lied about the parameters of his power in an attempt to look more townie. There's no reason for him to lie about his power if he's town, and similarly there's no reason for him not to comply with this request if he's town.

Furthermore this test doesn't confirm him the other way either - if he's telling the truth about his power then he could still be mafia, it just means that his power started off easily confirmable and he simply told the truth about it.

This is simply to rule out one really easy way to confirm him as mafia.

On November 12 2014 02:15 Holyflare wrote:
let's just stick to ray for now

On November 11 2014 14:57 Damdred wrote:
I thought you were reevaluating this tunnel VE.

I've thought about it, I've always liked crs slot for scum and if you compare what's he's doing here to number mafia its so drastically different. He's almost 100% scum.

I like lian as mafia as well for reasons before

I don't know though if slam or jay is the last I would rather wait to lynch them , but you raise great points against slam