|
On September 28 2014 09:42 GlowingBear wrote:Show nested quote +On September 28 2014 09:41 VisceraEyes wrote:On September 28 2014 09:36 Chairman Ray wrote:On September 28 2014 09:33 VisceraEyes wrote:On September 28 2014 09:32 Chairman Ray wrote:On September 28 2014 09:26 VisceraEyes wrote: I wasn't, you were. And I didn't claim immediately because I wanted to see what happened.
So unless someone is trolling we have 4 OV claims and 1 Boxer claim, making FF confirmed town this game. If you're the REAL Boxer, you need to stand up and say something now or you'll be instantly lynched later in the day if you try and claim. Unless I missed something, your claim came 2 posts after mine. But regardless, what do you make of what happened? I'm definitely OV. Not fake claiming this time. GB is acting anti-town and now there's 1 more between the OV's. Right now I'm looking at you because you tried to fake-claim Boxer. Why did you try and fake-claim Boxer? My plan was to claim the opposite role if I rolled town. If I claimed boxer and there was only one other boxer claim, then we have a confirmed town. FF is confirmed town now. Okay, so what was your plan if you rolled Boxer? Because if you claim OV then there are two other OV's out there and NO one is confirmed because one of the anti-town claimed your role, and presumably the other one claims OV. Like....I'm not buying this as a "premeditated plan" at all. And his claim was after FF's, so, harder to believe it was premeditated... Well, his claim is that he was planning on claiming the opposite town role before the game started or whatever, so order of claims doesn't really matter in this situation.
|
On September 28 2014 10:33 Fecalfeast wrote: OK I understand why I'm an idiot now. I think CR is jester. He's trying to wiggle out of his counterclaim a little too obviously I think. I mean if he said "I planned to claim boxer only if I rolled OV/VT" I would believe him but "I planned to claim the opposite town role" sounds hastily typed out in a panic. I still think CR is non-town but I think he is jester. I don't understand what makes him the Jester over mafia in this case. For one, if he's trying to get lynched, then why not stick with the claim and then just afk? Backing out of it seems more like someone who's afraid they might get lynched to me than someone who's actively trying to get lynched as a part of their wincon.
|
Like, I frankly my gut tells me that CR is actually town here. The move doesn't make sense from either perspective honestly - if he's mafia then he KNOWS, KNOWS FOR A FACT that a counterclaim is coming. It's not like, a chance or whatever, this is an open setup with all roles known. If CR is mafia then he knows for a fact that the REAL Boxer IS going to counterclaim him. It's much easier for me to believe that he's town and made a plan to confirm a townie than it is for me to believe that he's mafia and claimed a role he KNOWS is going to be counterclaimed BY MECHANICS only to back off it.
That leaves him as either townie or Jester, and as I said, I don't know that I believe he does that as Jester. It's possible, I'm just skeptical.
|
On September 28 2014 10:48 Fecalfeast wrote:Show nested quote +On September 28 2014 10:36 GlowingBear wrote:On September 28 2014 10:33 Fecalfeast wrote: OK I understand why I'm an idiot now. I think CR is jester. He's trying to wiggle out of his counterclaim a little too obviously I think. I mean if he said "I planned to claim boxer only if I rolled OV/VT" I would believe him but "I planned to claim the opposite town role" sounds hastily typed out in a panic. I still think CR is non-town but I think he is jester. ... What? I need to take a time from this game. I'm going to drink like hell and I am completely confused. Can't even think right now. My post is WIFOM for certain but I am saying: as far as i can tell, CR is good enough to know what he is typing out when he types it out. Typing "I planned to claim boxer if I rolled VT" eliminates posts like: Show nested quote +On September 28 2014 09:41 VisceraEyes wrote:On September 28 2014 09:36 Chairman Ray wrote:On September 28 2014 09:33 VisceraEyes wrote:On September 28 2014 09:32 Chairman Ray wrote:On September 28 2014 09:26 VisceraEyes wrote: I wasn't, you were. And I didn't claim immediately because I wanted to see what happened.
