EPTStill reading but I'll give some input once I've caught up.
2p2 Vanilla Werewolf 13er - Page 4
| Forum Index > TL Mafia |
|
SkyDragon
United Kingdom142 Posts
Still reading but I'll give some input once I've caught up. | ||
|
SkyDragon
United Kingdom142 Posts
- Me, GB and Palmar were scum - GB turned out to be Town - I know I'm Town In my view, Palmar is probably Town as well then because Killing has talked rubbish from his very first post by making silly conclusions based on flimsy evidence. | ||
|
SkyDragon
United Kingdom142 Posts
That made me smile. Thanks. | ||
|
SkyDragon
United Kingdom142 Posts
| ||
|
SkyDragon
United Kingdom142 Posts
| ||
|
SkyDragon
United Kingdom142 Posts
Killing claims to be Seer and calls Bats Green. Also says that he has a Red Check. Now, I'm not familiar with this strange terminology but I'm assuming that he means he knows who one Wolf is. So who is it? And why are you dodging the issue? Also, why on Earth would a Seer reveal themselves as Seer at this stage unless they're retarded or Mafia? | ||
|
SkyDragon
United Kingdom142 Posts
| ||
|
SkyDragon
United Kingdom142 Posts
| ||
|
SkyDragon
United Kingdom142 Posts
- Killing really is Seer, really did see Bats as Green and really does know who one Wolf is. - Killing isn't Seer and is just goofing around - Killing is Mafia and trying to get the real Seer to reveal themselves 1. If Killing really is the Seer, then it was a terrible move by him since Mafia will just kill him tonight. Why even bother to reveal when you only know who one Wolf is? And why keep that one Wolf secret when we could all give valid input on who all 3 members are? It just doesn't make sense at all and I think he's lying. 2. If Killing is goofing around, what is the point? Why risk getting killed off by Mafia? No information would be extracted from doing something like this. 3. Pretending to be Seer and pointing random fingers could possibly get the real Seer to reveal themselves. If nothing else, the Seer would probably spy Killing tonight, confirm he's Wolf and try and make an attempt to disseminate that information to the rest of us tomorrow. Personally, I'm strongly leaning in favor of 3. If he really is a Wolf, that limits the potential number of other Wolves because he has raised suspicion or tried lynching a number of people so far: - FecalFeast - SkyDragon - Batsnacks - Palmar - JAT - HF HaruRH voted to lynch Killing earlier so I'm going to assume that he/she's not Mafia. That leaves: - Storr - Killing - Obi - Superbia I don't know if my analysis is correct, but I believe the 3 Mafia members to be in the group of Storr, Killing, Obi and/or Superbia. | ||
|
SkyDragon
United Kingdom142 Posts
| ||
|
SkyDragon
United Kingdom142 Posts
| ||
|
SkyDragon
United Kingdom142 Posts
| ||
|
SkyDragon
United Kingdom142 Posts
But go ahead and lynch me. I've only ever given GB a somewhat free pass whilst saying that I'm suspicious of everyone else (GB, who turned out to be a Villager when most people insisted that he was scum) - If that makes me scum, then whatever. Just goes to show that almost everyone's readings and analysis in this game is garbage. | ||
|
SkyDragon
United Kingdom142 Posts
On September 28 2014 22:08 Holyflare wrote: and if storr turns out to be town then are you willing to admit your analysis is also garbage??? Of course! I'm not some person who thinks his analysis is perfect or anything. I'm just getting a little annoyed that Hopeless, a Villager, got lynched on d1 (Because it turned out most of us were wrong) then GB was also killed off (Another Villager). That leaves 8 Town and 3 Mafia. Lynch me, Mafia kills another tonight and that leaves 6 Town and 3 Mafia at start of d3. It's hard not to get a little frustrated. Pretty much gg by d4. | ||
|
SkyDragon
United Kingdom142 Posts
On d1, he knew that Hopeless is Villager, and his posts seem to tally up with that since he defends Hopeless and calls him Town at every opportunity. He also puts him in the 'Town Circle'. On September 26 2014 08:21 Killing wrote: Yolo read off of one post, although I like what else he has said. He's my weakest town atm but at least when I read his posts I thought he was town. On September 26 2014 23:26 Killing wrote: -PALMAR FUCKING MAD THAT HIS TEAM IS LOSING SO HE'S TRYING TO MAKE A CASE ON HOPELESS. I also think he's mad that my town circle is god tier amazing so he's trying to lynch me. When I roll town, I just assume everything I'm doing is right so when people go against me, I'm always highly suspicious that I'm just about to truck mafia and they are getting mad at about it. -I don't know if you guys get mad when vts tell the seer who they