|
Ceph's point of view makes a lot of sense if you accept
1: Ceph finds hiro town 2: Ceph thinks zentor is scum 3: Ceph has two items a kp and and item A 4: Ceph cannot use item A 5: Give kp to town read and item A to scum read 6: Have town read retrieve Item A by kill scum read.
I don't accept part 1 though. How exactly is hiro town?
|
On September 10 2013 06:12 Mr. Cheesecake wrote:Show nested quote +On September 10 2013 06:12 austinmcc wrote: Has he done anything as part of this plan other than crushing Zentor? Put yourself outside the plan (if you're town).
If HiroPro is town, he probably follows along, pew pew Zentor.
If HiroPro is mafia, he does...what? He crushes someone else? He says he never got the crusher? The moment he gets involved in something he doesn't fully understand, he HAS to follow instructions, or it may very well be a scumclaim. And if HE refuses to follow instructions and basically scumclaims, he almost certainly dies. And if he dies and flips scum, we 100% flip Zentor.
Mafia HiroPro HAS to follow the plan. Him crushing Zentor doesn't indicate anything. Did Hiro ever question hammering Zentor? Was he apprehensive about it? Or was it LOLHAMMER
Pretty sure it was LOLHAMMER.
|
|
On September 10 2013 06:24 Clarity_nl wrote:Show nested quote +On September 10 2013 06:23 Risen wrote:On September 10 2013 06:22 Clarity_nl wrote: I still think axle is town, I dunno about hiro but I think zentor is gonna flip scum and that would make hiro town. We really should consolidate, but interest in randombum seems to be going away because of the austin check that MIGHT happen??
I'm really tempted to just lynch into one of the 3p claims because this is just ridiculous. And just when I have consolidated my final three scum reads you come in and say stupid shit like this. He IMMEDIATELY crushed zentor without even a question of why. If he's scum with zentor why would he do that?!?
Because he planned ahead of time before answering he was here who he would be willing to crush.
|
I think his sneakiness in trying to catch WoS in a lie by not posting in mason is pretty scummy. If he was town he should have used the mason to talk to him instead of what he did. I don't think his whole "YOU LIED" deal made much sense against WoS. Especially since I don't even think he caught him in a lie.
|
Ceph, I think you are trying too hard for your plan and big plays to work out and not seeing what everyone else is seeing. Like you want this plan to work so hard you are assuming that zenor have to be scum and hiro has to be town.
There's not much else in hiro's play that really points him as town. I mean even this day when he's becoming a major lynch target all he is doing is sheeping you.
|
Fuck, I've been flip flopping internally on axle and hiro. At this point I'm willing to just sheep and go with thread sentiment.
I assume it's not possible we can consolidate on rayne? I'm one of the few that actually think he's scum?
|
Axle disappearing and his hiding play was really not good. Refusal to claim is also bad.
Hiro's brown shit was bad, and his not caring today accept to sheep ceph is also really shitty.
zentor ninja vote is really wtf too.
I'm also scared if hiro IS scum then we lose since w/e ceph gave zentor would be super scary in scum hands.. arrrgh
|
Lol axles finally returns?
|
Why did the soul gem gun not work?
|
Right... I rememebr reading that in QT, but forgot about it again.
|
Dandel's list is surprisingly scary.
|
Also I gotta say this game was extra hard for me. I really wanted to be "townier" and not be so obvious scum, but with my role I thought it would actually be best to be caught earlier than later since you know, I had 6 lives.
|
On September 11 2013 11:57 WaveofShadow wrote: Ok some random questions/comment: What was up with Black Mesa? WHO THE FUCK WAS YI Is 8-man scumteam and that many 3P really balanced? ( I assume it is given town roles but jeez) Town and scum each having basically a 6-shot vet? Wat? I don't think my body was quite ready for the chaos that happens in an Aperture game. (Speaking of Chaos...what was that? Was it used?)
Also, I find anger works really really well for me. No hard feelings Axle? I didn't mean any of it, I swear! :D
I wanna know this too. Pretty sure YI was felkr.
|
The whole thing with yi was it's extra funny because being in BM chat he knew stutters wanted to check him, but he just so happened to be the god father role so he got a green check and got to sail through the game.
|
I thought the masoning thing would happen instantly and only last that during the phase I did it. Like if I mason n2 I get it for n2 and n2 only. But I think it was actually use it at night get it the following day until the next day. whoops. We dind't really need to coordinate with VE though, he pretty blatantly playing for scum from our PoV
|
|
|
|