On September 08 2014 14:43 ritoky wrote:
EVERYONE needs to give an opinion on this since it was NOT something decided collectively. IF YOU DO NOT I WILL PUSH YOU WITH THE WRATH OF TOWN JESUS:

Koshi: hit or miss? why?

Waste of time

geript

10024 Posts

September 08 2014 06:52 GMT

#1039

On September 08 2014 14:39 Sylencia wrote:
yam would you consider Haru town for the fact he didn't play to the fact he could've fake CC'd Martyr as scum since he caught on to the fact I suspected he was the martyr? It would've had a fair chance of working ocnsidering it was goobly who was the actual martyr and a lot of us were quite suspicious of goobly until he dropped the role bomb

This is a super convoluted argument. I'm ignoring yam's read on you from now on.

geript

10024 Posts

September 08 2014 07:05 GMT

#1042

HaruRH/Damdred. They're both conf mafia.
Look at Damdred's other games. He's forming reads exceptionally differently than he has as town. He's also less active. He's also more idk polarized. That's harder to explain but I'll try. There's less confidence (less wishy washy than he is as town) and more surety. It looks like he's saying things more so to make a point than to drive discussion (which is a theme I see in his town games). There's also fewer recurring themes or ideas that he latches onto.

I'll vote for either of these two today.

geript

10024 Posts

September 08 2014 07:07 GMT

#1043

Fwiw HaruRH and Oats are not very likely to be mafia. HaruRH continuing to bitch about being caught. So noted.

geript

10024 Posts

September 08 2014 14:52 GMT

#1066

On September 08 2014 16:07 geript wrote:
Fwiw HaruRH and Oats are not very likely to be mafia together. HaruRH continuing to bitch about being caught. So noted.

Fixed

geript

10024 Posts

September 08 2014 14:55 GMT

#1068

On September 08 2014 19:02 raynpelikoneet wrote:

Show nested quote +

geript you are saying here mafia is in Sloosh/Damdred/Haru/Oats.
What has changed?

You are now calling at least one of Oats/Haru town (or both?). Do you still think Sloosh is mafia and if so why are you not voting for him?

Look at HaruRH's reaction to Oats. No way that's a scum on scum reaction. Ergo at least one is town. Sloosh could be mafia. It's not where I'm currently leaning but it's possible.

geript

10024 Posts

September 08 2014 15:00 GMT

#1069

On September 08 2014 23:54 IAmRobik wrote:
Also, geript and rayn bitching about me getting the grail is laughable. If they're town and wanna take control, I'm not stopping them. I'm 2 votes with 11 people in the game. Theoretically they could potentially get me lynched even with my two votes, but that would be super bad and super dumb since I'm town.

Anyone bitching about me being useless or about how they're upset that I have the grail looks really scummy

If you keep on calling yourself town, maybe everyone will believe it.

geript

10024 Posts

September 08 2014 15:02 GMT

#1070

On September 08 2014 23:01 IAmRobik wrote:
EVERYONE NEEDS TO MAKE AT LEAST ONE POST ABOUT KOSHI SAYING IF IT WAS A HIT OR MISS AND WHY

Please continue to waste everyone's time.

geript

10024 Posts

September 08 2014 15:49 GMT

#1073

Robik, HaruRH, Damdred
Game solved.

geript

10024 Posts

September 08 2014 16:09 GMT

#1076

Didn't do yours in red. Mine is clearly the correct one then.

geript

10024 Posts

September 08 2014 16:10 GMT

#1078

On September 09 2014 01:08 IAmRobik wrote:

Show nested quote +

Then vote me you lil bitch.

I don't care which of you three gets lynched today.

geript

10024 Posts

September 08 2014 16:12 GMT

#1080

On September 09 2014 01:09 IAmRobik wrote:

Show nested quote +

If you think I'm scum, you should 100% be voting me over anyone else since I have 2 votes. Man the fuck up and give an actual accusation besides "well he did something that I did in a scum game once" LOL

You're such trash

I'm sorry I can't hear you over the sound of how awesome I am.

geript

10024 Posts

September 08 2014 16:14 GMT

#1082

On September 09 2014 01:11 IAmRobik wrote:

Show nested quote +

You should care, for the exact reason that I gave.

If you're going to call me mafia, I want a real fucking accusation. Then I'm gonna take your meta cock and shove it in your ear.

Nah. Because even if that's true I'd only have to convince one of two or three people. Votes are rather irrelevant in this setup.

geript

10024 Posts

September 08 2014 16:34 GMT

#1084

On September 09 2014 01:19 IAmRobik wrote:
if votes are irrelevant, why are you spending 5 pages bitching about me having the grail? You're being a huge fucking hypocrite.

Because shit like that goes to your head and makes you think you have a big peepee.

geript

10024 Posts

September 08 2014 16:50 GMT

#1090

On September 09 2014 01:41 IAmRobik wrote:
In fact, that statement makes me town. I wouldn't need a "big peepee" as scum.

False.

But please continue on explaining how not reading filters and waiting for other people to make cases makes you town. Also please expound on the numerous ways in which you have acted which in no way you could have done as mafia. Also, please explain how I have at least 4 games experience with you doing this exact thing and having done it as mafia but of course you're town this game. You see, I'm not arguing with you because there's no point. Any three of you will do. I don't care if we lynch the prick with 2 votes, the prick who's done nothing but bitch about how people who are calling him mafia are wrong, or the prick who's just sliding by. Makes no difference.

geript

10024 Posts

September 08 2014 16:53 GMT

#1091

On September 09 2014 01:50 ritoky wrote:

Show nested quote +

right, because let's not consider that it's a no-flip game, so it's more like video mafia than regular forum mafia where speculation on the alignment of the dead is valuable information. that aside, there is NO VOTING RECORD. this was decided by 1 person, so we have no record of people's thoughts on the matter. why the hell do you want less information in the thread?

In video mafia it's also 100% correct to not speculate on the dead. It's literally worthless information there too.

geript

10024 Posts

September 08 2014 16:56 GMT

#1093

On September 09 2014 01:47 Sylencia wrote:
Oh yeah, forgot to mention:

Show nested quote +

I wrote my post pretty much with yamato's post in mind, and yet I get completely different results from geript:

Show nested quote +

Other than the fact my thought process was actually incorrect (which geript doesn't actually comment on), both follow the same train of thought. One player was in the position to make an 'easy' play (ignore the incorrect logic for a second). They don't, and instead choose to go with their honest thoughts about the situation. Thus, this player should be townie.

So how is it that in one case it's seen as really good logic, and in the other case it's seen as convoluted logic? As far as I can tell, this is a pretty easy way for geript to slowly move targets towards me. If he had commented on the incorrect logic around the time yamato posted about it and I realised my error, sure things would probably be different but he didn't consider it and just gave a weird reaction given the previous case.

Because in one case, it's a matter of using logic and applying it really well. In the other case, it's a matter of trying to find a way to call someone town in potentially the strangest loop of logic I've ever seen. "HaruRH is town because he didn't counterclaim the martyr when he could have because few people believed goobly." I've rarely seen town think up that line. I have seen scum make a round about path like that reasonably often. So yah, Good read based on strong logic versus trying to make shit up based on needing to take a dump in the thread.

geript

10024 Posts

September 08 2014 16:58 GMT

#1095

On September 09 2014 01:53 IAmRobik wrote:
Haru might actually be mafia