BH, can you direct me to any town game of yours where you have fake claimed. I don't see why you would put a breadcrumb like that in your first post as town if you are not actually a tracker; as soon as you entered the game you were already planning to fake claim...

Grackaroni

United States9857 Posts

November 18 2013 06:01 GMT

#2895

I still think Koshi is likely scum but I want to hear more from BH. I also haven't peeked into Oats' filter since the start of the game so I will take a look at him.

Grackaroni

United States9857 Posts

November 18 2013 06:02 GMT

#2899

I can't tell if Hopeless is for real or not. He's like annoyed that people are pushing him and calling him useless after he's done nothing for so long.

Grackaroni

United States9857 Posts

November 18 2013 06:03 GMT

#2901

Did you look at my Koshi case Pandain?

Grackaroni

United States9857 Posts

November 18 2013 06:06 GMT

#2904

Tracker is a hard role to fakeclaim with other trackers in the game likely to watch him. I could understand him wanting to get out of that as scum and he already said in his original claim in thread that he was claiming because he didn't have any time.

BH's case on me is honestly better than any contribution I have seen him make as scum in recent days, but I can't remember a single time where BH has fake claimed as town before.

Grackaroni

United States9857 Posts

November 18 2013 06:19 GMT

#2912

On November 18 2013 15:17 Oatsmaster wrote:
as in knowing its fake, or the claim? Again, claiming as scum who is gonna get lynched is NEVER bad.

Or sometimes even making a completely random claim when you are already not going to get lynched! That is even more fun.

Grackaroni

United States9857 Posts

November 18 2013 06:29 GMT

#2916

On November 18 2013 15:24 Oatsmaster wrote:
Hey grack, is hopeless scum?

I don't think he's reading the thread. After being gone for an entire cycle he added nothing. I'm having a difficult time believing that a scum player could be so monumentally useless when he is under some pressure to be killed.

Grackaroni

United States9857 Posts

November 18 2013 06:41 GMT

#2920

Hey Oats, can you elaborate on what you meant earlier when you said VE can't play this good as scum? I think he looks quite bad right now.

Grackaroni

United States9857 Posts

November 18 2013 06:42 GMT

#2922

Pandain all you talk about is BH's fake claim. It's not an attractive look for you. I want you to talk to me about my case. discuss actual reads with me rather than drone on about this one thing over and over again.

Grackaroni

United States9857 Posts

November 18 2013 06:45 GMT

#2925

On November 18 2013 15:40 Oatsmaster wrote:
So too bad to be scum. Right.

I wouldn't really argue against vigging him, but the too bad to be scum does usually end up correct. (It could actually just be because there are more bad players than scum players.)

Grackaroni

United States9857 Posts

November 18 2013 06:49 GMT

#2927

On November 18 2013 15:43 Pandain wrote:
No I'm done thinking about BH for the most part. I'm not talking about it except to explain what I think about BH. And I can do that without thinking hard while I would have to read your analysis of Koshi, then read Koshi's filter, then read his meta, and so forth which would take like an hour.

It's convenience posting for me until I fall asleep

It's not just tonight though, even earlier in the day when I originally wrote a case on Koshi all you were doing was attacking BH for making a dumb claim.

Grackaroni

United States9857 Posts

November 18 2013 06:52 GMT

#2929

BH scum is as easy to read as Yamato's scum. If he doesn't scumhunt then he dies. No point continuously pushing him for making a dumb claim.

Grackaroni

United States9857 Posts

November 18 2013 06:57 GMT

#2933

On November 18 2013 15:53 Oatsmaster wrote:

Show nested quote +

Why does VE look bad?

He wouldn't fully flesh out any real reasoning for his mayor lynch targets being scum. The fact that he ended up lynching Skanjab. I also don't like the way he started accusing me of "breaking character" as soon as I attempted to question Mocsta.

Grackaroni

United States9857 Posts

November 18 2013 06:58 GMT

#2935

On November 18 2013 15:55 Oatsmaster wrote:

Show nested quote +

But hopeless is bad at playing scum. He is just blending man. He posts insightful and useful stuff as town and doesnt do it as scum. And he is TRYING to post its just not very good.

I'll look into him then. I don't think I've seen a scum hopeless before.

Grackaroni

United States9857 Posts

November 18 2013 07:03 GMT

#2942

On November 18 2013 15:59 Pandain wrote:

Show nested quote +

Oh stop he posted afterwards

and it makes sense if you don't want to get lynched and don't have time to fully commit day one as town.

This is the last I'll post of this since Grack wants me to stop, though I'm a bit irritated he doesn't see that I'm not even concerned about BH that much anymore

I know you aren't concerned about BH but you have spent practically all of the night phase saying BH is scum for his role claim and then spent the last few hours arguing that BH is town because it was a fake claim. You just don't seem willing to actually discuss anything important in the game.

Grackaroni

United States9857 Posts

November 18 2013 07:03 GMT

#2943

On November 18 2013 16:02 Oatsmaster wrote:
BH if you did that as town, I will shit on you every time you say you are a good player.

I already do.

Grackaroni

United States9857 Posts

November 18 2013 07:07 GMT

#2947

On November 18 2013 16:01 Oatsmaster wrote:

Show nested quote +

Yeah the skanjab lynch was weird and bad. So you dont think the 'breaking character' thing is accurate? Why did you change from messing around to playing properly?

No I don't think that's accurate. I trolled my way through most of the dick measuring contest and Mocsta's post was the first thing that actually struck me as scummy. I had wanted to try to question him and he pushed me into defending myself and my trolling.

Grackaroni

United States9857 Posts

November 18 2013 07:13 GMT

#2954

BH. Have you ever fake claimed as town before?