|
Like
On October 18 2014 02:03 kushm4sta wrote:
do you have the flu?
do you work full time?
do you go to school full time for chemical engineering and get fuck tons of homework?
do you have a girlfriend?
yes to all those questions for me. so i dont think your business can compete with mine.
And you were mafia.
So I'm lynching you gladly 
|
Why nobody plays when I can play  ((
|
On October 24 2014 22:34 justanothertownie wrote:
I am here from time to time. Why don't you go into more detail about your HF observation for example.
Why him, specifically?
|
On October 24 2014 21:00 justanothertownie wrote:Show nested quote +On October 24 2014 11:54 GlowingBear wrote:On October 24 2014 11:43 Holyflare wrote:On October 24 2014 11:37 GlowingBear wrote:On October 24 2014 11:35 Holyflare wrote:On October 24 2014 11:32 GlowingBear wrote:On October 24 2014 11:29 Holyflare wrote:On October 24 2014 11:24 GlowingBear wrote:On October 24 2014 10:59 Holyflare wrote:On October 24 2014 10:56 GlowingBear wrote:
[quote]
20 pages of thread and yes, I have a scumread on lian. The strongest, but not strong.
So you didn't had any reads at page 20? You think that it's impossible? I think it's entirely strange that the part I highlighted in red shows that you think that nobody has done anything towny at all yet and how it sucks but instead of checking if that's actually true and maybe re-evaluating that by actually reading the whole game and MAYBE changing your mind on your scum read on lian who you don't even know if he shits town rainbows since page 19 you decide to say that you're going to make a full blown case on him. Without reading the rest of the game. That's the strangest thing i've seen in a while. I was talking about the game until the page I was at. I'm sorry I had opinions on page 20 what use is a read up to page 20 when there's 20+ more pages to read and everything could have changed? It just screams of wanting to appear to contribute and get post count up because you're afraid of having an empty filter with no contributions There's a lot of content on 20 pages HF. I can give reads that nobody gave yet and it will also help you reading me. There's more content in 40 pages that would be more than enough to COMPLETELY change any read you have up on it's head, I don't even know why you're contesting this at all. You're literally working with 50% information and saying that it's better than 100%. If you had the same reads after you read all the game I wouldn't even be bringing this up but you're being stubborn on a point which is a no brainer. Ok HF, from the case I posted, what's different? I literally just explained it to you, he's baiting people for reactions and trying to get them to converse about him and made that list post about why he's playing a bit differently from last game where he was trying hard and got shot by the vig. He's disproved half your case. Like 50% of your case is that he's not playing how he explained but when does anyone ever trust self meta ever? Why does that make him mafia in the slightest, what stops it being someone disgruntled from being scum read why is it a mafia trait to be wrong about yourself!??!?! Like I said the only relevant part was that he hasn't posted his conclusions from reactions (I haven't even really checked if he actually has) but even then I've seen plenty of townies do the same thing and I actually even town read him for other things/not giving a crap about things sooo there's that too Best way to play as town right? Acting scummy to get people talking and not actually contributing to the thread. That's the thing, HF. He isn't bringing his conclusions regarding reactions. Any alignment can do that. And if he is town, he is playing anti town because he is making us wasting our time talking about him. The thing is - we are not lynching anti town players. We are lynching scummy players. Show nested quote +On October 24 2014 12:52 IAmRobik wrote:Controversial read of the game: GB is town + Show Spoiler +Based solely on the fact that he gave himself 3-4 outs to go to sleep and he continued to converse with people even though he coulda just peaced out That's not a towntell. I did that as mafia before.
Why do you think lian is town?
|
Ok, I'm on the phone so it will be hard to quote, but:
Around page five of HF's filter, he says the thread should let FF retreat and comeback later with more consolidated reads.
Then FF comes back around page 7 and HF ignores him, putting him on a list and not talking about him at all. Votes for batsnacks. Then, he is asked to talk about FF and all he says is that, based on meta, FF looks genuine so he is not concerned with him. Why putting him on a possible lynch lost if he is not concerned with him? Or, is FF's meta really I fixative in a way that you can not be concerned with him?
Now, he is voting for batsnacks, but completely drops the push on bats to argue with Rayn. But he is not completely OMGUSing. He does not assume, explicitly, that Rayn is mafia. He just says Rayn might be trolling.
You see, HF is not following his reads. He just call people out for bad logic but doesn't really pushes anyone. He even dislocate threads direction out of FF who is acting weird, for no apparent reason. Says he isn't concerned with ff but keeps him in a list of possible lynches
|
On October 24 2014 23:02 justanothertownie wrote:
I think the filter page numbers you just gave are off?!
I think I like what you wrote though. There were some HF posts recently that I really disliked too and that is generally a very bad sign.
