[T] Nuclear Winter Mafia - Page 2

On July 06 2013 14:39 geript wrote:
Just play both, we'll just nuke your ass asap

On July 07 2013 14:06 CaucasianAsian wrote:
Wow just woke up. There is so much random rambling in here so far.

On July 07 2013 10:39 geript wrote:
@Teng, what do you think of WoS and why?

3. Why does Alakaslam's martyring make him look scummy?
It's like a preemptive defense that an innocent player would not need. I mean c'mon, would you or I leave the thread and feel the need to defend ourselves in case someone attacked us while we were gone? Townies get called scum all the time, but they have an inherent innocence about their defense because they know the accusations are wrong. Scum know deep down the accusations are right and thus have this inherent guilt. That's why martyring is scummy, it shows that inherent guilt.

On July 05 2013 01:42 Alakaslam wrote:
May I learn from watching the greats within!

On July 08 2013 08:48 austinmcc wrote:
His case feels a little weak:

On July 08 2013 03:48 Meapak_Ziphh wrote:
Ok so I just went down the line of filters:

Dandel: Made a statement about afking through the day phase and has thus far followed through with it. His play is very different from town Dandel and I would not at all be opposed to seeing him lynched.
Verdict: Possible Scum


Ghost_403: No posts
Verdict: Someone vigi his ass

Oatsmaster: his only post thus far has been nuking johnnywup. He really needs to post more because right now he really leaves a lot to be desired… especially since I’m not ruling out his nuke being the one that’s aimed at me.
Verdict: Null

Stutters695: Two posts, one saying he’s awake and the other saying he’s reading the thread. Would love to know what information he gleaned from his read through.
Verdict: Null

Z-Boson: No posts
Verdict: Someone vigi his ass

Abenson: Two posts, one talking about how shitty the thread is and one speculating on the setup.
Verdict: Possible Scum

Meapak: Fantastic posts, truly enlightening filter, someone every mafia play should aspire to.
Verdict: Towniest Townie who ever Towned

Ace: decent posts, isn’t reading the thread very well, but most definitely isn’t scum for easily noticeable meta reasons. Seriously if you doubt me on this one just go look at any Ace scum game ever and you’ll see what I’m talking about.
Verdict: Probably Town

MajuGarzett: Two utterly worthless question posts.
Verdict Possible Scum

Johnnywup: Really not as bad as people kept making him out to be. Sure his entrance post wasn’t good but he’s obviously trying and does not seem defensive or inherently guilty. He just looks like any regular noob player who rolled town.
Verdict: Probable Town

Onegu: See this is a point in which I wish this was a PM game because I’d love to organize some pressure against this dude to see how he reacts. His posts have a very vague feel to them but there’s nothing there yet that I would call definitively scummy. I guess the best I can do is keep an eye on him and see what happens:
Verdict: Null

Geript: I’m eager to see his reasoning behind the list of people he wants to lynch but overall I feel very good about him this game. He’s posting well and is thinking along the same lines I am. Also after being scum with him in the last game, his behavior is so different this game I just have to use a little meta.
Verdict: Probably Town

VayneAuthority: hmm tricky one. On one hand his posts feel very natural and open which is good because it means he’s not hiding anything but on the other hand he’s been useless thus far. He’s another one I’m going to have to wait and see on.
Verdict: Null

Strongandbig: only just started playing, I’ll wait and see.
Verdict: Null

Gumshoe: I actually agree with s&b that gumshoe’s constant talk of nukes is odd but I don’t think it’s damning. Aside from the nuke talk I actually didn’t really have any problems with gumshoe.
Verdict: Possible Town

OriginalName: This one’s making a lot of sense/agreeing with me on the right things.
Verdict: Probably Town

TanGeng: For someone who doesn’t have a lot of posts this dude is surprisingly coherent and smart.

Verdict: Possible Town

Xatalos: this bro and I are dying which is too bad because he’s def town
Verdict: Probable Town

CaucasianAsian: One post talking about the thread.

Verdict: Someone vigi his ass

Alakaslam: For all the pregame spam he had he’s been very quiet now that the actual game has started. That coupled with his little martyr post (watch me be scummy by tomorrow morning) tells me that I should fulfill his prophecy.
Verdict: Possible Scum

WaveOfShadow: last game as scum I wrote what I thought was actually a very decent piece of analysis (albeit fake) against WoS. I see him doing a lot of stuff that I had brought up in my analysis again which makes me think we’re dealing with a town WoS
Verdict: Probably Town

Jampidampi: New player, don’t recognize him, he at least seems like he’s trying to play the game.
Verdict: Possible Town

Raynpelikoneet: lolscum
Verdict: Probably Scum

Nirvana.Gabo: promised to be active, he has a few more hours left of grace period.
Verdict: Null

FirmTofu: said he needed a few minutes to read the thread, never got back.
Verdict: Someone vigi his ass

Chezinu: possibly town, don’t really feel like arguing with the jubjubs about this one.
Verdict: Possibly Town

Austinmcc: need to see some activity bro :/ I liked it when he was posting but now that it slacked off a bit I don’t like the feeling. If Austin comes back I’ll feel much better, if he stays away I’ll start thinking scum.
Verdict: Null

Ok so tl;dr
Probably scum: raynpelikoneet
Possible scum: Danel, abensen, MajurGarzett, Alakaslam
Null: oatsmaster, stutters, onegu, vayneauthority, strongandbig, Nirvana, austinmcc
Possible town: gumshoe, TanGeng, jampidampi, Chez
Probably town: Ace, Johnnywup, geript, originalname, xata, WoS
Towniest townie who ever town: Meapak_Ziphh

Vigi these lurkers ASAP: ghost_403, Z-Boson, CaucasianAsian, FirmTofu

On July 08 2013 09:07 austinmcc wrote:
Which exchanges in particular had you scummy on rayn/what posts pull you back the other way? I don't care oodles and oodles about changed minds, but it helps to actually know where your mind was and is.

On July 08 2013 09:18 Z-BosoN wrote:
austinmcc , you have neither said hi to me nor have you called me scum. This goes against your "hurray" townie attitude I am accustomed with, and sets a mild taste taciturn and shady mood, tempered with a bit of shadyness and prejudice, when I think of you.

Has time withered your love for me away? Or are there.... "other" reasons... ?

On July 08 2013 09:02 VayneAuthority wrote:
If anyone gets cold feet on this shit let it be known that I am down for a Caucasian or dandel lynch as well, after reading up on the recent back and forth this is kinda textbook dandel scum from playing scum with him