Team Melee Mini Mafia V: Newbies and Vets

On July 12 2014 05:50 Stratiform wrote:
Well I have some stuff to say about the game at least. I feel like rayn is town, and I don't think haru is necessarily mafia.


I don't really think that in this situation voting without reasoning up front is reason to call someone scum. At this point in this game, I don't think mafia would sheep a vote without explanation, and then publicly declare it in the thread. I just don't see the logic from a mafia perspective.

Haru is null because all he did was defend his teammate to the best of his ability, which you would want to do for either alignment.

Also, although ExO has acted differently in other games, his massive post shows that he is putting a lot of effort into his reads. While I may not agree with all of them, I think it is a sign of town. Robik, while acting strange, isn't necessarily acting scummy.

On July 12 2014 06:14 Stratiform wrote:
Not really. I posted my thoughts, not the very first thing that came to mind.

And also, that's a great second post, CR. Do you have anything else to say about the game so far?

On July 12 2014 06:36 Stratiform wrote:

I disagree particularly with ExO's read on my team. I included Robik to show that I think both members of their team are town.

I don't see OnceKing voting for team WeDemandALawyer in the voting thread. In fact, I only see Palmar and Rayn, so I mentioned Rayn.

I mentioned Haru because there was sort of a back and forth between rayn and haru. Tbh I initially put him in there because I townread him but then I realized I didn't really have enough info to confirm it.

On July 12 2014 11:01 sqrtofneg1 wrote:
Slam conceded.
So do I.

On July 12 2014 11:39 Stratiform wrote:
Koshi/CR is a good guess for mafia.

Chairman Ray:

His second post in the game and it's voting on an easy target. He then proceeds to tunnel me for pretty much the entire time he was in the thread. His away post then randomly throws accusation on bunnies, not sure if that comment is mean to be taken seriously. Also, he barely acknowledges anything else that is going on in the thread.


That's all he posts aside from tunneling me pretty much.

As for Koshi:


This post is the one that stood out to me. ExO being town is a fairly common read by this point, and no one is really attacking Eden either. His only scumread is a sheep of his partner with a half-assed justification.

On July 12 2014 12:17 Stratiform wrote:

I was an easy target at the time because pretty much anything said about me at that point was negative. OnceKing and Bunnies had called my earlier posts bad, and on page 42 where I return, Slenderman casts a casual vote on me and Robik suspects me as mafia before you made your vote.