Newbie Mini Mafia LVII - Page 9

On August 04 2014 06:26 Tehpoofter wrote:
Rip MeatPu$$y.


This game is silly. I have an idea of who I think it is....

before I go into can people give where they stand? Especially GB Teemu Seeya? Like those 3 should really talk about who they think the next kill is and why.

On August 04 2014 07:52 Tehpoofter wrote:


Just breathe. I'm going to tell you whose mafia later.


Tell me what you think of people that could be mafia plz .

On August 05 2014 06:48 Lord Tolkien wrote:

It's rather frustrating for me since I want to read him more solidly, but his paucity of posts D2 onwards makes it nearly impossible for me to say anything. Was trying to see if I could coax more posts out of him D2 for a more solid D3 read, but nope.



1) Mafia rarely kills at random. There's usually some logic behind it.

However, you should NOT let night kills influence your decisions regarding who is scum, because of aforementioned wifom. It could be for any reason from Teemu starting to look town in everyone's eyes, they thought he was blue, "let's confuse town", to let's make town think XXX is town/scum.

Again, evaluate a case on it's merits, not on unknown speculation for now.


I continue to disagree about where the vote for mafia was D1 (hence why I was looking at lilwade as probably scum D2), but I'm kinda reluctantly going to have to agree that cya is the "best" case right now, though I really do not want us to have just one bandwagon.

On August 05 2014 08:51 Lord Tolkien wrote:

Fair enough.

1) plausible
2) plausible
3) plausible

The issue is it doesn't help us actually make any major reads so...

On August 05 2014 11:16 Seeyalater wrote:

1) After what Jenny said(and was right on MP), I'm not sure it was a random kill.

2) From what I understand you're trying to say, killing teemu would be a terrible idea by me, as people have been saying there's a mafia between one of us a couple times since MP was mislynched.

3) I think this is the most obvious choice here. Still not 100% sure what the WIFOM thing means, but it does seem like Jenny and teemu shared some similar thoughts(on me, tolkien, poof at least).

On August 05 2014 11:49 lilwade wrote:
What is the likely-hood that there is 3 town left and 2 mafia, this puts us in a LYLO situation. What are we thinkin boys.

On August 05 2014 19:27 Lord Tolkien wrote:
OK NOW, THIS is interesting and probably puts us on the path to winning. Unless cya is godfather and we're all screwed because of this; I wouldn't put it past Haru.


Right, so this actually explains why I felt so very uncomfortable with lilwade's posts and reading him in general. GIVEN THE TIMING, he's pretty much confirmed town. The only reason mafia would make such a cop claim is that it's either LYLO, or they're about to get lynched. I highly doubt we're at LYLO since that requires 3-6 town split, which means 2 mislynches=gg for town, and that's abit too little room for error in a newbie game I would think. And he'd have to be worried about a counterclaim.

I'm going to reach here and say there's 4 town 1 mafia left. What does this mean? lilwade is almost certainly not scum if that's the game setup. If he was TOWN fake-claiming cop then we may have just lost the game, but he's not an idiot from the way his posts have read, which indicates he's town. If he were mafia, the fact he doesn't die tonight after a mislynch would basically mean he's mafia and thus seal the game for town. WAYYYY too big a risk for mafia to take would think. And Mafia would basically never let him live into LYLO, because at this stage, he would basically have a 66% chance of checking a LYLO member and thus basically win it for town, vs 33% chance he checks someone who dies, and thus gets a shitton of suspicion on him. 2:1 odds...that's pretty long.

So yeah, he's most likely what he says he is, and in any event, we'll know after night if we lynch incorrectly if he was just really desperate mafia (doesn't seem like it).

Unless there was a godfather in the game, that's the "wrench", but a town read on cya is invaluable to solving the game..

So the question for me is: Poofter or GB. Hmm...after I wake up from a quick nap.



If we have any other blues (unlikely), claim now I think. I'll say it now, I'm VT.

On August 05 2014 17:13 lilwade wrote:
Operation Town Victory

Ok guys, let us get this game on the right track for town win.

We have 5 players left and potentially 1-2 mafias members alive.

Plan

I am town cop.

N1: I investigated teemu, sadly he just passed away last night.

N2: I investigated Seeyalater and guess what Green check good to go (hopefully you will team up with me here)

Basically me and seeya have to decide on which one of you remaining 3 players tolkien, poof, GB is actually town so we can lynch the remaining mafia.

If there is only 1 mafia member left we have a huge change at the outright victory.

Here are my current townie rankings

1) Lord Tolkien, I think you are very much town, and your recent filter is outstanding.

2) Poofter, I think there is a good possibility you bused DC day 1 to pocket the remaining town, but chances are that would be more unlikely. Your recent posts are good as well and I would like to see what you have to say to me now.

3) GB I was never able to get a good read on you throughout the day 1 and night 1 phases, As of late I am still undecided that is why you are #3

Ride or die,

Any questions ladies?

On July 31 2014 17:39 lilwade wrote:
I got excited to see a bunch of posts when I got back, I am sincerely disappointed that the game had to go this direction, Meatpudding. What are your goals right now, you look like the kid in kindergarten pointing the finger and the other kid spitting gibberish because he took your toy. We are almost at the point where it would be better for you to role claim than anything else, not saying you have a role. Please put up a solid defense backed by what you think is solid leads and maybe we can get somewhere. For a bit you were leaning town but did not follow up on just about anything you have said. I am not sure if you just can not handle the pressure but if you are town hang in there and throw a few more punches.