Newbie Mini Mafia XLV - Page 5

On August 06 2013 05:43 Umasi wrote:
nightcat is just confirmed not scum, could still be sk. Won't pursue that avenue of logic atm :< it's not relevant

On August 05 2013 07:18 RDaneelOlivaw wrote:
FUCK. I was at the card shop for a magic sealed event and my phone died, which is why I couldn't switch when we went for gotard. Sorry guys, yes that looks scummy as hell.

As for why I stayed on Umasi earlier--we had 3? votes for him and there was no real consensus, I just didn't switch bc it to seemed silly to just keep throwing around the vote until we had decided who to knock out....is what it is, not much else I can say. Obviously you all will still be suspicious, not much else I can do besides playing well from here on out anyway....I'll go back through again and read the last pages, see what happened

On August 06 2013 09:14 RDaneelOlivaw wrote:

I do keep track of those sort of things. I've been keeping up on the thread and if you notice, I was posting in the morning just before so I had read up

Where does this idea that I haven't posted any reads come from? I was actually the one first made a real case for suspicion against Gotard, and I was very vocal on my opinions of Usami. I've posted plenty of my own reads.

At any rate, last night kind of fucked up what I thought again.
Stim are confirmed town

Slam is playing a really strong town game--that being said- why has he not been lynched? Seems like he would have been a great target for mafia-he would be playing a wild joker game, but he seems like that sort of guy..he is the best and mosts experienced player here.just something worth thinking about

That leaves Deus and Umasi

Still a little suspicious of Umasi--his play to go after scam may have been an attempt to put his name in the clear by getting rid of a lurker and also spearheading a charge to kill a fellow mafia member.

Dues--I have a decent townread on him

Nightcat--he may be town, but he is not confirmed not-scum either, but there are a number of important possibilities to consider- namely Mafia tried to kill jaded salesman first night, or someone who was saved by the doctor the first night. They would know that their kill was blocked and there IS a serial killer- fact is, he is still my strongest scum read

Look at this post again+ Show Spoiler +
Not only completely wrong, but the reasoning is exceptionally weak. 1 liners and no quotes about his scum reads--it is more of a post because he has to and to shift suspicion than anything else.

Also, an "if I die" post? He's clearly trying to play up the possibility of his being murdered. Why? Everybody has the chance, why make such a big deal of it? To associate himself with town as much as possible

+ Show Spoiler +
+ Show Spoiler +

Above, he tries the very low-profile defense of Gotard. First states he is pretty sure that he's town, then questions why everyone is voting for him. Just enough to call into question the vote against Gotard and try to help Gotard's defense without drawing signifcant attention to himself. He doesn't join on the suspicion of Gotard until the last minute, when it becomes apparent that Gotard is going to be lynched.


Also important to note is that his posts are almost entirely fluff. Most are 1 or 2 liners making some minor comment to show his presence in the thread (or to ask slam for an opinion, which he does a lot of ) without drawing attention. He's largely failed to level significant accusations (he's only posted them twice?), and the one's he has made he has not gone after aggressively. He posts them and then lets it go, leading me to believe that once again, he was posting them to blend in, not to actually make strong cases.





Probably nothing, but "another source"---that's a pretty confident statement

On August 06 2013 11:56 Alakaslam wrote:
Flesh out nightcat vote then?

On August 07 2013 21:59 RDaneelOlivaw wrote:
I cannot wait to see the oh shit posts when I flip town. Y'all are gonna have a fun time!