Just like holy, oats, cc scum team yes? :D why are people playing today like it's day 1?? You're just saying a bunch of names abd adding scum to it but aren't backing it up with evidence, conclusions, logic. I get suspicions because I have a butt load of them and I even question my super towny reads at points but adding it to the thread like you people are doing is not contribution. In fact only LM has properly tried that.

My real contender for the lynch today is alakaslam and the vote switch was the trigger for that. There are a lot of questionable things in his filter that I suggest you look at. I will update you when I get to a computer

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

December 03 2013 23:11 GMT

#7413

On December 04 2013 07:58 Pandain wrote:
Just a question, why did you vote CC

He made a plan that said what to do if risen was town and that we had to lynch risen but then when i was going for the onegu lynch he hopped straight off of the risen lynch even though all his game plan was based off risen lynch scenarios. I thought he was town and was arguing for him but then saw that situation on a last minute trawl.

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

December 03 2013 23:13 GMT

#7415

On December 04 2013 08:07 Grackaroni wrote:
Which slam vote switch are you talking about HF?

The one that says that risen/thrawn votes are much too close and that we need to consolidate onto thrawn and slam says sure and does but then switches to dead vote VA in stealth shenanigans

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

December 04 2013 00:17 GMT

#7422

Pandain i don't get what exactly you're getting at re:me, there was clearly no incentive for scum to argue against a town/town lynch, i came back with4 hours to go before lynch to discuss why i thought one of the candidates was town and yes, unfortunately it led to me being hypocritical on slam but the point you said about his vote NOT being alignment indicative is very very wrong.

The vote was at like 7 to 6 or 7 to 5, i tell him to consolidate to thrawn and he says sure thing. What town motivation is there to suddenly switch his vote to VA who had no prior votes? The only thing it enables is town consensus to fail, it showed he hadn't read the thread because he asked US who to lynch and instead of making the lynch safe on a scum lynch he makes it highly vulnerable to shenanigans. There is no town motivation there at all.

I said he may as well be a lurker despite his lengthy post count because I haven't seen much contribution at all. The fact of the matter is 2 townies just died. 3 if you count vayne. People are tagging along for the ride when the only people who even properly discussed the cc lynch were me and austin and you. There is quite clearly scum sitting along for the ride here.

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

December 04 2013 00:38 GMT

#7424

It doesn't matter what you do or did because that thrawn lynch is completely different scenario. You go from 2kp to 1 in a big game, not a newbie. I would love to hear your thought process on the switch to VA instead of consolidation though, why bother asking us what to do to just end up not doing it?

I am tunnelled on this point and it's annoying me because i see no logical town reasoning behind it, so convince me!

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

December 04 2013 01:10 GMT

#7428

I want to know how the plan of lynch coag was aborted while I was gone and put onto 2 people nobody really fully questioned though. I also want to know why, when I voted coag everyone just said no and got on with their lives only to now question him again today?

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

December 04 2013 06:24 GMT

#7436

On December 04 2013 10:32 Alakaslam wrote:

Show nested quote +

Who?

I have been chasing lone to no avail

Hopeless wants Onegu out

Lone doesn't know for sure

Coag wants pandain out

Pandain wants Coag out

What the fish? Your ka bar sounds like a fart on that dry ice

Was talking about last day cycle

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

December 04 2013 06:27 GMT

#7437

On December 04 2013 14:45 Pandain wrote:
I masoned Onegu and I'm not as confident he's scum.

But then again I'm not confident anyone is scum

On December 04 2013 07:14 Pandain wrote:
Onegu, Coagulation, Holy are my guesses.

How does this make any sense within the same day?

Holyflare

United Kingdom30775 Posts

December 04 2013 09:31 GMT

#7449

Here's my problem pandain, you tell onegu all the things that "make you town"

Here's why I'm town:
1. All my mason choices have been clear town. First three were Supersoft, BC, and then Mig. That shows lack of fear, and my mason logs are pretty legit. Esp B.C., where we disagree a lot and there's actually emotional conflict in there. I masoned Grack which makes sense because Grackapack. I masoned Hopeless and now you to figure out your guys' alignment. All town mason choices unlike Thrawn who with masons like Koshi and Rayne shows that he was scared.

2. Most people who are dead thought I was town. I masoned SS and Mig, and they're confirmed town, and they had strong town reads on me. Prob cuz they liked me in mason chats.

3. I've clearly shown an interst to lynch scum, not just Oats. I'm talking with you and trying to figure out who is scum, actually getting conversation started.

These apply tenfold to me, yet, you have labelled me as one of your "scum" reads. The fact that you have done that must equivocate to those points in fact meaning nothing if they don't apply to another person. Now, when it comes down to the facts of the game when people weigh up between me and you, I have made cases, lynched and hammered now confirmed scum, whereas you were off scum wagons, lynched townies and only really gathered steam in the past 2 ish days.

I do not know whether you are scum or not, truthfully my gut says you aren't but in order for me to know, you need a little more convincing argument than "i masoned town people".

That being said, I'm at a toss up between coag, hopeless and slam lynch today. I'm pretty sure i remember today being a pivotal lynch and I'm on my phone so can't really confirm but we actually need to hit scum today. I will be on a computer from 6pm onwards (gmt) so can make cases around then. I want people to read my case on coag, although a little outdated now, his complete lack of involvement since the case etc etc. I want you to check hopeless' posting style. It's totally different from what I've seen him do before, then he upped his posts to an antagonistic vibe for no reason while contributing nothing. Slam for reasons I have said before.

I think there must have been at least 1 scum off the thrawn wagon to try shenanigans so check that!