|
On September 07 2014 02:53 geript wrote:
FWIW, other than meta reasons, one of the things that's really bothered me about Robik is that his reads are so ephemeral. In the last game I was in (which I was scum), I didn't really cared what I said and I just spewed a bunch of random bullshit and never really bothered to figure out how much of it was right. It was just do stuff to look active and towny and stuff that sounds good. That's exactly how Robik's been playing. No read lasts, everything changes and it often changes so fast and so often that it's really hard to nail down where he actually stands "this second." I don't get why Rayn, Yam, and Koshi are all reading him town.
Can you please be specific about which reads "don't last"?
I think there are a couple I've been wishy washy on like 3 people, but would love to know what you're talkinga bout?
Why is it bad to reevaluate the game as the game progresses?
Like nothing you're saying here makes a lick of fucking sense
|
My Syl read actually was the most recent to flip.
My early game read of gobble = town switched to gobble = scum based off of what oats said, and then went back to gobble = town after the claim
Yamato didn't do dick, but I don't think I necessarily called him scum. He became obvious town after the logic-bomb he dropped
Koshi I've never called town an still think he's on the scummier side
Same goes for Rayn
Same goes for you
I've been flip flopping on sloosh. I thoguth ht was scummy, then he called out damdred. I'm pretty sure that when he said "wanna see a trick" and then called out damdred to get damdred to appear in the thread, that was super fucking town. Even though he disappeared, I don't think I'd lynch him at least the first few days, simply based off of that one post.
Oats I thought was scummy at first, but pretty much changed my mind at the beginning of the game and have been town on him since.
Ritoky is fairly townie. I may be wrong, but whatever. I have him as town for now.
I think that covers the majority of the game
Would love to answer any and all questions about my reads. I think I left out Haru...he's a fucking ghost.
|
I never actually thought oats was scummy. I just thought it would be funny to call him out for a little bit 
|
We haven't talked about night actions in a while. Everyone put everything on me.
Thanks!
|
Like, wtf are you even doing this game geript? Why are you voting for people who you don't even talk about? If you think I'm scum, vote for me. You'd be so fucking wrong,but this voting on random people is not helping anyone. Why aren't you trying to get your thoughts out clearly and concisely? Why aren't you pushing an agenda?
|
On September 07 2014 03:52 yamato77 wrote:Show nested quote +On September 07 2014 03:46 slOosh wrote:
Hmm ... I can see myself being persuaded (since I have a couple of thoughts on it), but I'm curious if our reasons match up. Could you give me a brief synopsis as I work on catching up? rayn's voting patterns and reads make absolutely no sense that's not entirely unusual, but he's also too meek for town rayn basically he's just trying to get an easy mislynch and not really trying to find mafia at all
Have you ever seen Rayn with a filter this small? Have you ever seen him not be aggressive? I think the answer to the first question, is only that pro/am game. The answer to the 2nd question is never. I'm so confused. In what fucking world does Rayn not try. Why doesn't he at least attempt to emulate his town play, if he's scum, by attacking people and trying to bury people.
|
That vote on Damdred feels pretty pretty pretty good.
Mafia team: Damdred/Rayn/geript with a hint of Koshi/haru/sylencia
|
Nah ... we're small time here. No killing Rayn d1. That's silly. Kill off his partners and watch him squirm.
|
Sloosh, you're wrong on oats. Take him off your list. From now until forever
|
|
|
##deadlinevote Raynimpolite
|
On September 07 2014 04:40 yamato77 wrote:
you owe me anyway robik
your play in the other game is a travesty
ummm, only if i were town.
|
On September 07 2014 04:43 yamato77 wrote:
fuckin shit
I had this feeling about you
I actually stole your play from this game and used it to get town read in that game. LOL. When I called that one girl town for coming to the conclusion that I was town based off of her not pushing scum on me after giving herself every ample opportunity to do so -- that was basically what you did this game. Cept I'm fairly convinced that you did that as town here, which is why I thought it would seem super town there
|
It was town/town/town wagons. Didn't matter all that much.
|
Nope. I can pm you the roles if you want. Let's focus on deciding between Rayn or damdred. possibly geript. possibly koshi because oats wants to kill koshi and oats plays pretty well when he's town
|
On September 07 2014 05:00 Koshi wrote:
I really hope it is a yamato/oats scumteam. That would be so fucking perfect.
That would be impossible.
|
On September 07 2014 05:02 geript wrote:
I'm quite sure that Robik needs to die today for town to win.
Never gonna happen. Mafia might try to NK me, but they sure as hell won't lynch me
|
On September 07 2014 05:02 geript wrote:Show nested quote +On September 07 2014 05:02 IAmRobik wrote:On September 07 2014 05:00 Koshi wrote:
I really hope it is a yamato/oats scumteam. That would be so fucking perfect. That would be impossible. Nah, you'd just be misreading oats for the second game in a row. Nothing new there.
It's literally impossible for me to misread him
|
loooooooooool. Geript still calling me scum. What an idiot
|
As for why I haven't read haru, it's not cause i have a town read on him. It's cause I have no read on him. He's not memorable at all this game. That's what earned him a spot on my "to lynch" list. How am I going to have a read on someone who hasn't posted anything and has given very few reads. Yeah, I can "meta" read that as scum, but that's on par with meta reading rayn scum for not posting a lot. Why is haru that much scummier than rayn from a meta perspective? He's not.
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
