Hogwarts Mafia - Page 5

On October 21 2013 08:34 StorrZerg wrote:
can syllo and mocasta name claim at this point?

On October 21 2013 08:59 Mocsta wrote:

Ceph apparently gets stronger when ppl in the group die.... Odd that pandain was in it then.

On October 21 2013 09:27 Mocsta wrote:
Palomar pm is not relevant because that is mod generated.

Whereas the message I got I am certain was written by cephiro now.

I received my pm about 5min after cycle post..so it suggests cephiro was aware of the phrase Dumbledore army.

He's prob a good option for sk...and fits into rayn theory of being in his house. Also explains why his emotion felt real.

On October 21 2013 09:39 Holyflare wrote:


He said he had an explanation, didn't say what it was

On October 21 2013 10:09 Mocsta wrote:

Yeah I did read it, but was on phone so haven't had a chance to mull it over.

We can safely assume that ET knew he was linked to Toad.
So it does seem likely ET was killed due to this power from Sn0 and him using the 0.5KP. This would then also apply to Pandain.
The other option is that a SK took out Pandain & a town vig took out ET, thus taking out Toad.
Due to the quantity of NKs; Sn0's "power" seems more plausible.

So: LoneMeow/LastArgument/Supersoft.

Now: If 3 scum are dead, I would expect KP to be 1 as per OP (but depends on how hosts resolve night actions). Lets say KP is still 2.. we still require that 2 KP to be delivered by members that were not dead (probably same resolution process as above). So assume 2 KP; LastArgument makes a lot of sense. With Syllo a likely medic save, Supersoft also makes sense. So OK, then a vig of some sort on LoneMeow.

Thats A LOT of KP though; and its also interesting to note that Cephiro wrote nothing about LoneMeow in his list post.
So we come back to whether
LoneMeow was taken out by town vig power; or SK.

I don't think Cephiro can be easily dismissed as an SK (and I would prefer a town vig not to claim the kill, as they probably not 1-shot).

On October 21 2013 10:20 StorrZerg wrote:
hmmm

well is policy lynching him good then because he is failing to live up to his word on scum hunting?

On October 21 2013 10:27 Grackaroni wrote:
JAT why did you say Palmar should be in Dumbledore's army?

On October 21 2013 20:30 Mattchew wrote:
So syllo, who do we lynch... I can dig a JAT lynch

On October 21 2013 21:55 Mattchew wrote:
I think we have 2 general options, we lynch into my house or we lynch outside my house plus slytherin... I say this because i firmly believe in the check on my house and dont really see a framer being involved with any of us except maybe me.. If this is true and the is 1 mafia in our house, then i dont like slytherin with mocsta (as i believe his claim) to have a 2nd (and 3rd on house cop check) mafia in the house

In my mind, unless im completely missing something we should be lynching into jat, onegu, va or yam/cr...
Onegu has tried to pressure me and scum hunt mostly me but i think his read has been adapting, which seems pretty townie
Yam just bounced so i dont really know where i lie on him anymore it seems he really couldnt be arsed to try
Jat and VA i havent dont enough reading on to say scum or not but i havent read anything that made me think theyre town yet

On October 21 2013 22:05 Cephiro wrote:


There's nothing contradictory about those posts. As a mafia player you should know that it's not even a rare occurence to see a town vote for someone they aren't sure of being scum, simply because:

1) They are more sure that other players are town
2) Consolidating votes for lynch
3) Weird powers

etc.

Why are you painting those as something they're not?

On October 21 2013 22:59 Mocsta wrote:

Misread.

Too tired for this shit. Where the fuck is everyone else, sigh.

Did you address Koshi case? The points were valid. I know you gave a one-line reply, but wasn't sure if that was the entirety of the defense.

On October 21 2013 23:19 Mocsta wrote:

Do you agree with his assessment that a scum team should have pushed for his "mislynch"?