I would think not Asinine is a likely teammate of Poofter/Odin either because with the way Asinine was pushing against the fuba lynch it's not worth it to have 1 lurker push the lynch on to scum when everyone else on the team is not on the wagon.

Grackaroni

United States9846 Posts

November 04 2013 02:41 GMT

#862

*Asinine is not.

Tehpoofter

United States2911 Posts

November 04 2013 02:44 GMT

#863

##Vote Asinine

Knowing that 1 of his mafia was on the line day one his defense was hard core. I hate his "vig me thats okay" thing that self sacrificing thing doesn't do anything for town. (I realize these points are not new but reading his filter I have a hard time seeing anything but mafia out of Asinine)

Going to read up on others filters next (berett mig pan) specifically.

I'd like to just point out that when I voted (same time stamp as stutters) hz was set to be lynched so as someone pointed out my vote was the hammer. So definitely makes me suspicious of people thinking that hoping on the hz (who was confirmed town) vote wouldn't have been the best mafia play. I understand those who voted on me for being lurky though I have no good defense for that.

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

November 04 2013 02:46 GMT

#864

Honestly I do agree. I read his filter and I can't really see it coming from town. I also don't know any townies recently or ever who have actually said "it's alright, vig me we have enough people", even though its logical.

His defense was just so weird, out of nowhere, and embraced the majority of his posts. He then downplayed it later.

Maybe Grack or Mig, you guys can convince me otherwise, but I think I have to vote Asinine.

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

November 04 2013 02:47 GMT

#865

Like I can see it coming from not mafia but I can't see it coming from town, which means it has to be mafia.

Grackaroni

United States9846 Posts

November 04 2013 02:47 GMT

#866

Meaning if Asinine was mafia at this point and committed to trying to push the lynch off of his teammate I would think it makes sense for him to instruct poofter/odin to vote hzflank.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

November 04 2013 02:50 GMT

#867

If asinine is mafia then who is his scummate? tehpoofter/hopeless/bereft/LJ all voting for him.

Grackaroni

United States9846 Posts

November 04 2013 02:56 GMT

#868

On November 04 2013 11:46 Pandain wrote:
I also don't know any townies recently or ever who have actually said "it's alright, vig me we have enough people", even though its logical.

Chairman Ray in Hogwarts!

Hopeless1der

United States5836 Posts

November 04 2013 03:14 GMT

#869

thats slightly different grack, CR was trying to pull the too scummy to be scum card. His slot was already hooped by the time he "replaced" in, and I use the term replacement loosely considering the level of commitment he was able to provide.

Asinine on the other hand demonstrated he had at least some time, was up to date and following the thread, and was supposedly making reads of all the players he found scummy. I don't like his analyses but I'll get to that tomorrow if/when town needs further convincing to lynch Asinine.

I've just opened bereft's filter, going to read through and gather what context I can, so it wont be an instant "oh its only 2 pages" read.

Pandain

United States12989 Posts

November 04 2013 03:16 GMT

#870

On November 04 2013 11:50 Mig wrote:
If asinine is mafia then who is his scummate? tehpoofter/hopeless/bereft/LJ all voting for him.

I don't know maybe Stutters. Not impossible Oats just went hard on him and he voted for fuba. After all, he didn't vote him originally and he could have just bussed.

I just can't see him being town.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

November 04 2013 03:21 GMT

#871

I am getting nervous about stutters not posting in so long but not only did Oats mess with stutters he was also one of the first guys to target fuba with this post

+ Show Spoiler +

On November 02 2013 01:13 Stutters695 wrote:
Well I was hoping Fuba/Hz would have posted by now since I want to see what they say, but I want to get this out there sooner rather than later so other people can give their input also.

Fuba usually is a low post, high analysis player. That analysis is non-existent in his vote on Hz. If memory serves he usually has no problem saying he doesn't know until he is certain someone is scum. I'm at work, phone posting, so I can't check past games. This does remind me far too much of Basterd Mini where he struggled to push anyone (as scum) who wasn't actually scum because he struggles finding reasons. Consequently, he lurked a lot d1 until he had stuff to weigh in on during massive posts.

The only reason I'm not pushing him 100% right now is if he is really busy he wouldn't have a lot of time and I can't remember any games off the top of my head on how he played in one where he was limited on time.

Anyone experienced with him want to weigh in on that?

He did still vote for HZ at first but he eventually switched and hammered fuba. If he was bussing fuba for town cred wouldn't he have just voted fuba after making this post instead of making himself look worse by voting HZ first?

Mig

United States4714 Posts

November 04 2013 03:29 GMT

#872

I am nervous when all the most suspicious people in the town are voting for asinine.

Maybe JarJar is mafia with asinine and he just randomly decided he couldn't leave his vote on Pandain and it would be too suspicious to be the last vote on hz so he was forced to bus fuba.

Hopeless1der

United States5836 Posts

November 04 2013 03:39 GMT

#873

k finished bereft's filter, I'm getting a town vibe..

Mig

United States4714 Posts

November 04 2013 03:41 GMT

#874

Hopeless you have no problem with bereft voting pandain for "pressure" then disappearing while there was a contested lynch between a mafia and town?

OdinOfPergo

United States840 Posts

November 04 2013 03:45 GMT

#875

I actually disagree. Most of the vibes I've been getting from Bereft are more along the lines of... I'm just going to post these apologetic low to no content post. I feel like he's just trying to play the "bad townie" and go unnoticed.

OdinOfPergo

United States840 Posts

November 04 2013 03:45 GMT

#876

I also really don't like Poofter. Other than changing his vote to Fuba he has contributed literally nothing to this game.

OdinOfPergo

United States840 Posts

November 04 2013 03:46 GMT

#877

So Hopeless, what's so townie about Bereft?

Hopeless1der

United States5836 Posts

November 04 2013 03:48 GMT

#878

On November 04 2013 12:41 Mig wrote:
Hopeless you have no problem with bereft voting pandain for "pressure" then disappearing while there was a contested lynch between a mafia and town?

its obviously less than ideal, and when you consider the lack of perceived resistance to fuba's lynch I can now understand why people have jumped to the conclusion that the remaining scum are in the /afk's. However, I don't think bereft was around or she'd have managed to get her vote onto a meaningful candidate. The apathy for the lynch to me suggests a townie mindset of not knowing who to vote and just parking it on the RNG, then not having time to play for the remainder of the day.

She's now hiding behind the grackapack's supreme wisdom, but they're almost confirmed town. I know I just sheeped the Innocent Child in Hogwarts for a good deal of the game, so I can see it happening.

Mig

United States4714 Posts

November 04 2013 03:54 GMT

#879

I see, would you have said the same thing about oat's vote on pandain?

Any reservations about Oats targeting asinine before he died?