Following through with that, If you saying that people with the same reads are more likely to share the same side, then you're making the argument that people with different reads are more likely to NOT share the same side. That's just simple. So why wouldn't you absolutely attack anyone who doesn't share your early reads? Nope, this is a complete waste.

geript

10024 Posts

March 02 2013 20:16 GMT

#2911

Your point is that people who have the same reads are more likely to share the same perspective and therefore more likely to share the Same alignment. This assumes that scum/3rd party can't attack from town perspective or in the least is unlikely to. Isn't the point of scum to be more 'towny' than town and aggressively punish bad town?

Nope, you're logic is bad. It completely ignores the fact that people can come to the same reads from different perspectives. It's just bad.

geript

10024 Posts

March 02 2013 22:41 GMT

#2941

When I think about him I touch myself

geript

10024 Posts

March 03 2013 00:07 GMT

#2991

Well I think that I don't need to check this thread anymore.

geript

10024 Posts

March 03 2013 00:13 GMT

#3002

On March 03 2013 09:10 Wade Fell wrote:
"blazinghand how are you so good"

"i was wrong all along and blazinghand was always right"

Well 2/3 ain't bad I guess.

geript

10024 Posts

March 03 2013 00:23 GMT

#3005

I appreciate it BH, but I don't think there's a point.

geript

10024 Posts

March 03 2013 00:52 GMT

#3015

A few points before I intentionally go quiet until whenever it is I end up dead. I'm going to recommend not killing me, it's a waste of town KP; and scum may intentionally heal me to counteract it. You can roleblock me if you want, but I'd rather you protect someone else.

If I find anything productive to say then I'll post it then. Odds are though that I'm just going to stay out of discussion entirely as I think that's likely the most productive thing I can do at this point.

geript

10024 Posts

March 03 2013 00:56 GMT

#3018

Look mic, really just drop it.

geript

10024 Posts

March 03 2013 01:02 GMT

#3023

Vivas I'm a setter. If I read the OP right then an armored can copy medic and protect.

geript

10024 Posts

March 03 2013 04:12 GMT

#3041

Ok WF, I'll come at it again with another set of eyes. But don't expect it until 5-6 am est. I have to finish up work then reread from the beginning.

geript

10024 Posts

March 03 2013 08:24 GMT

#3062

On March 01 2013 04:31 WaveofShadow wrote:
VE states it himself: Geript looks like he is grasping SO HARD to find something wrong with VE, when in reality he's looking in the wrong place. VE never lied about his intentions at all, rather its his behaviour which makes VE not look so great at times and his ragey raging at the end of D1...but instead Geript tunnels him on lying. VE has defended himself on the 'lying' aspect adequately, I feel. I'll get to this in my analysis of his most recent case at the end.

There have been lots of little things that have bugged me about WoS. Call it tunneling, call it confirmation bias, call it whatever you want. Now I'll admit that the bolded phrase could be taken to mean, "VE is clearly town." But isn't the simplest way of saying that as doing just that. This phrasing makes it sound to me like he knows the right place to be looking.

More to come.

geript

10024 Posts

March 03 2013 08:44 GMT

#3066

OO's filter looks bad, but he's genuinely disinterested in the game. In the last game he was clearly invested and interested (as 3rd party). Whether or not you factor any BPD into the equation, I seriously doubt it would affect it like this. If he's rolled scum you'd at least be seeing him wave up and down and that's just not there at all. I have him marked as 1000% vanilla.

geript

10024 Posts

March 03 2013 08:48 GMT

#3067

Also as an fyi, this may end up being more stream of consciousness than I intended, but it's coming out as it comes out.

geript

10024 Posts

March 03 2013 08:51 GMT

#3069

JJ has made some real sense to me throughout and in review his filter I don't entirely understand his whole case on Aqua, but it definitely seems weird that Aqua only 'buys' the Prome case when WF spells it out. I mean, I had Prome as null to null minus, but WF case didn't budge me whatsoever. IIRC, Wade's case was the nail in the coffin of sorts. Right now I'm leaning Plus, since Aqua's been attacking OO who I have at vanilla it makes more sense for Aqua to be scum. I'm definitely leaning Aqua as not third party.

geript

10024 Posts

March 03 2013 09:03 GMT

#3075

TMM made a hard defense of Prome with a possible chainsaw on Vivax. He admits to being willing to bus as scum. He's seems completely indifferent as to who he attacks and doesn't really care about scumhunting. Strongly leaning 3rd party.

geript

10024 Posts

March 03 2013 09:03 GMT

#3077

Bipolar

geript

10024 Posts

March 03 2013 09:07 GMT

#3078

@Mocsta re:OO BPD tends to have highs and lows. I will admit that perhaps I'm projecting on him re: scum is fun because I've gotten non-VT twice, but I see no interest in staying alive in him. I'd expect that he'd either lurk hardcore doing the minimum until he'd die. He's wanting to put in effort but isnt; that's my read. Reads VT to me.

geript

10024 Posts

March 03 2013 09:24 GMT

#3080

On March 03 2013 17:51 Mocsta wrote:
It is the way he chooses to push his agenda.

I think there is a clear difference in that behaviour.

Look, there's really not a point. Honestly. My filter looks different at points and in some regards. He can point to size/vets/coaching, you can point to the fact that there's a difference. I can point to the fact in 12 games, I've gotten LVT in 10 of them (one of them I was mafia). Either way, I think that barring something completely crazy I can put the 11nth on the mantle with the rest. So I'd appreciate it if you'd just shut the fuck up about my play entirely as you're literally judging me on the best game I've played and there's no real way to defend myself this game.

geript

10024 Posts

March 03 2013 09:41 GMT

#3086

Randombum I have as total blue. People will likely hate me for saying that but whatever. Restraining Order is in the same boat as far as length goes, but he's completely null to me. I think he's getting a complete vet free ride.

geript

10024 Posts

March 03 2013 09:50 GMT

#3087

Grush is town. Not just for starsenses, but the dude attacks things sideways. When players who naturally attack things sideways, there's always an odd, forced feeling to it. There's nothing that reads to me like he feels forced to do something to prove what he's doing. He reminds me of a certain other player I know. He's 100% town though in my book.