|
On April 27 2014 18:41 Palmar wrote:
To be completely fair, the blow me town is usually a scumclaim geript, so Odin isn't wrong.
Also I don't tend to antagonize Ace all that much, he's a pain in the ass to deal with as either alignment so I tend to just ignore him for the most part.
@Odin, I didn't read whatever caused Foolishness to vote prplhz, I have other reasons to think prplhz is probably town.
I'm not faulting him for it. I just don't find it convincing personally. I am however very interested in your prplhz read. Mind explaining that one to your town hero. Also what do you think of how a Yam has chosen to not play this game whatsoever so far?
@Odin. Other than Palmer has anyone else piqued you're interest and why?
|
On April 28 2014 04:27 Foolishness wrote:
I've already had the liberty of going through Cephiro's past games. He hasn't been mafia in a while and when he is he's very apathetic in his play, while his town posts are very definitive thoughts that he's having. Based on his one post so far this game he's probably town, but a read on him later in the game will tell for sure. Really it's simple, in a day or two ask yourself, "has Cephiro been trying to help the town?" If yes, then town. If no, then kill with fire. Don't need to over-think him.
Cephiro was just recently mafia in Cell where he came in and made 1 big post and mostly fucked off. I don't think that there's any reason to clear him in any realistic way based on that for sure.
On April 28 2014 05:47 Cephiro wrote:
EBWOP: Anyone need posts in the meanwhile? I won't be needing all of mine remaining for the day cycle.
Yes. You need to donate posts to yourself and then use them. Like I've been following Dreamhack and playing D&D and been able to make posts and shit. You can do the same.
On April 28 2014 05:38 yamato77 wrote:
I dare you to shoot me, VE.
I dare you.
Please do. I'd be 100% happy to see this lazy ass yam be shot. He's done nothing useful and if I had a gun I'd shoot him for being useless when I know he doesn't have to be. The only problem with this of course is that there's way too many useless people in this game right now who are not clearly town.
On April 28 2014 01:38 strongandbig wrote:
What I'm saying is, even though caller did throw a nuke and looked like scum, I try to judge whether I agree with his reactions and reasoning about other players separately from whether I think those reactions and reasoning make him scum. Sometimes those conclusions feed into each other, like if someone's reasoning is bad and I can find a scum motivation for that bad reasoning.
His reactions were nothing and nothing essentially and you townread him for it? There was no reasoning for nuking Palmer at that time and no clear motivation for said reasonings, so how does that work towards Caller being more town. Like this part was just an exceptionally fail part of the whole post. Hell, like you calling Caller's fake nuke worthless and NAI is pretty much bullshit imo. I don't see a point in fake nuking D1 as mafia when you can save that to protect a partner later on or do other shit with it. I find how he used it pretty towny because it started discussion instantly which is pretty hard to do in a post restriction game imo.
Honestly, I'm like super pissed at Wave and Palmer right now. Wave has done jack shit all day. Banks is being an MIA asshole. Palmer is just providing reads without any fucking reason; I'm happy to see his ass shot too; as far as I'm concerned he's claimed scum too many times now. SnB looks to be a solid lynch.
I remember seeing that Austin had a scum read on Oats. I strongly disagree with that. I wish I had the energy to go look at the catastrophy QT again to see how his mentality lines up.
I could get behind a BH lynch if I didn't think that he's been worse than I remember him used to being. IDK, maybe LIX overinflated my opinion of him for all time.
I don't really get Fool's push on prplhz. Like I get what he's saying, but I just don't read that as automatically scummy.
RoL useless should be shot. I'm kinda surprised that BH isn't in any way poking at him whatsoever. I figure that considering their history and BH being the type of player he is, that BH would've poked or prodded him some by now. That feels a bit weird to me.
Prplhz's response to Fool is weird to me. Like it's a pretty drastic change from how I saw him in Cell. Like he's way more jerkface/assholy than he was in cell where he came from the position that he would and should be cleared for specific reasons. I'm not really getting that at all here.
~15
|
On April 27 2014 05:18 geript wrote:
Oats--So I've pretty much owned Scum!Oats everytime I've seen him. I have a really good read on him and I'm pretty sure he's town here. Basically, as town he's more aggressive and offensive than he is as scum. He also lets himself be more "free" and will follow whatever dumb idea pops into his head.
4
Gotcha covered snooglewoogle
16
|
To snooglewoogle I am the oats whisperer. I don't think any of your points actually make him scum. Normal people, maybe but not oats IMO.
I'm really surprised slam shot without any provocation. That's pretty far out his character. Like really really far out of his character. Enough so that I'm considering him again.
