This post is posted like 3 times already so it's not really "finding" a gem is it? No thread reading means can't trust rest of reads tbh.
+ Show Spoiler +

On June 18 2014 05:18 mattisfoolish wrote:
Repost in here sorry

Also found this gem:

Show nested quote +

~Foolishness

Then this travesty

On June 18 2014 06:55 mattisfoolish wrote:
ok so my buddy foolishness is correct, we think that sandroba is mafia, so marv, thats a fine vote right there if it said the right name.

secondly, gumshoe is probably mafia as well

i think obi is mafia, his posts during n2(?) were really really off putting to me, however my partnah disagrees and doesnt think so cause he's a silly willy

people who shouldnt be lynched until everyone else is dead include

marv, chrom, batsnacks, ticatica, round, CR, 27nb

The red shows that the sandroba read is a far more definitive read than the green text which shows gumshoe is a "probable" mafia", yet:

On June 18 2014 05:08 mattisfoolish wrote:
##Vote: gumshoe

dafuk is going on -.- this lurking shit is fucking frustrating tbh

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

June 18 2014 08:16 GMT

#4074

oh yeh

##unvote
##vote mif

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

June 18 2014 08:22 GMT

#4075

I also can't remember who wrote it so own up if you did for +++ points but someone said that mif only appears when he is under suspicion and getting voted which is very very true.

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

June 18 2014 08:25 GMT

#4077

+++ arbitrary meaningless points for you

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

June 18 2014 08:42 GMT

#4079

On June 18 2014 15:25 roundabound wrote:

Show nested quote +

So, this is way more than sandro has done and hos list isnt terrible. It at least shows a semblance of paying attention and knowing whats going on.

As I was tyoing that to say we shouldnt lynch MIF, I realized that thats probably even scummier than just not showing up like gumshoe is doing.

Not sure if it is scummier than sandro promising in the thread to pick up activity and then disappearing though.

this post... wtf does it even say, flip flop central

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

June 18 2014 09:39 GMT

#4084

On June 18 2014 18:31 marvellosity wrote:
I'll probably be lynching sandroba if things carry on as it is, although sand was probably doing football-brazil things last night.

so he has today to dazzle my socks off.

so why is mif voting gumshoe when sandroba is his most definite scum read?

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

June 18 2014 09:56 GMT

#4087

because now he's saying it like gumshoe is some kind of sub read that isn't as strong as a guy that isn't even playing and he most definitely isn't reading the thread because what he's quoting has been quoted numerous times he also hasn't commented on anything related to gumshoe or even seemed like he's updating that read

also pretty salty for not being town read for starting this gumshoe thing

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

June 18 2014 10:05 GMT

#4090

he could have from the last time he posted his gumshoe read

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

June 18 2014 10:12 GMT

#4092

meeeeeeeeeeh

just trying to find *things* that seem like any sort of scum motivation because shit tonnes of people are afk :/

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

June 18 2014 10:26 GMT

#4095

i should bet some money on that match

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

June 18 2014 10:55 GMT

#4096

On June 18 2014 19:15 marvellosity wrote:
well look, there's plenty of reason for mif to be mafia, indeed my vote is on him right now. But voting for a scumread and not updating a scumread when that scumread hasn't posted isn't really one of them :p

What I don't get is why we have a massive discussion thread about behaviour when the "behaviour" that is really deleterious to our games is people not putting in any effort. Even if the thread is super long, you can still filter a few of the consensus mafia reads and give reasons why they are/aren't mafia. That's the real stain on mafia games, people not trying or giving a shit. Not someone saying fuck you occasionally or whatever.

well yeh that's pretty much my only gripe with mafia atm although i'm sure loads of the "i quit cz boo hoo meanies" would love to disagree

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

June 18 2014 13:05 GMT

#4129

On June 18 2014 21:47 marvellosity wrote:
mehhhhhh. still doens't look like mafia on mafia.

yes

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

June 18 2014 13:09 GMT

#4130

I don't think i want to lynch someone that's not sandroba/foolishness/gumshoe today