|
On August 22 2014 00:30 Damdred wrote:
I tried to scum hunt but I felt like everything I did was met with suspicion or laughed off by almost everyone in the game and that their feel on the person was better than my case it was kinda demoralizing. Though I was an ass towards the end of day 1 with xata and a bit with rob
I think your posting improved a lot on D1. You did play a good scumgame just a while ago and i got maybe a bit biased in my read on you because of it. 
|
I agree with rayn the game was balanaced
|
On August 22 2014 00:31 raynpelikoneet wrote:Show nested quote +On August 22 2014 00:30 Damdred wrote:
I tried to scum hunt but I felt like everything I did was met with suspicion or laughed off by almost everyone in the game and that their feel on the person was better than my case it was kinda demoralizing. Though I was an ass towards the end of day 1 with xata and a bit with rob I think your posting improved a lot on D1. You did play a good scumgame just a while ago and i got maybe a bit biased in my read on you because of it.
Well thats understandable healthy suspicion on everyone is good you shoudl never just accept people at face value. But I deserved to get scum read especially N0 for my awkward posts god they were horrid
|
Stop saying that, Damdred. It's crystal clear that your gameplay improved a lot. I believe I also said that on the obs or scum qt
|
GB its true you said it and the obs said that a few of my posts were true.
But in game I made posts Oats (mafia) said they were bad and Xat discredited them and nobody else even bothered to comment besides Rob who said I sheeped him on what I was saying about Xat being fluffy basically and ignored for most of day 1 lol. And all I did was discredit people that was said several times by the PR in thread.
And instead of talking out what happened day one and seeing what I said make sense one of the only active townies immediately threw down a vote on me lol. So yeaaaa
|
I really blame myself because i should have totes read GB and Oats mafia. 
And it would have given Xatalos (most likely) more confidence to push his good reads on D1.
|
Yea I started thinking something was fishy about Oats when he was gone for so long all the time after looking at some of his other games but other things were drawing my attention <<
|
On August 22 2014 00:53 raynpelikoneet wrote:I really blame myself because i should have totes read GB and Oats mafia. And it would have given Xatalos (most likely) more confidence to push his good reads on D1.
I'm so happy you felt i was too silly to be scum lol
You also had a scum read on damdred. I was going to use that as a possible red check from you to mislynch damdred
BTW when does the cop check returns for god sake?
|
At the end of the night when day post happens
|
On August 22 2014 01:11 GlowingBear wrote:
I'm so happy you felt i was too silly to be scum lol
You also had a scum read on damdred. I was going to use that as a possible red check from you to mislynch damdred
That was a one time thing. You won't get away with it anymore.
|
On August 22 2014 01:15 raynpelikoneet wrote:Show nested quote +On August 22 2014 01:11 GlowingBear wrote:
I'm so happy you felt i was too silly to be scum lol
You also had a scum read on damdred. I was going to use that as a possible red check from you to mislynch damdred
That was a one time thing. You won't get away with it anymore.
I'm not trying that anymore now that you say it unless I'm town.
TBH I just tried to emulate my town play and I think I would act as silly as that LOLOLOL
|
haha
|
Mull d1 is not balanced. The only part that "balanced" the game was that it could turn into a claimfest. Anyone saying anything different is wrong. And n0 was 12hrs. That's barely enough time for me to read into shit and figure out the game. People were playing on d1. I don't know what any of you idiots are talking about.
|
|
|
On August 21 2014 23:56 raynpelikoneet wrote:Show nested quote +On August 21 2014 23:18 IAmRobik wrote:
Just realized: this setup is broken in mafias favor so hard. Mafia has like a 66% chance to ensure that no gun is given out at f6 as long as they mislynch d1 automatically ensuring d2 victory. That's kinda sick There is nothing wrong in D2 LYLO. Just fucking play from the beginning and lynch mafia and win. People just didn't play. Me dying is on YOU, not on me. And i hated the comment you posted about me because it's so fucking wrong. Go read Palmar's analysis post. If townies do not play in a short game town will lose. Period. You didn't play, fuck noone played on N0 except for me and Xatalos. You are supposed to PROTECT THE BLUES by playing. I got shot even though i was WRONG on BOTH of my scumreads i posted in the thread. rofl.
I signed up to play a game. I didn't sign up to die n0.
|
You can only die n0 if you are actually playing the game.
Idc tbh, I think it's balanced just because n0 is decisive. This could be a stomp from any sides. But if you think the problem was the mechanics and not gameplay, I won't argue anymore.
|
Well we failed to lynch you d1 which was clearly our fault. If we had done that, the game might have been interesting, but you pretty much have to have EVERY SINGLE TOWNIE vote for mafia d1 or you lose d2. That seems like a silly concept and not in the spirit of the game of mafia. It's a d1 final 4 situation
|
And ya. That's part of the reason why I didn't play n0. People here already know how I feel about posting at night. The majority of my night posts are just me trolling
|
You should probably change it.
It does not matter who dies. Lynch mafia. Find mafia. All game, day or night. Period.
Maybe you should try it sometimes Robik.
|
On August 21 2014 23:56 raynpelikoneet wrote:Show nested quote +On August 21 2014 23:19 Xatalos wrote:Well yeah I'll admit that scumhunting is the weakest part of my play. That's why my reads are generally pretty weak at the early stages of the game and slowly get better from there when I can see vote movements, deadline behaviour, night actions, roleclaims etc. I guess this game wasn't really my ideal game since there was so little to form reads with  Like many players had only 1-3 pages of filter. You had it all right at some point on D1. Then you did something and changed your mind.
I never read geript as scum until the voterace situation though, but I had GB+Oats as scum at some point, that's true. Well, Oats was partly because of a misunderstanding, and when it got cleared up, I kind of forgot about Oats (still had him as potential scum but not as a priority). GB I felt was scummy throughout the game, but I think Robik said that his recent posts were a bit towny at some point and I kind of agreed, so I just consolidated on Tehpoofter (in hindsight I never really felt that Tehpoofter was scum, in fact the opposite at many points in time, so I shouldn't have voted him really.... but I thought geript was town and apparently he had this magical read on him damn I'm too easily swayed sometimes).
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