So unless someone is trolling we have 4 OV claims and 1 Boxer claim, making FF confirmed town this game. If you're the REAL Boxer, you need to stand up and say something now or you'll be instantly lynched later in the day if you try and claim. Unless I missed something, your claim came 2 posts after mine. But regardless, what do you make of what happened? I'm definitely OV. Not fake claiming this time. GB is acting anti-town and now there's 1 more between the OV's. Right now I'm looking at you because you tried to fake-claim Boxer. Why did you try and fake-claim Boxer? My plan was to claim the opposite role if I rolled town. If I claimed boxer and there was only one other boxer claim, then we have a confirmed town. FF is confirmed town now. Okay, so what was your plan if you rolled Boxer? Because if you claim OV then there are two other OV's out there and NO one is confirmed because one of the anti-town claimed your role, and presumably the other one claims OV. Like....I'm not buying this as a "premeditated plan" at all. So, assuming CR understand the words he is typing, he intentionally left ambiguous language in his post then LEFT THE THREAD so we can stew on it. Jester. Yeah I'm not discounting the possibility.
What do you think about GlowingBear? Like, he said he was so confused earlier...why? What's confusing? There are five players and 5 claims. 2 people are lying. This is the game we signed up for. There's literally nothing confusing about what has happened so far.
|
Especially since when he came in everything I was saying was just so obvious that I had to be mafia. Like, from the looks of things he's got the game all figured out and the claims shouldn't have done anything to change that unless I'm missing something. How does he go from having the game figured out in the first five minutes to being so confused that he has to drown his confusion and tell us all about how confused he is?
|
On September 28 2014 10:53 Fecalfeast wrote: Exactly. I honestly was chalking it up to english as a second language and being drunk but he said he is just going to get drunk now so I think he is just not reading the thread properly. I think GB is scummier than everyone but CR. Well you and me both - but frankly I don't think there's much scummy in what CR is doing. Suboptimal for town sure, antitown flavored maybe, but SCUMMY? Meeehhhh...not with GB in the game. In my opinion anyway.
|
I was really confused by that post but forgot about it while he was here data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/77e98/77e98be67f263e78995d632fb850d627ce97d99f" alt=""
Thx for reminding me, I hope he answers you when he gets back LOL
|
On September 28 2014 11:03 GlowingBear wrote: VE you're assuming CR's plan is legit and you're again working with the hypothesis where he claimed before FF. why are you so sure his plan is legit?
I thought I had the game close to be figured out, but CR's unclaim just messed everything up. I'm scum for getting things confused? Lol VE. You can do better than that, regardless alignments I'm not assuming his "plan" is legit, in fact I'm one of the first who doesn't buy his explanation. I gave explicit reasoning as to why I think he's not mafia doing what he's doing, so that leaves me with town or Jester and I think town is more likely. I'm not assuming his plan is legit, and I STILL don't give a shit who claimed first.
I never said you're scum for getting things confused. I'm saying it didn't take much for you to "figure out" the game in the first place. So why when CLARITY is brought to the thread in the form of CR UNCLAIMING Boxer and making FF CONFIRMED TOWN, why are you confused then? It doesn't make any sense from the standpoint of a townie processing new information and making new conclusions. It makes sense from a perspective of a mafia who's just saying shit to try and appear active. So I think you're mafia. I never said anything about you being mafia "because you got things confused".
Like if you're town you really need to take a step back, realize that I'm town, and try and work with me - because this whole business of you just lol'ing everything I say and calling all of my contributions fluff and you setting up strawmen IS going to get you killed.
|
On September 28 2014 19:52 Chairman Ray wrote:Show nested quote +On September 28 2014 09:26 VisceraEyes wrote: I wasn't, you were. And I didn't claim immediately because I wanted to see what happened.
