I don't see the contradiction. There is no reason for any townie to do various strange things, yet they do it all the time and we even clear the for it. (it: this is so dumb he has to be town).

Palmar

Iceland22631 Posts

February 20 2014 08:39 GMT

#374

On February 20 2014 11:44 prplhz wrote:

Show nested quote +

top kek

You don't think there was ever a scum who was like "Shit, I need to get my vote off of this guy because this vote is a little silly and it's attracting attention to me. I guess I'll try to do it in a townie way."

The whole "scum act like town so we can never catch them"-idea is silly. Scum can't perfectly act like town and the more we force them to act the less they look like town (ideally).

I don't agree with your logic prplhz. IF rayn is mafia he's not dumb enough to create an entire plan to simply get his vote off someone. If he is mafia the reason he did this is he thought the plan would be well-received in town and considered advantageous for town, thus giving him townie points for not really doing anything.

Palmar

Iceland22631 Posts

February 20 2014 09:39 GMT

#380

On February 20 2014 18:27 Oatsmaster wrote:
What are you doing palmar? Are you pressuring anyone with that set of posts? It seems totally useless man. Why dont you finish reading then consolidate a push against someone

I'm posting things I find interesting?

Why is everyone so annoying and rash? Could you people just chill while I develop reads etc?

Palmar

Iceland22631 Posts

February 20 2014 09:40 GMT

#381

On February 20 2014 18:37 Koshi wrote:
@rayn
prplhz contradiction is something I don't perceive as scummy btw. But I can give him a scummy point.

I don't think it is a contradiction at all and I think the whole exchange makes prplhz look pretty good.

Palmar

Iceland22631 Posts

February 20 2014 09:44 GMT

#382

On February 20 2014 14:04 Oatsmaster wrote:
suki's post about rayn's policy was really bad because it served no purpose, nobody was asking her what she thought and she just comments on it that it doesnt make Rayn scum or town. Completely useless and not what a townie thinks about at all.

Toad because of his wishywashyness on rayn and his inconsistant stance on rayn.

Basically what other people said.

I don't agree that it's useless to make comments without reaching conclusion. Sometimes you're making them in hopes further comments will arise, sometimes you're simply stating your position. I've made multiple comments this game without trying to pretend I've reached some sort of conclusion.

If toad is scum it is because of what marv pointed out.

Palmar

Iceland22631 Posts

February 20 2014 09:49 GMT

#383

I just went back through the playerlist and I realized I actually like this game. Almost everyone has posted something that I can work with.

Palmar

Iceland22631 Posts

February 20 2014 10:56 GMT

#390

I know I want to see another train of thought by smurf. This first one was pretty bad, but I'm not sure it was scum-bad.

I agree with most of marv's conclusions. prplhz looks very much ok to me. I'm not as certain about Suki, but I am nowhere near calling her scum. As for clarification, I think it's much more likely rayn is scum than she is.

Palmar

Iceland22631 Posts

February 20 2014 10:58 GMT

#391

On February 20 2014 18:50 Koshi wrote:
yay. Now let's brainstorm.

I'm waiting for any kind of contribution to the discussion from you. You've posted a lot and said very little.

Palmar

Iceland22631 Posts

February 20 2014 11:06 GMT

#393

Are you actually going to play this game?

Palmar

Iceland22631 Posts

February 20 2014 11:07 GMT

#394

On February 20 2014 20:06 marvellosity wrote:
Seriously wish you'd let Balla answer first T.T

Agree with you about Koshi - Koshi my love, you can't just hang off me/rayn's coat-tails. You should know by now I only protect you when I have good reasons to think you're town... :>

Do you think rayn is town?

He's definitely in my lower tier of "possibly scum" players at the moment.

Palmar

Iceland22631 Posts

February 20 2014 11:08 GMT

#396

on a scale of 1 - starsenses, how certain are you?

Palmar

Iceland22631 Posts

February 20 2014 11:11 GMT

#399

I don't even understand that conversation.

Palmar

Iceland22631 Posts

February 20 2014 11:17 GMT

#406

That being said, of the people targeted by rayn, suki looks by far the worst. But she still looks better than Toad/Oats/sidesprang, who are the players I'd probably lynch if I had to choose right now.

For the time being marv is town for posting smart stuff, prplhz is town for being townie. kush is probably town too. I need to see more from the smurf to make a decision on him, but at least the pressure he put on me last night was genuine if a bit stupid. I like the fact he just dropped it when it was clear he wasn't getting anywhere with it, it feels very much town-like to just back off like that.

The pool is narrowing quite a bit, I mean if you can somehow convince me rayn/suki are town marv, and I might be inclined to just take a flyer on your read on them, then there isn't many players left to discuss for lynching.

Palmar

Iceland22631 Posts

February 20 2014 11:19 GMT

#407

It's basically the three I mentioned + balla + koshi.

Palmar

Iceland22631 Posts

February 20 2014 11:21 GMT

#409

Why have you been considering that Koshi? Why do you think Toad is scum?

Palmar

Iceland22631 Posts

February 20 2014 11:22 GMT

#411

pls respond fast so I can believe you're actually reading the thread and making informed decisions.

Palmar

Iceland22631 Posts

February 20 2014 11:22 GMT

#413

On February 20 2014 20:21 marvellosity wrote:
I'm not that interested in convincing you right now, Palmar, simply because it's so early and I can easily be wrong at this stage (especially suki I think - the continued attack on rayn's reasoning I found terrible, but then I found suki's incredulation at being rayn's scumread pretty genuine) and we have a tonne of time.

Agree with you on kush+Smurf as it stands.

This game has been much easier to get involved in and I feel kinda inclined to wait and see what a couple of my unknowns are going to do through the day

Out of curiosity, have you realized I'm town yet?