I read his filter and posted. I didn't have the page numbers in mind, just the facts.
|
On October 24 2014 13:16 Holyflare wrote:
i mean i read all his long post and i don't particularly see the total similarities between fecal in that game and this one but his other reads seem legitimate (from someone looking analytically at the game rather than meta/feelings of individual posts) and he has a lengthy posting style in his newbie which i think would be pretty hard to keep up with if he's mafia this game so much so that i'm not too worried about him at the moment
Legitimate, genuine... Whatever you may call it
|
Like... "It's really hard to keep up as mafia" sounds like "probably town". But he is still on your list, so...
|
Robik, what do you think of FF?
|
On October 24 2014 23:17 IAmRobik wrote:Is this a comment on my play in general or my play this game? Or is this a comment on me as a person?
In general.
I find you arrogant, but funny.
I just like to diss you
|
On October 24 2014 23:09 IAmRobik wrote:
Just finished reading pg 43. I'm down to kill rayn. He's playing this game at the brain capacity of an infant and it's really not even fun having him in games anymore. I don't know why he even signs up.
W/R/T the question he asked me...no?
Can you break down that read on Rayn a little bit more?
|
On October 24 2014 23:06 GlowingBear wrote:Show nested quote +On October 24 2014 13:16 Holyflare wrote:
i mean i read all his long post and i don't particularly see the total similarities between fecal in that game and this one but his other reads seem legitimate (from someone looking analytically at the game rather than meta/feelings of individual posts) and he has a lengthy posting style in his newbie which i think would be pretty hard to keep up with if he's mafia this game so much so that i'm not too worried about him at the moment Legitimate, genuine... Whatever you may call it
Address to this, HF.
I've just brought a post of you calling his reads legitimate and implying that he is town, and yet he was constantly on your lynch list. He also posted nothing different for you to change your read on him, which is proven by the fact that you didn't even tried to reconsider him later when you promised to.
|
JAT I'm getting inclined to lynch HF today.
We have enough reasons to lynch him and his lynch will be pretty informative regarding people's alignment.
Also, it would give time to Rayn and kush to step up in the thread. If specially kush doesn't try hard, he is probably mafia.
|
A vote count would be appreciated so we can do a better analysis
|
On October 24 2014 23:38 justanothertownie wrote:
Dude, there are like 3 people voting. You should be able to analyse that.
It's still easier to do with a vote count log
|
On October 24 2014 23:39 justanothertownie wrote:
Let's see where this leads us.
##Vote: Holyflare
Thanks.
##Vote: Holyflare
|
On October 24 2014 23:39 IAmRobik wrote:I don't know what to think of him yet. He doesn't seem to have the pop that he had game 1 and I think I commented on his early mention of my name as something I found odd/weird Show nested quote +On October 24 2014 23:20 GlowingBear wrote:On October 24 2014 23:17 IAmRobik wrote:On October 24 2014 21:49 GlowingBear wrote:
Robik sucks. Is this a comment on my play in general or my play this game? Or is this a comment on me as a person? In general. I find you arrogant, but funny. I just like to diss you What does this have to do with me sucking? I haven't been arrogant this game at all. In fact, quite the opposite. You even wanted to lynch me for not being arrogant at some point. Show nested quote +On October 24 2014 23:21 GlowingBear wrote:On October 24 2014 23:09 IAmRobik wrote:
Just finished reading pg 43. I'm down to kill rayn. He's playing this game at the brain capacity of an infant and it's really not even fun having him in games anymore. I don't know why he even signs up.
W/R/T the question he asked me...no? Can you break down that read on Rayn a little bit more? There's nothing to break down. Rayn has gotten progressively more annoying to play with. His attitude towards the game has gotten worse. He doesn't try as hard. He thinks he's hot shit and always blames everyone else for everything, even when he's the one instigating or the one not playing or the one who playing poorly. I signed up after I saw that neither he nor obiwan were playing and then I got tarped. The reason I brought up pg 43 is becauseh e was having his back and forth with HF there and I just got really annoyed reading it. He hasn't done anything all game. He hasn't given reads and then sits there and says that he has. Read his town games from 1yr ago and read his games now. I don't know if he's town or scum, but regardless, his pomposity and his arrogance and his lack of care lead me to believe that I'd rather have him out of the game. There's potential that he's town, but he could very well be scum too.
Ok, so you don't have any idea of rayn's alignment. Just want to lynch him out of spite.
So, who's scum?
|
LOL there is no way that JAT is scum in this game. We are on the same page.
|
Here is the problem, Robik: in this game, we have 3 or 4 people lurking (if you believe thrawn is): kush, Elvis, Rayn and thrawn.
Kush promised he was going to blow the thread with towniness, but he didn't . He brought the excuse that he is busy, but he did the same last game he was scum. He also was active. He was only responding when he was cited, which means he is reading the thread but not contributing.
Elvis has 3 posts. In one, he says FF and lian looks bad for terrible, terrible reasons. He also said I and thrawn looks bad and that he was going to tell us why later, but never did.
Rayn came to the thread, said he was busy, pointed out things, threw weird town reads and leader out.
I have nothing memorable from thrawn, which is really bad for him. I have to dive him.
So, between these four , you're trying to lynch Rayn, the only guy that said he was busy. And you're trying to lynch him based mostly on inactivity.
Why not considering the others?
|
Oh god thrawn's filter is also so bad...
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