So unless someone is trolling we have 4 OV claims and 1 Boxer claim, making FF confirmed town this game. If you're the REAL Boxer, you need to stand up and say something now or you'll be instantly lynched later in the day if you try and claim. VE, can you explain this statement? I wanted to see who claimed what. From my perspective, I'm going to come from the group that is most claimed (OV/VT) so it doesn't matter when I claim. Besides me, at least one and probably 2 others were going to claim OV, I didn't feel the need to claim immediately.
|
Like you have to understand that order of claims is NOT important here. Why? Because from the beginning of the game, the two anti-town ARE GOING to fake-claim. Like, it's not just a possibility, that's a FUNCTION of the setup. So we KNOW at least TWO people are going to fake-claim.
|
And GB you're still saying that "the game is solved" and that "VE is mafia?"
##Vote: GlowingBear
That's one. I need the other two townies onboard.
|
I can't believe this setup will finish without anyone claiming mafia. I'm SO disappointed.
|
Like if anything at all, I'd say people who were QUICK to claim are more suspicious. Do you not get why I say that?
|
Ray I'm talkin to you bud, I need you in here to talk to me so we can vote for GB and win.
|
Fecal I'm talkin to you bud, let's do this. GB is the mafia and Damdred is the Jester. For the win.
|
On September 28 2014 19:41 Chairman Ray wrote:Show nested quote +On September 28 2014 10:54 VisceraEyes wrote:On September 28 2014 10:53 Fecalfeast wrote: Exactly. I honestly was chalking it up to english as a second language and being drunk but he said he is just going to get drunk now so I think he is just not reading the thread properly. I think GB is scummier than everyone but CR. Well you and me both - but frankly I don't think there's much scummy in what CR is doing. Suboptimal for town sure, antitown flavored maybe, but SCUMMY? Meeehhhh...not with GB in the game. In my opinion anyway. If you think what I did was suboptimal for town, then tell me one harm that it did. It put doubt in others' minds about YOUR alignment, for one. If you're town then that's suboptimal.
I don't care. I literally was defending you from Fecal anyway.
|
On September 29 2014 00:30 Damdred wrote: As much as it pains me I'm not the jester just oil and vinegar Why would it pain you that you're not the jester?
|
Further, if you're town then vote for GB. Unless you think HE'S the Jester, which isn't outside the realm of possibility.
|
On September 29 2014 01:10 GlowingBear wrote: LOL I challenge you to say what is scummy in me. I'm tired of people looking at my clear town play and say I'm scum.
Damdred, you have to tell me what am I doing that looks so scum. VE if you intentionally dropped your vote on me you're clearly not caring for the lynch. We have a lot of time to decide who is who, and you were rushing things.
If you didn't vote on the vote thread intentionally, you could be trying to get reaction, which I must say that felt townie.
Did you really try to vote me? You tell me I'm rushing things when you're coming into the thread immediately upon starting saying "Game solved, vote VE and win GG"? Like, really?
|
On September 29 2014 05:23 Chairman Ray wrote:Show nested quote +On September 29 2014 00:02 VisceraEyes wrote:On September 28 2014 19:52 Chairman Ray wrote:On September 28 2014 09:26 VisceraEyes wrote: I wasn't, you were. And I didn't claim immediately because I wanted to see what happened.
So unless someone is trolling we have 4 OV claims and 1 Boxer claim, making FF confirmed town this game. If you're the REAL Boxer, you need to stand up and say something now or you'll be instantly lynched later in the day if you try and claim. VE, can you explain this statement? I wanted to see who claimed what. From my perspective, I'm going to come from the group that is most claimed (OV/VT) so it doesn't matter when I claim. Besides me, at least one and probably 2 others were going to claim OV, I didn't feel the need to claim immediately. Show nested quote +On September 29 2014 00:04 VisceraEyes wrote: Like you have to understand that order of claims is NOT important here. Why? Because from the beginning of the game, the two anti-town ARE GOING to fake-claim. Like, it's not just a possibility, that's a FUNCTION of the setup. So we KNOW at least TWO people are going to fake-claim. That's the thing I don't understand. You feel that order of claims is not important, but you also intentionally withheld your claim. That's a contradiction. It's not - I didn't want to see the claims to get their order, I wanted to see under what circumstances people claimed and how people reacted to the claims, and finally how people reacted to MY claim. It has nothing to do with the order, and it's not a contradiction.
|
|
|
|