Holy shit I hate making cases. Guess I have to try. >.>
Haru
Haru's only scum game was NMM LVI. Let's take a quick look at his manner of interacting with the thread:
Meatpudding is already self-immolating. His cases have changed from 'weak with no substantiation' to 'weak with a pinch of bullshit'. This guy should be lynched today for his incoherent reads.
Even if Meatpudding don't get lynched today, I'll push for his lynch on d2 unless he gives something constructive.
The case on MM is nearly the same as Meatpudding.
1) reads that include points that they exhibit
2) incoherency
3) some form of kneejerk OMGUS
Therefore I'm fine with any of their lynches.
He's interacting with players in the exact same manner in both games. He comes up with flimsy/nonexistant reasons to scumread people, IE:
Opportunistic? Even if I was blindfolded and asked to type what I feel about cava/sinani still serious about robik's fake scumread, I would have shouted 'THATS SO SCUMMY'. I don't need a good excuse to lynch you, your actions is a good enough excuse.
If we can't lynch cava/sinani today, then town is fked. Such an obvious hit on mafia and yet, you lynch someone who could only formulate opinions d2.
Then, there are his recaps of in-game events made in order to look busy while he accomplishes nothing, but for the sake of not taking up the entire page, here's a link to the fifth page of his newbie filter:
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/450895-newbie-mini-mafia-lvi?user=HaruRH&page=5
The first post is basically a match for his analysis regarding my claim. Why does he do this? To look busy and spread doubt. Here's a link to the third page of his filter from this game:
http://www.teamliquid.net/forum/mafia/460092-world-cup-mini-mafia?user=HaruRH&page=3
These large posts serve the purpose of casting suspicion on other players without being held accountable. The main difference is that, this game, he was riding the wave of thread sentiment against both mderg and me and made a giant post condemning both of us.
I've also already pointed out that Haru has never explicitly mentioned Poofter as a scumread at any point during this game:
On June 30 2014 11:36 HaruRH wrote:Show nested quote +On June 30 2014 10:27 ObviousOne wrote:
The pissed is more about status of how games play out not about winning I think it was in the scum or obs qt
Wifom. I was pissed because everyone didn't understand that 1 game of meta cant be used, thus I switched up and got meta read.
This wagon on me by oo and kush is so telling.
Scumpool: cav kush oo exo mderg
3/5 is scum here
This post was made after people starting moving off of my wagon on day 2. The thing to note is that Poofter was actually wound up voting him and then leaving the thread, and Haru never bothered to include him in his scumlists. His vote later on in mylo confirmed my suspicions, where he voted Poofter while thread sentiment was already stacked against him.
tl;dr
Haru is interacting with the thread the same way he did during his scum game. He is attempting to spread doubt amongst easily lynchable players rather than attempting to solve the game.
He only voted Poofter because the town forced him to. He has never included Poofter as one of his scummers, even though he was basically saying that he wanted almost anyone else to die.
His earlier posts about not being able to establish reads basically comes off as a giant excuse, since he can just coast to the end of the game if I get mislynched and he basically doesn't have to do anything if he shoots/roleblocks the right people. He technically saved me during day 1, but then immediately turned around and kept trying to lynch me. He has been setting this up all game. Haru is scum.
EPT
