Like, for what it's worth, if rayn were in fact scum and kush told rayn that kush was a medic, rayn would probably tell bc anyways, even if he was going to shoot kush. After all, you can reasonably assume (remember the part where I told everyone to claim to bc?) that BC knows everyone's roles. Imagine how the conversation goes.

BC: Hey Kush, what are you?
Kush: Hey BC, I am the Medic.
BC: Okay, cool. What were your actions so far? What's your action tonight?
Kush: X and Y.
BC:

What does BC ask next here? What BC asks next, obviously, is who else have you told?.

He will ask and find out that Rayn knows, and that Kush told rayn he was saving Z (or whatever). Scum rayn, anticipating this, tells BC that Kush is Doc (revealing no new info to BC, who already knows everything, including that rayn knows), to look good.

Now, I don't think this is what happened; I think rayn is town. I'm just saying a scumread on rayn is not logically inconsistent with knowing rayn told BC kush was doc; rayn couldn't have known that kush hadn't claimed to BC.

Blazinghand

United States25550 Posts

January 31 2014 18:24 GMT

#2052

On February 01 2014 03:23 raynpelikoneet wrote:
lol BH, read my post. kush didn't even trust BC.. he thought BC WAS FAKECLAIMING VIGI!!

wait really

fuckin kush

Blazinghand

United States25550 Posts

January 31 2014 18:25 GMT

#2054

in case anyone somehow doubts BC's alignment, there's no counterclaim for vigi, BC MUST be town. come on guys.

Blazinghand

United States25550 Posts

January 31 2014 18:29 GMT

#2058

On February 01 2014 03:27 Grackaroni wrote:
If Coag flips town you guys can lynch me. Once he flips scum it should be pretty clear that Rayn has just been trying to save his kp and pushing whatever townie he can.

man this is shit logic, if coag flips town we only have one lynch left and you yourself should in theory know that you're town, so why would you even say this? if coag flips town you're gonna throw the game? seriously?

Blazinghand

United States25550 Posts

January 31 2014 18:31 GMT

#2060

##unvote

Ok, how do you tell town coag from scum coag? I'm bad at it and would like to know-- both to help solidify my reads this game, and for future reference. Please let me know, grack.

Blazinghand

United States25550 Posts

January 31 2014 18:37 GMT

#2067

On February 01 2014 03:34 Grackaroni wrote:
well the not posting the badge looks pretty bad, but I just can't find a scum team without Coag on it.
Oats - town
bum - probably town
Slam - town
BH - confirmed town and obv town before that
BC confirmed town and was also pretty likely town before that
Thrawn- really unlikely for Thrawn to be mafia

Ok, so it's entirely based on PoE? there are 11 people alive right now, so you need to make 8 townreads on people who are not coag to make coag into for sure scum. you've only listed 6 townreads (+1 for yourself)

so, from what you've just listed, a skan/rayn/mocsta scumteam is possible. Even if I had the same reads as you I would not be convinced.

Blazinghand

United States25550 Posts

January 31 2014 18:38 GMT

#2069

On February 01 2014 03:37 raynpelikoneet wrote:
##unvote
##Vote Coagulation

So I don't have a good handle on reading coag. any advice?

Blazinghand

United States25550 Posts

January 31 2014 18:38 GMT

#2072

On February 01 2014 03:38 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Neither of Mocsta/Skan is mafia.

i didn't say they were, i'm saying grack's conclusion doesn't follow his premise.

Blazinghand

United States25550 Posts

January 31 2014 18:40 GMT

#2074

On February 01 2014 03:38 raynpelikoneet wrote:

Show nested quote +

When he is town he tries to post something useful.
When he is mafia he posts absolutely nothing of value, like here.

yeah that's true he's not even trying. I'm down to lynch coag. Let me just consult with BC first.

Blazinghand

United States25550 Posts

January 31 2014 19:03 GMT

#2090

On February 01 2014 04:02 Coagulation wrote:
guys im town

surely you understand why this post is not alignment-indicative, right coag?

Blazinghand

United States25550 Posts

January 31 2014 19:05 GMT

#2093

On February 01 2014 04:04 bumatlarge wrote:
Look at these bullshit votes. He's not going to be hammered because everyone not on him is likely town.

so you're thinking slam skan grack scumteam?

Blazinghand

United States25550 Posts

January 31 2014 19:10 GMT

#2097

On February 01 2014 04:06 Skanjab1s wrote:

Show nested quote +

Babies or the flashy round one, either works.

is seal coag's version of STARSENSES?

Blazinghand

United States25550 Posts

January 31 2014 19:12 GMT

#2100

On February 01 2014 04:11 Grackaroni wrote:

Show nested quote +

lol no he has a seal that certifies his townieness that he is only willing to post as town

yeah that's what I meant. well if he doesn't post it we lynch him then

Blazinghand

United States25550 Posts

January 31 2014 19:12 GMT

#2102

i'll do some thinking! we still have like 24 hours :D

Blazinghand

United States25550 Posts

January 31 2014 19:16 GMT

#2106

if he's scum, he wont' post it, and we'll lynch him.

Blazinghand

United States25550 Posts

January 31 2014 19:17 GMT

#2112

If he posts it as scum, then he'll have lost the ability to use it in a trustworthy fashion in the future since people will know he's used it as scum before. I don't think he'd be willing to do that.