think they should check but I think palmar is a really great check. He had unsubstantiated reads at the start of the day who ended up being scum read and then he backed off of them and I believe that now he's trying to start a BW onto hopeless when his partners are under fire. Other than that, I also think GB would be a good check. A lot of people are trying to kill him ( including myself), if he flips mafia then good stuff and if he flips town, I think that's also good info. IN B4 PALMAR STARTS YELLING AT ME great stuff can't wait Updated Reads: Town -Storr -HF -Haru -Obi -SuperBia -Hopeless (u mad palmar??????) On September 27 2014 05:18 Killing wrote: I don't correlate activity with alignment. If someone makes 3 posts and I find the posts townie, I call them town. I believe hopeless is town. In response to the vote train on Hopeless and he probably didn't want to make it obvious that he was Seer. On September 27 2014 09:51 Killing wrote: HOPELESS BW IS FUCKING BAD PLEASE ALL OFF On September 27 2014 09:57 Killing wrote: But for serious, this is a shit vote At this stage, Hopeless was lynched and Killing had already spied on Bats to confirm him as Villager: On September 28 2014 00:46 Killing wrote: Me and snatbacks vs the world I think he just started getting irritated with the accusations of being scum: On September 28 2014 05:39 Killing wrote: Can you confirm your only reason you think I'm scum is "You came in 5 minutes before deadline shitting on the lynch and were way too sure that hopeless would flip town" On September 28 2014 05:45 Killing wrote: Meh probably shoulda tried harder but it was pretty impossible so I didn't bother. That's still a terrible reason for scum reading me. So in the heat of the moment, claimed Seer to put an end to the debate. On September 28 2014 05:47 Killing wrote: GONNA BE A PRETTY FUCKING BAD REASON WHEN I CLAIM SEER On September 28 2014 05:52 Killing wrote: I'm claiming. I have a red check, I just wanted to see if I could kill the person today without outing but it seems it's a no go. I think the team is: SkyDragon, Red Check and a random third. Still think it was a terrible move on his part. The lie about a Red Check made it look even worse for him. | ||
|
SkyDragon
United Kingdom142 Posts
On September 28 2014 23:43 ObiWanShinobi wrote: Can also see this wagon happening. HF/others have already pointed out a bunch of problem posts, but another thing I didn't like about him: http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/467273-2p2-vanilla-werewolf-13er?page=66#1305 He drops a bunch of names based on GB's raising suspicion of people (ie nonreasons), and follows it up with generic advice like "if Killing claimed Seer, here are some reasons why he would have claimed Seer." It's an inherently blendy post and it stinks. If you had read that comment properly, you'd have noticed that those people are only suspects were Killing actually Mafia. | ||
|
SkyDragon
United Kingdom142 Posts
| ||
|
SkyDragon
United Kingdom142 Posts
On September 28 2014 23:31 justanothertownie wrote: Ok, but I would like to know who you would vote right now. Musing about Killing and/or his alignment is not productive right now. Well, if you really want to know, just from seeing your filter, I'd vote for you to be lynched. All you've done since the start of d1 is whine, complain and point fingers at others. You haven't really contributed anything at all but have talked enough to make it appear as if you have. Neither have you pushed anyone yourself except those who are being pushed by someone else anyway (You seem more than happy to jump on the bandwagon) and haven't said anything original at all. I'm starting to think that you're scum. | ||
|
SkyDragon
United Kingdom142 Posts
To other Townies (This isn't directed at the clueless ones voting to lynch me), make sure you look at who jumped on the "SkyDragon lynch" train. Not necessarily who started the train (Because it could've been clueless Townies starting it) but those who jumped on board and made it seem as though they agree with the reasons. After all, Mafia has no reason to start vote trains on anyone and expose themselves like that. - JAT hasn't really done much all game in my view - Storr has been suspicious to me since the start of the game - Obi hasn't really done much either and what I said about JAT in a previous post about an hour or two ago, you can probably apply to this guy as well - Just can't seem to accept Haru's excuse for the blue/green Villager stuff. I thought I had but I haven't. JAT, Storr, Obi and Haru would be the ones I'd keep my eyes on. | ||
|
SkyDragon
United Kingdom142 Posts
| ||
| ||
