TL Mafia LX - Page 4

On March 01 2013 11:56 geript wrote:
Chez I would've hearted you more if you had shot the suckling.

On March 01 2013 12:01 WaveofShadow wrote:
The chaos.....THE CHAOS
So....is there gonna be a flip or can we get back to productive discussion?

On March 01 2013 12:13 Wade Fell wrote:
Chezinu needs to be not-alive. IMO dayvig him or lynch him

I've outlined why, and his behavior today only reinforces how important it is to lynch him, and how obviously he is scum.

On March 01 2013 12:36 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
Resolving Chezinu's alignment:

If you are a town dayvig in this game you MUST shoot Chezinu right now. I am not inclined to believe Chezinu is the scum dayvig because the scumteam would see this logic coming. There is no sense in shooting Milkman, a player scum has no reason to be afraid of. If you instead prefer to claim tonight, we will lynch you and set town night KP on Chezinu. It is a 1:1 trade.

If there is no claim or shot, we can assume Chezinu is in fact the town dayvig so leaping onto him now is beside the point. There is a chance to actually confirm his alignment or get a 50/50 chance with it so I would like to move forward with my points on Toadesstern. Hold your horses BH, this is an easy resolution.

This is a semi-open setup but scum would never take the chance of using the dayvig power this early when there is a chance of a counterclaim. I refuse to believe scum would be that reckless after losing Day 1.

On March 01 2013 12:40 DoctorHelvetica wrote:
Chezinu, explain right now why you felt you should shoot the Milkman of any player. There was nothing really scummy about him.

I will wait for a counterclaim to make any further decision regarding Chezinu's alignment because we have a rare chance at actually getting an objective confirmation in this game. Any discussion prior to that will be unproductive I think.

On March 01 2013 12:44 MilkSuckler wrote:

You were accusing him of being the bartender

i awnt to know why....

On March 01 2013 12:45 jcarlsoniv wrote:
So wait...

DrH, if Chez flips town, would you be looking at grush to be scum dayvig?

It's something like this that would make it easy for grush to gain towncred cuz he can claim "I WAS JUST FOLLOWING ORDERS FROM DRH"

On March 01 2013 12:57 jcarlsoniv wrote:


Ok...I think I'm following.

I'm not disagreeing with ridding of Chez. What I'm disagreeing with is the thought process that if Chez flips green, that automatically makes grush red.

It makes him look worse, sure. But it is just as likely that grush could be green and trying to jump on the opportunity to rid of Chez thinking he's scum.

Hypothetical:
Wouldn't a scum dayvig know that Chez is green, and shooting him would reveal that? This makes it seem, in my mind at least, that grush is town just knowing that he wouldn't out himself as a vig if he were scum.

...I think my train of thought it followable

On March 01 2013 13:15 MilkSuckler wrote:
Im over this.. im starting to think grush was just trolling

Geript. i will have a look through what you wrote later on.. im not sure why your pushing the point though.. Toad has enough evidence on him to justify a consolidated vote

So i am not sure what you are trying to prove.

On March 02 2013 04:19 geript wrote:
Chez that is not a defense.