Thug Life Mini Mafia - Page 23

On October 01 2013 00:46 VayneAuthority wrote:
after reading all filters those are the 3 that were most likely to dispose of BH

On October 12 2013 04:19 austinmcc wrote:
You have a quote that says you don't know what to make of it. You have a quote that these three are the most likely to dispose of him. They either conflict OR you think those three are the most likely to dispose of him but don't actually know what to do with that thought.

And there's no attempt to go "these are the people most likely to dispose of him, which one is the MOST likely." If you come to a conclusion, your conclusion is "These are the people that might have wanted to kill BH and they're all scum." To me, that's a part of the progression of you thinking about the NK, but not the end. Throwing out the names without digging to see if you like one in particular, or think that these 2 might be on the same team because of x, and therefore BH was probably killed by that team, etc. etc. You pause at "here are some dudes."

On October 11 2013 09:59 VayneAuthority wrote:
in regards to the whole payphone thing this is where im at:

s0lstice = scum read on Mr.CC

CR = useless(sorry)

austin = adamant about pandain not being scum even when it was blatantly obvious, couldn't wait for noire to be over to say it.

so this together makes sense on paper in them thinking that cheesecake is the last scum and contacting him.

On October 10 2013 07:54 VayneAuthority wrote:


1. Doesn't implicate anyone really. s0lstice had Mr.CC as a scumread so it actually makes sense that he contacted him as a potential opposing team, and he also thought pandain was town. This doesnt have to be some elaborate plan by any means, it could be simply that.

2. Again, doesn't implicate anybody. Only shows that they were trying to save the last banger. Hence why when pandain dies, CR tries to unclaim scum.

3. See above, completely meaningless to finding the last scum.

4. Austin has been targeting s0lstice and CR for a bit recently, this implicates him the most. S0lstice also warmed up to an austin lynch before the whole fiasco but never actually expands on it.

In the end, I'm willing to stick with Occam's razor which has been great so far and lynch austin who I believe is the last scum. He has quite a long bullshit of a filter, but in the end his play doesn't add up this game.

Austin is the last scum, final answer.

On October 12 2013 07:20 austinmcc wrote:
rayn, apart from the payphone doodle, can you give me a couple things about cheesecake that you find/found townie?

VA,
I think some of the stuff you did was scummy. I'd think it regardless of alignment. It's not lying, it's not being untruthful, I don't think you came to the final conclusion when analyzing the BH kill. You gave a list of 3 people, decided you'd vote for them ALL, without doing ANY analysis of why one might be more likely than the other, why one person gave a town read on BH but wasn't scum, etc. etc. Essentially, ANYONE WHO HAD A TOWNREAD ON BH D1 WAS SCUM FOR YOU, and that was it. No attempt to see if the rest of their filters did anything for you, no attempt to pick a likely killer, just BH died --> people townie on BH most likely killers --> here are people townie on BH --> I will vote for all of them.

Actually, same question to you VA, apart from the payphone thing, Cheese is town because ____________

On October 12 2013 07:34 austinmcc wrote:
I guess I don't understand how occam's razor says "the dude who nobody can say a townie thing about, bar the payphone" is the less obvious mafia than the various crap you think about me.

On October 12 2013 07:37 austinmcc wrote:
no. not at all.

I can type "I'm an elephant."

It's not apparent that I'm an elephant.

For it to be apparent that you actually looked at their filters, I'd expect quotes from their filters, or references to scummy posts they made, or ANY sort of specific reference. Instead, you comment on hiro/WoS and some other stuff, then say, "I delved their filters."

You saying you did something doesn't make it apparent that you actually did it, when this is a game where people lie.

On October 12 2013 13:48 raynpelikoneet wrote:
The most hilarious part for me was when Noir ended, i think "okay so now i can actually make a case against Pandain". Then Vayne immediately posts "Pandain totally scum, no doubt."

"Thank you, a totally free and legit townread added to my collection." ^_^