PTP IV - Demon's Run - Page 14

On July 03 2013 09:04 Dandel Ion wrote:

Wait wasn't there somebody ranting about people equating role = town?

I think I remember somebody like that.
Do you know who it was? Cause you should totally talk to him.

On July 03 2013 09:17 Acrofales wrote:
Well, I just raged at town from obs QT from the moment I was dead. Yes, sk8r played pretty badly, but you had fucking AUSTIN to lynch and he wiggled his way out of it. Then you got a retry with all that confirmed scum around and shot XATALOS.

Town threw this game pretty badly

Endgame was fun, though :D

On July 03 2013 09:22 Meapak_Ziphh wrote:
Honestly I do agree a little bit with geript's balance whine and think kita should have just been scum. Even though we won town still had waaaaaay too much leniency to fuck up.

Other than that it was a fun game, thanks to decon and sent for hosting.

Also fuck you BC I thought we were bros lol

On July 03 2013 09:20 strongandbig wrote:
Still the role I made was the best

On July 03 2013 23:44 Xatalos wrote:
ALTHOUGH!!!

I did clearly ask in the thread for host confirmation about this mess. What we got were two opposite answers by two different hosts ("no" by deconduo and "yes" by Sentinel). This could all have easily been resolved, and somewhat likely my death avoided, if it had been just made clear in the thread as I requested to begin with.

Hosts pls

(PS. I would have repeatedly demanded the situation to be resolved in the thread if I hadn't been AFK for that crucial time. Thus, I am also to blame for being AFK, although less than the hosts for contradicting each other IMO.)

(PS+. Otherwise good job hosts, but this one failure *might* have caused town to lose. I hope I don't sound too much like geript now, I'm just.... Sad, I guess. Since I wrongly suspected Crossfire99 and he wrongly suspected and pushed me to death.)

On July 04 2013 05:34 kitaman27 wrote:
I think it was a nice improvement that players did not know who they were picking for. The possibility of players creating their own role really opened up the fake claim options as well. Introducing a couple non-submitted roles (while omitting a few of the player created ones) might make fake claiming even easier.

The problem with all blue games is that everyone wants to be superman and that leads to really swingy games. Players that don't wind up with overpowered roles are disappointed, yet a game full of them is too rough on town.

Even normal roles like detective or 2-shot vig become too powerful in a setup like this because there is too much role synergy when everyone has an ability every night.

On July 04 2013 00:56 kitaman27 wrote:


You created your own role didn't you? Couldn't you just include a mafia player in the group, rig the results every night, turn your role into a mafia kp and then never claim how it works? You'd eventually have to come up with a fake claim at endgame, but that endgame would come a cycle sooner and you didn't need to tell the truth about how the role works because only you know how it works.