Hogwarts Mafia - Page 5

On October 19 2013 05:10 Grackaroni wrote:
I blame BH. Who knows what kind of shenannies he was pulling behind the scenes.

On October 20 2013 06:20 LastArgument wrote:
glhf town, gg

On October 20 2013 07:24 syllogism wrote:
If anything that looks bad since Mocsta for the most part ignored LastArgument and doesn't know alignments meaning he can't know if he played a "really strong town game". Oops?

On October 20 2013 06:32 syllogism wrote:

Mocsta looks fairly suspicious for this

On October 19 2013 22:57 Mocsta wrote:
I'm of a fan of echelon escaping discussion by using the bandwagon argument that syllo is town, and +1.

he is a slippery one worthy of the serpent.

in Slytherin, he is the top scum potential.


hmmm, BH and zaragon scum for me still.

cephrio made a weird ass post about charms etc prior as well.

night

.

On October 20 2013 05:32 VayneAuthority wrote:
indeed, pandain started with his town meta and then was unable to keep it up. echelontee was obvious scum so good shot there, surprised about lonemeow since its impossible to tell people like that alignment as far as im aware.

should be plenty obvious im town now with the harry potter red flip. I could only know that main characters could be scum if I was scum. I think the rest of our house is town FYI

On October 20 2013 07:01 syllogism wrote:
No, me being an innocent child is my license not to do anything. Even now I'm just pushing a policy lynch on a miller.

On October 20 2013 07:24 syllogism wrote:
If anything that looks bad since Mocsta for the most part ignored LastArgument and doesn't know alignments meaning he can't know if he played a "really strong town game". Oops?

On October 20 2013 07:26 Blazinghand wrote:


you turd-hat you literally quote his goodbye post

On October 20 2013 07:27 syllogism wrote:

You weren't pushing the same reads as him and based on a quick skim of your filter this is the only time you mentioned him. A very strong town game implies he was pushing correct reads.

On October 20 2013 07:43 Blazinghand wrote:


so you were planning to PM a live player asking for who he was a smurf of? yeah right

also if you think i get demotivated as scum you've literally read none of my scumgames

On October 18 2013 11:17 EchelonTee wrote:

I'm utilizing my self control so I don't just flame you endlessly, but it's difficult. My statement that it is likely this game has lots of roles because it is a theme game, a Harry Potter one no less, does not indicate nor deny my status as a blue. Stop the WIFOM.

On October 18 2013 23:16 EchelonTee wrote:
On my Onegu case; it is true that Onegu has examples of being apologetic as both town and scum. I'll consider that aspect to be a bit hazy, but if you take a quick gander at his filter, you'd see that since he's been back all he's giving is town reads; no scum reads in sight. To me this is a blatant showing of non-contribution to thread, activity for activity's sake. I am still confident in my read, but I am moving my vote to better guarantee a good lynch, as the difference in votes are a hair's difference and we have ~10 votes still not in.

##unvote

---

I don't know who koshi is so no that's not a really good answer for me. I also don't know rayn at all either yet people are saying things along the lines of "oh it was actually that guy who is talking? yeah I know he's town then". Honestly this situation is souring my opinion towards hydras: twice the amount of posts to decipher with half the amount of cohesiveness between them.
lul

---

On cephiro; his only post reeks; I primarily agree with the logic laid out here. I also already noted how strange it is that Cephiro was casually active on QT yet not involved in thread nor in scumhunting. This indicates that he definitely had the time to be reading the thread, yet he has no time to follow through on his so called reads? I'm happy with a lynch on him.

##Vote: Cephiro

Will not be back before deadline. Fingers crossed.

On October 20 2013 08:34 Holyflare wrote:


This. Look at BH's filter, 3 pages and it's all useless spam shit. What is more curious is how mocsta could have an entire read on Zaragon/BH and he can see BH doing this trolly shit but he doesn't even mention that shit in his last case post on mattchew????

On October 20 2013 08:43 syllogism wrote:
That Mocsta case on Mattchew is up there among the least convincing cases I've read in this game. It appears to amount to "mafia briefly discussed something fairly irrelevant with another player, therefore that player is mafia". Could Mocsta actually believe that is a reasonable reason for suspecting someone, not to mention be his number one suspect, or is that a case made by a mafia who is under suspicion and just had three of his teammates flip on n?.

On October 20 2013 08:47 Holyflare wrote:
Want more damning conclusions/evidence?

Here is Mocsta's original case: Click me!

and this:



There's 1 kp, scum just got hit hard, I don't think they'd be in the position to bus right now, so why has mocsta dropped this entire read for mattchew instead? Especially as the evidence he's given isn't very damning for mattchew. I had a case on mattchew before the lynch too that was much more substantial but I've been discussing this with him in our QT, his reactions to me were very puzzled at how nobody could understand why he was doing the things he was doing (not something I'd expect from a scum) but I'm still a little wary.




Mocsta also switched his vote during the Cephiro/Palmar situation to BH. He switched after I said day 2 was better to get a read off him but then switched to Palmar who arguably was the same. Why? Palmar was going after Mocsta and only him. It's obviously an easy wagon to join.

On October 20 2013 08:58 raynpelikonoshi wrote:
Mocsta, gief lvl (%) of scuminess on both BH and Mattchew plz.

On October 20 2013 09:05 Holyflare wrote:


It is most definitely not tunneling and I of course know what that is. I can say the same thing about all of your last posts confirming/disproving towns/scum. A lot of those were confirmation biased opinions. This is just stating facts. Either way, I am comfortable lynching BH in light of this and it gives us more time to discuss other scenarios/scum.

##Vote: Blazinghand