|
On October 30 2013 12:02 Seuss wrote:Show nested quote +On October 30 2013 12:01 Pandain wrote:
This is a policy nuke and I hope its real
##Nuke strongandbig If you assume all the nukes are real, which (correct me if I'm wrong) seems to be your working assumption, you just wasted your nuke.
It was my working assumption, but Marv convinced me that not all nukes are real because that would be real bad play by the hosts.
Even if they are all real, I wouldn't be comfortable nuking anyone else.
I heavily encourage you and everyone to nuke Snb
|
Actually this is a good compromise.
Everyone should nuke SnB
Good chance of being scum, and ensures that we don't have a nuclear armageddon.
Seuss why not nuke SnB?
|
That's not a contradiction lol.
I don't think all of them are fake, but now I don't think all of them are real.
What's the problem?
|
oh wait seuss already nuked didn't he
|
Yeah, so they'll nuke someone suspicious or not nuke at all
It isn't going to be alignment indicative unless a townie nukes a scum.
|
I don't see what you're honestly hoping to gain from this HCC.
Only more information through deaths, but that also means we're closer to lylo and normally we would have that amount of deaths with MORE INFORMATION ON A LATER DAY
|
The only possibly good thing is if vets don't get shot then they can analyze this information, but that's assuming scum won't go for vets, that we have a doctor (honestly don't know with how roles are shaping up), and that the vets are even right.
|
Problem is SnB has deeper reasons why he's scum. Koshi for instance, isn't certain scum despite him having shit reasons to suspect me, thought I made good points before, mainly only sheeped Rayn in regards to me, had other scum reads, etc........
But that doesn't mean he's scum.
|
I think, regardless if the the nukes are real or not, you're over-evaluating the information we will have at the end.
If I die to Koshi, what will you make of it?
I think SnB is scum and so did you two, but we'd have already killed him and like I said would be the only real results. And would help certify we are town. But that's really the only way.
SnB nuking you is more suspicious because he fundamentally is showing a disregard of concern, but I wasn't fully fully convinced he was scum; it's the policy nuke that pushed me over the edge and what I am so angry about.
I understand, in the end, we will get information. I just think it's better to consolidate on SnB rather then potentially nuke townies for information.
|
On October 30 2013 23:30 Promethelax wrote:Show nested quote +On October 30 2013 23:26 WaveofShadow wrote:
Well kush acting like an asshole to me would make some sense. Not that I think he's telling the truth anyway.
Prome what do you make of VA's play? I have him as tentative town atm but I'm curious if anyone shares my sentiment. I don't know. Not helpful I know. I find myself fluctuating on him a lot, like dude was being smart and on point early on but his presence fell of and he kinda seemed to coast through the thread during the giant piles of shit flinging that occurred in the middle of the day. He is in that somewhat large group of players who I'd be happy to see flip but wouldn't be my first target. Has kush's meta changed? Because if it hasn't he is 100% scum. Anyone remember that whole kush likes to be right as scum and defends townies for no fucking reason thing? Clarity should never have been defended and was being defended on stupid shit by kush.
Idk I gave pretty good point that was ignored
|
I agree that if kush is scum then points stand, with exception of who he put as mafia.
I am not however certain although I am watching him that he is scum
|
On October 30 2013 05:30 Pandain wrote:
Actually Clarity brings too much suspicion to himself for my taste. Like he's like "yeah, I know I'm scummy, but w/e can't help it". Scum would justify themselves and say "No dude i have homework to do" or another excuse, but at least adress it and not give up.
He's also consistant with the mindset I'm getting from him, not sure how to describe it but sad-ish. Like not confident, still somewhat trying, etc....
And a bad case in itself isn't worthy of scum when other people are more suspicious.
|
On October 30 2013 23:40 Koshi wrote:
Clarity was a policy lynch.
Koshi not to be mean but you are playing so poorly this game in particular
It's really the only reason I think you're town
|
Does anyone disagree SnB is scum btw?
|
That's a good point, and I do think OOHChild has a good chance of flipping scum.
I'll think about it more since I still think SnB is objectively scummy for several reasons.
|
Wave seems town cuz why use a third nuke on SnB. For mafia of he's town, why draw suspicion on yourself if any of our nukes are real. And he wouldn't use a nuke on scum
|
Also my nuke would have evaporated by now. Do other nukes not have time limits?
|
In my mind SnB, Seuss, and someone else but I'll say Koshi is scum.
Marv is def town, oats is town. Prom is likely town but I won't say he can't be scum or 3p
Koshi probably isn't 3rd party, neither is oats. Koshi doesn't post enough real shit and oats posts too assertive/ much in terms of clear opinions
|
Wave is town too for nuke reasoning and his responses, his play feels like town.
|
On October 31 2013 05:02 raynpelikoneet wrote:
Pandain read me, read me!
I think your town but if I were to die I wouldn't say trust that you are town
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
