|
On October 31 2013 06:23 Promethelax wrote:
As scum I have shot people for tonnes of reasons, good reads is one but so is being a universal town read. The death implicating someone I want to get lynched. Eliminating a power role.
I also just realized how scummy me saying all this is since I was WoS's major scum read at least for a while. But whatever. I don't think wos was shot for beig right. He didn't have power i this town to lead to a correct lynch even if he was right about scum.
Unfortunately WoS was not a town read by the majority of town, especially since he had just been up for lynch.
What do you think he was shot for, and it's probably not to cast suspicion on others who didn't get shot.
I cannot fathom how you think he was randomly shot for being a town read or for any other reason then the simple fact he must have been on to something because he got shot while he was suspicious to town
|
And lol if you think mafia shot him because of his role
|
I'm fine with lynching SnB or Seuss today.
|
And my nuke pm said that nukes disappear if you don't use them within the first 12 hours, did others get different pms?
|
On October 30 2013 02:28 HotCottonCandy wrote:Show nested quote +On October 30 2013 02:23 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Also CandymanAuthority why are you voting for Pandain? Case please if you think he is scum. It's not based on what he is doing but rather what the thread is doing. Go through and count how many times he has been mentioned randomly for pretty much no reason when there isn't even a discussion on him! There is so much light suspicion on him but nobody is pushing him or doing anything about it, it's just oh yea he's scummy maybe idk. This is usually scum when this happens because they are just skating by in thread and their buddies try to make him look bad but not too bad so he blends in. even though he is not playing to his scum meta here I think he has a good chance of flipping scum for other reasons in a nutshell.
I like this post,this is a good town post while an awful mafia post. Why use such assumption-based reasoning?
The rests of his posts are fine too, if not very assertive or Vayne-like.
I could see this as him appearing to be town, but I see little reason to assume that unless we have no proof.
Also would you guys rather lynch Seuss instead? They're interchangable to me and you guys don't seem to believe me yet about SnB
|
On October 31 2013 08:42 marvellosity wrote:
The long and short of it rayn is that
a) I'm not sure I believe that you "accidentally" fucked up using your powers on me. It's very convenient.
b) I'm not sure I believe your non-excuse for disappearing around lynch time and not being proactive about WoS. Again, it's very convenient.
In my own view I think there are better ways to analyze people then deciding whether or not an "excuse" they make can be valid or not.
You can connect it to an overall analysis, but we should be looking at the behavior of people why they are here. I personally think analysis based on what people do not post is pretty weak as it's like assigning an x possibility when that person has one of abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz possibilities.
|
I need to decide between Seuss, SnB, VA, Kush, and Sentinel.
So I'll do that tomorrow probably.
|
On October 31 2013 08:47 marvellosity wrote:
Not "oh my dear god"
For you to be town I have to accept you randomly went somewhere you can't remember to buy cigarettes with lynch coming up immediately, and you somehow managed to fuck up your power and fucked up one of the strongest players' in the game power because "woops". I hate having to assume stupid shit.
Do you think this is even likely as scum?
One, he would easily make up a story about where he got cigerrates as scum. The fact he didn't and still doesn't shows some unnecessary guilt and therefore authenticity.
It being around lynch time is okay, but not everyone has to be here at lynch, and you're assuming priorities of people which shouldn't be our priority for analysis.
Also, again, would he have gone after you if he was scum? Purposely mess up? It's wifom but it's a scary thing to do within the first (10?) hours of the game.
|
I'm going to give Rayn a definitive town read. If not, it'll at least force me to change my post psychology theory.
What he's doing doesn't make sense from a scum or 3p mindset, esp. with the actions surrounding Marv.
|
Rayn would you support a Seuss lynch?
|
On October 31 2013 09:48 marvellosity wrote:
Given you were interested in Wave's reads as he died, Pandain, it's curious that you didn't pick that up or mention that yet
I only skimmed but yeah his reads aren't aligning with mine. I doubt he was all right. He was curious about Rayn which still puts a thought in my mind he's scum, but without that I would say he's town. I just know he's not scum.
Yeah he does defend Seuss. Hmm
|
Do you now trust that it's important to look into his reads or are you doing this to mock me
|
Seuss basically is definition of skirting by with important caveat he's putting huge effort into things which don't really affect the game.
Makes sense from scum mindset not really town.
|
On October 31 2013 09:55 marvellosity wrote:
Neither - I'm doing it because you stated it could be important and then failed to do it yourself when bringing up a lynch candidate, especially a lynch candidate that Wave has a particular connection with.
I think basically you want me to research a person in depth before giving any thoughts.
|
Which I can do, but it'll mean I'll post less
|
That's thoughts to me, no?
I mean I haven't fully decided yet but as of now I want those two lynched. Later I may change it
|
Seuss and SnB are my main looks.
VA, Kush, Sentinel, and Koshi are possibilities
|
Yeah I think they would as long as they seem to contribute. This is his second game, correct? Makes sense to be wishy washy especially if he's carrying a persona.
It's not about that though its more I think he doesn't care yet is seeming to. Like a more subtle version of SnB
|
On October 31 2013 09:56 Pandain wrote:
Seuss basically is definition of skirting by with important caveat he's putting huge effort into things which don't really affect the game.
Makes sense from scum mindset not really town.
I mean this is what I originally said
|
On October 31 2013 10:03 marvellosity wrote:
Apologies if it's in your filter recently, but what are your general Oats-thoughts, Pandain?
I gave a town read on him early on because he was so aggressive to me the townie. Also genuinely wanted me to adress the points when I ignored him.
Plus I meant to check this but doesn't oats usually bus?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