I don't get why Sandroba doesn't like the SnB stuf.
~16
|
On April 27 2014 05:18 geript wrote:Here's where I'm at: Alakaslam-- + Show Spoiler +On April 02 2014 12:49 getmoript wrote:
The read on Slam changed after having time to reread his filter. The read on Slam used to be: Is he having fun, if yes then town. But that's really an incomplete explanation. Slam subjectively has more fun playing mafia than he does as town. The difference is that as mafia he doesn't want to be lynched. As town, I don't think he cares. As town, he allows himself to be carefree so that he can enjoy playing. As scum, he doesn't because that's what gets him lynched. The two posts I've quoted, show off that carefree attitude. In these posts he's allowing himself to post whatever the fuck he's thinking; it's just him posting. That's town for him. Reading Slam is pretty simple, I think he's pretty obviously town here for anyone who's played with him before. BTW You have 8 posts left by my count. You must now stop doing fun shit and make posts about who you think is what and why4
@Sandro here. This is a 100% perfect way to read Slam.
|
Because this is my first game with Foolishness and I'm really unsure where I stand on him. Like I think SnB is a great fucking lynch but after I got up from my nap I wasn't really impressed with his meta read on him. I've also not been impressed with him missing the fact that Ceph has indeed played scum recently and played it exceptionally similar to this game. As far as tone being different, idk that's possible I guess. But I'm also not coming in 200 pages late. That's a pretty big difference. Like I can read this whole thread in less than an hour likely. Like I have really not been impressed by Foolishness, but I'm just not quite seeing it. Maybe it's just that I haven't ever played in a game (other than 1-2 video) with foolishness in it.
19
|
Oh fuck... this is majority lynch. I fucking hate majority lynhc.
|
Here's the thing. I don't see any better wagon right now. Not having a lynch is 100% not acceptable. SnB is wagon of justice people. Do the right thing. Free smores to everyone who joins.
~21
|
Palmer. He's been super worthless and assholey and he's one of a very few who might get enough to be lynched outside of Oats/SnB. I don't get why you don't think SnB is mafia. Wanna essplans that plz Wubby.
22?
|
Part of the reasoning for switching off Caller is that the fake nuke changes the whole point of lynching him in the first place. I don't find that strange to include. So I'd say you're half right, ie Oats not really properly explaining my vote on SnB but I'm really not seeing this as an important issue.
|
Can we get a vote count please
|
This is seriously fucked up and why I hate majority lynch system. 2 non-voters and 3 one-of voters. This is bullshit.
|
I'm back to Koshi being scum
|
On April 29 2014 07:01 Cephiro wrote:
Mason group please recruit me. That's all for tonight.
You've made what... 1 post. Fuck that idea. Vigi shoot Ceph. That will solve the problem.
|
On April 29 2014 07:07 Cephiro wrote:Show nested quote +On April 29 2014 07:04 geript wrote:On April 29 2014 07:01 Cephiro wrote:
Mason group please recruit me. That's all for tonight. You've made what... 1 post. Fuck that idea. Vigi shoot Ceph. That will solve the problem. Now I've made two. There is no "problem". A vig shot on me would be a waste with much better targets around.
So who do you shoot if you had a gun?
|
ok I fully approve of someone shooting Ceph full of holes.
|
On April 29 2014 07:57 austinmcc wrote:
1/5
Geript, why do you dislike that post of Cephiro's? You can add general Cephiro-is-mafia stuff for flavor, if you'd like, but why do you want Ceph shot in response to that post?
Ceph has been lurking and hasn't taken any realistic stance on anything this whole game. Apparently he finds the people who were on the SnB wagon scummy, but he never talks about it. Apparently, he's got ok reads or something but doesn't want to contribute until halfway through day 3 where there's no longer a good chance of a mislynch (bullshit). He hasn't bothered trying to look town. He hasn't try to push good lynches. He hasn't done shit. He's a decent player and the last time he was a shitty lurker like this he was mafia. I see no reason to expect him to derivate from his shitty lurker status or provide something useful to the game. So I want him dead with a capitol DED.
|
Dear snooglewoogle. I will take your points under consideration. I would still shoot him personally, but that's easy to say because I don't have a gun. Also, I get what you're saying about Oats. I just disagree. Please pretend they're both town... who do you shoot then? If I assume they're both town, then I'd shoot Plammer for playing dota. Or Foolishness. He seems weird too.
ps. I'm not your snooglewoogle; you're my snooglewoogle. You have to come up with a different name for me. It's how the game works.
|
|
|
Kumbiyah my lord Kumbiyah.....
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
