[M][N] "SMB" Mini Mafia - Page 3

On January 18 2014 04:37 Hopeless1der wrote:
I told Toad there was no basis for his (meta?) read on sn0 since sn0 has never rolled scum. Using the reasoning that wishywashy statements come from scum doesn't apply to sn0 since in every town game he's played, he has similar statements. He pulls one post from WC2 when at MYLO (LYLO?) sn0 finally has to play (so did I if you remember correctly, it was my case sn0 was responding to) after days of information. There is again, no reasonable comparison to this game the way Toad has framed his case.

He goes on to say how I'm the only other player thats 'yellow/orange' on his sheet when we have Grack doing nothing, cephiro being afk. Toad is opportunistically trying to bandwagon on me and doesnt give a shit about pushing anyone because both me and sn0 are mislynch targets, and I was leading the votes.

---

skanjab is a weaker read but basically his case on sn0 was garbage and his followup explaining the way he makes his cases is using scummy and selective reasoning.

On January 18 2014 05:15 Hopeless1der wrote:

"Look at these posts I quoted. They are scummy for Reason A. Therefore the player is scummy for Reason A.
NO!! Do not read those other posts that disagree with Reason A. They aren't important. Read the posts I quoted and only those posts. Those are the scummy ones. Read those. No guys stop looking at the entire filter. You only need to look at what I showed you. I clearly explained why the posts I quoted are scummy. That means that player is scummy. You don't need to know anything else."

On January 18 2014 09:11 thrawn2112 wrote:


how did the flip affect your reads? what was your immediate reaction to seeing the flip?

On January 18 2014 21:42 raynpelikoneet wrote:
You can't say Grackaroni flipping town makes Hopeless more likely to be scum if you are town because if that is the case you did believe Grack is scum - so him being a wagon does not make Hopeless mafia, because other townies (like you) thought he is scum too. Therefore, if you did not think Grack is town before the flip you can't make the connection argument. It's only possible if you know/think Grack is town before the flip and you didn't think so because you did not say so. If you had thought so, you would have tried to prevent a mislynch before it happened.

No, that's not how townies make cases. You don't need to "try to find something scummy", you read the thread and notice scummy things and then you point them out. Not go to someone's filter and try to find something scummy..

If you do that as town that's probably why you are bad.

On January 18 2014 21:44 raynpelikoneet wrote:
So Skanjabs, tell me who did save Hopeless and what are the bullshit arguments Grack was lynched with?

On January 19 2014 09:14 Hopeless1der wrote:
##DoubleLynch

If I'm reading this correctly cephiro is a day-vig or is scum. I'm in the process of rereading things. Skanjab has damn near claimed SK and while he could just be joking about it I greatly dislike having to second guess someone who is wearing a "Lynch me" sign. Toad is being "framed" by the SK in my opinion. Not sure how that is going to play out as I still think Toad is scummy.

On January 20 2014 00:33 Toadesstern wrote:
His most recent post. Suddenly ska reappears on the list. I'm still his lynch candidate but Ska/Oats are STILL his more scummy suspects as he keeps on pondering about those instead. Despite saying though his vote is still firmly on me. And as you might have figured, still no fucking reasoning for anything.