On March 24 2014 12:15 Oatsmaster wrote:
Damn.

Ok so how do we decide between hopeless or thrawn?
Both of them have said decent stuff d1 and bad stuff d2

Problem is that everyone seems town or is confirmed town. It doesn't make sense.

DarthPunk

Australia10859 Posts

March 24 2014 03:56 GMT

#3822

Thrawn as scum

Normal Mini IV less than a page of filter being useless
Normal Mini Mafia IV

Extractor trick, 2 pages of filter being useless
Extractor trick

LXII 8 Pages in 3 days including post game.
LXII

LVII 8 Pages in 4 days including post game.
LVII

Thrawn as Town

SMB 11 pages killed night one
SMB mini

10 pages in PM game.
LXIV

Thrawn this game: 13 pages of filter after day 2

Thrawn just doesn't DO as much as mafia. Which is the basis for my town read of him essentially.

DarthPunk

Australia10859 Posts

March 24 2014 04:00 GMT

#3823

Same thing with Hopeless

His filter from Titanic 2 as scum

4 pages not doing much.

This game

12 pages in the same time frame in the same setup.

I know this is very reliant on filter length, but that heuristic has been good for me. People generally post LESS as mafia not MORE.

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

March 24 2014 04:02 GMT

#3824

Did you check from the start of the game?
Bleh. What about poof? His resistance to my lynch felt very fake.

DarthPunk

Australia10859 Posts

March 24 2014 04:06 GMT

#3825

On March 24 2014 13:02 Oatsmaster wrote:
Did you check from the start of the game?
Bleh. What about poof? His resistance to my lynch felt very fake.

Yeah. You know what I find odd. No one ever mentions him in the pool of scumspects. I want to know why.

I mean he has seemed very reasonable and friendly. But he hasn't exactly caught scum. He is blatantly sheeping rayn.

meh I dunno. He doesn't SEEM scummy. You know?

This is the problem. I have good reasons to think everyone is town. And the people who are acting scummy to me are rayn and koshi whom are both confirmed through mechanics.

DarthPunk

Australia10859 Posts

March 24 2014 04:08 GMT

#3826

On March 24 2014 13:06 DarthPunk wrote:

Show nested quote +

That being said. Poof could be good enough as scum to be flying under the radar. But why was VIVAX pushing him so hard day one?

DarthPunk

Australia10859 Posts

March 24 2014 04:10 GMT

#3827

VE had poof as scummy until the association with Vivax kind of cleared him. VE what do you think of poof now?

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

March 24 2014 04:26 GMT

#3828

I cant check the timing but it was before rayn found the slip right?

What do you think of VE?

DarthPunk

Australia10859 Posts

March 24 2014 04:33 GMT

#3829

On March 24 2014 13:26 Oatsmaster wrote:
I cant check the timing but it was before rayn found the slip right?

What do you think of VE?

Town cause he raged like he did in Shadow game. Also he actually read holy's case, and more terrifying still my filter.

To be honest it is probably like poof and slam scum.

Oatsmaster

United States16628 Posts

March 24 2014 04:44 GMT

#3830

And vivax bussed like he always does. That makes sense. Do you have any specific reasons why he is scum other than everyone else is town?

DarthPunk

Australia10859 Posts

March 24 2014 04:49 GMT

#3831

On March 24 2014 13:44 Oatsmaster wrote:
And vivax bussed like he always does. That makes sense. Do you have any specific reasons why he is scum other than everyone else is town?

Well he lied day one and looked pretty terrible. put him as town due to VIVAX association and his play looks much better since day one, I am just working off POE mostly. But if anyone is scum it is him.

Alakaslam

United States17336 Posts

March 24 2014 04:54 GMT

#3832

I was called away then I made this nasty coffee

I am so derpy on this game is the vote already flipped that I was all I will move off dp for?

Alakaslam

United States17336 Posts

March 24 2014 04:56 GMT

#3833

The curse be gone be scum lol

DarthPunk

Australia10859 Posts

March 24 2014 04:56 GMT

#3834

On March 24 2014 13:54 Alakaslam wrote:
I was called away then I made this nasty coffee

I am so derpy on this game is the vote already flipped that I was all I will move off dp for?

Hey scummer!