|
On July 23 2013 05:52 getmoript wrote:
Why is that Scummy JJD? I've called lots of people out for bullshit reasons this game. Sometimes you're just looking for reactions. Lol well I think ur scummy also so that's not gonna sway me.
On July 23 2013 05:54 getmoript wrote:
Really and truely JJD, I'm far more interested by the fact that you haven't updated the read to include anything from last night/today in it. Just "read my old post... lmk what you think guys." Nothing's really happened since then so yeah it is prtty much the same case. But no one really acknowledged it @ the time so I figured I'd put it out there again. Especially since no one is really talking about much else.
|
Marshall Islands1474 Posts
On July 23 2013 05:53 FiveTouch wrote:
Is there any reason a town-aligned Tofu can't be making those posts to like...provoke discussion or get reactions? Is there some reason you've narrowed it down to scum-aligned mentality?
That was my original problem with ur case and what remains my primary issue with it. Also consider: scum aren't often found to be just flinging shit every direction as their primary action in the game. Scum are more often found among the assenting voices...the hushed murmur in the background of people lining up to give away their votes to the loudest, often wrongheaded, actual attackers.
-VE
Don't ignore me JJD. You won't like me when I'm ignored.
-VE
|
@JJD. So have you actually read the thread?
|
On July 23 2013 06:08 FiveTouch wrote:Show nested quote +On July 23 2013 05:53 FiveTouch wrote:
Is there any reason a town-aligned Tofu can't be making those posts to like...provoke discussion or get reactions? Is there some reason you've narrowed it down to scum-aligned mentality?
That was my original problem with ur case and what remains my primary issue with it. Also consider: scum aren't often found to be just flinging shit every direction as their primary action in the game. Scum are more often found among the assenting voices...the hushed murmur in the background of people lining up to give away their votes to the loudest, often wrongheaded, actual attackers.
-VE Don't ignore me JJD. You won't like me when I'm ignored. -VE You can say that about almost anything scummy people do. If that was the case, wouldn't he have said so when questioned about it? He totally defended the points he made:On July 21 2013 08:04 FirmTofu wrote:Show nested quote +On July 21 2013 08:03 getmoript wrote:
Tofu what are you trying to do with that post? Trying to decide who to place my vote on. I'm not sure if I should vote you or rayn. Help me decide maybe?
On July 21 2013 08:07 FirmTofu wrote:Show nested quote +On July 21 2013 08:05 getmoript wrote:
You're being suspicious of 3 people early without having anything actually scummy from any of them. Just seems like you're trying to push random bullshit suspicion for no reason. Well, to me, it looks like I'm trying to find scum. Care to address my points instead of calling it bullshit suspicion? Thanks, bud.
And getmoript, why did you question him about the posts if you dont think they're scummy?
|
JJD, what do you think of oats?
|
You really haven't been reading have you jjd
|
As for why I asked: I found him scummy. But that doesn't make him scum. He's come across as scummy as town before.
|
|
|
Marshall Islands1474 Posts
JRKirby I'm intrigued by this Oats suspicion of yours and I'm anxious to see how he presents himself in the coming days.
What do you think, my friend, my colleague, about Zephirdd/Corazon?
|
Marshall Islands1474 Posts
Yes rayn I'm right here bbygrl don't worry.
|
On July 23 2013 06:19 getmoript wrote:
You really haven't been reading have you jjd Why don't you come out and say what you're trying to say instead making cryptic/condescending remarks that can't possibly be helpfull?
@jkirby - leaning scum on oats.
Leaving work. Will be around in a few hours.
|
VE what's your read on geript atm?
|
I don't see anything that's a red flag yet, but Zephirdd didn't post at all day 1 right? So I don't have enough to go off of yet.
|
Marshall Islands1474 Posts
Town. Too active to be scumGeript. I'm not sure I remember seeing WaveScum, but I don't expect it to be this active either. Too attention-whorey, too discussion-drivey.
|
On July 23 2013 06:26 jrkirby wrote:
I don't see anything that's a red flag yet, but Zephirdd didn't post at all day 1 right? So I don't have enough to go off of yet.
That's pretty interesting because you semmed to have 2 scumreads on D1... What's changed?
|
Marshall Islands1474 Posts
JR could you at least pretend to follow up on a question I ask you? Look, I'll even lay it out for you.
This was where I initially was concerned about Zephirdd - his intro post was totally fluff and accomplished nothing, followed by hard lurk.
On July 21 2013 15:19 FiveTouch wrote:
Okay I've read the thread and I want to lynch a lurker. Throw a dart between DocH, Zephirdd, Oatsmaster and TAA. None have even tried to fake caring about the game, so I'm not even going to fake caring about their lives. Who's it gonna be guys?
I prefer Zeph, as he's actually posted yet has said literally nothing...but like I said, I would support any of the other lynches I mentioned without hesitation.
-VE
This was my response to Cora's catchup post after replacing Zephirdd:
On July 23 2013 05:30 FiveTouch wrote:Show nested quote +On July 23 2013 05:04 cDgCorazon wrote:
Ok so I read everyone's filter and I've come up with a few opinions:
-TG should've been lynched D1. Like seriously. His game has been ridiculously scummy and he should've been lynched for it.
-Getmoript needs to stop arguing with everyone. While I applaud them for posting a lot and trying to move things forward, they are borderline creating chaos in the game. I'm leaning a bit towards scum with them, but I need to see more because Geript is playing very rash and emotional while WoS is being more moderate and even-keel.
-DrH did cause a no-lynch so I think that should against him, but he should not be instantly beheaded for it. That being said, I really do want to hear more from him.
-Everyone has been too spammy in their posts, and there has not been enough analysis. Only 2 or 3 players have been providing good analysis on a constant basis. In an environment like this, scum are going to thrive. Everyone needs to step up so scum have nowhere to hide.
If anyone wants opinions on specific things, just ask. Well that was underwhelming. Let's recap. TG = Scummy. Okay so far...no analysis about what it means that we no lynched or anything, but whatever Cora is blameless being a replacement anyway. Getmoript = leaning scum in spite of doing townie things. No reason given. Don't like that. DrH = not leaning scum in spite of doing scummy things. Wants to hear more. Meh whatever, I don't like it but I'm biased. Everyone spammy whine. Don't like it. Also he's saying he read filters, but this looks more like a bullet list of topics after skimming the thread. Why no questions of people who have NOT been topics of discussion? Overall I give this catchup post a 3 out of a possible 10 for towniness and I'm now scrutinizing Corazon heavily. -VE
I've got serious misgivings with that slot (which is why I asked you) so you just saying "Nothing, there's nothing to go off of" is a little insulting whether intended or not. Care to dig deep and give me your thoughts on what I've said about them?
|
On July 23 2013 06:27 FiveTouch wrote:
Town. Too active to be scumGeript. I'm not sure I remember seeing WaveScum, but I don't expect it to be this active either. Too attention-whorey, too discussion-drivey.
WoS is actually decent as mafia, and able to mimic his townplay pretty well from what i remember. I have mixed feelings from them, especially geript.. But actually you are right regarding geript, i already forgot LXI.
Hmm, there are too many people who look bad. FirmTofu comes off more townie than scum from D1 end.
Who are your scumreads atm?
|
Marshall Islands1474 Posts
I'm leaning scum on DocH, Corazon and maybe one of the active voices that I'm ignoring for the time being.
|
Why not TanGeng/JJD/jkirby?
|
Marshall Islands1474 Posts
I get newbie saying newbie shit vibes off jrk and JJD. And TanGeng is....on the block for tomorrow right?
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
