This Town Ain't Big Enough Mafia - Page 5

On February 28 2013 01:48 Oatsmaster wrote:
Iamp, why is adam a 3p?

On February 28 2013 01:58 zarepath wrote:


People don't play with labels on their heads reading "SCUM" or "TOWN," and they do not always play optimally or ideally, especially in weird formats like this one. I don't think you can declare someone 3P just because they don't play exactly according to your definition of what an ideal town or scum would do.

On February 28 2013 02:21 Oatsmaster wrote:
Actually thrawn you too, why did Adam basically claim 3P as Acro said instead of playing more like what a townie looks like?

On February 28 2013 02:25 zarepath wrote:


If you are so sure about Kier then vote for him. Doing anything else is a lack of conviction

On February 28 2013 02:27 Oatsmaster wrote:
No, what adam did was basically saying,
'I voted for that dude cause I wanted a mislynch'
He pretty much 'claimed' 3P right there. Except nobody does that.

On February 28 2013 03:38 Alderan wrote:
God this is setting up so perfectly for scum to push double lynch. They're able to do what Thrawn did and just switch at any time, or do what Dieno is doing and say,"welll..... I don't really know, nor do I plan on contributing so Im gonna put a vote on the one with the least and hope for the best."

And they are in a win win situation.

Two town deaths: "Oh well they played so bad, blame them, fucking noobs"
One town, One scum: "SEE, SEE WE TOLD YOU, WE'RE ALL TOWN"

I just don't see any evidence that someone can have as vanilla townie that suggest either are scum. Useless? Of course. Scum? I just don't see it.

On February 28 2013 03:44 Alderan wrote:


Why so defensive bro?

We have plenty of time for that, I'm not giving anyone any fodder to take this thread off track. The issue at hand is selecting this lynch, and in my opinion making sure it doesn't go to a double.

On February 28 2013 04:20 yamato77 wrote:

I've read the arguments, but you're so far into fantasy land with this that it makes zero sense. Adam's play makes plenty of sense from a town perspective, he's just not trying very hard to show it..

On February 28 2013 06:33 Alderan wrote:


While this hurts your opinion of me, your premise is wrong.

Didn't say it was double town, said I didn't feel good about either being scum (read: Null).

On February 28 2013 06:42 Alderan wrote:


BTW this is a scum quality.

On February 28 2013 02:52 Hapahauli wrote:
I'll be back in an hour. Till then, someone needs to explain to me why we're so sure that Adam is a 3rd party that we're willing to lynch him solely on that basis. 'Cause I don't get it at all.

On February 28 2013 12:01 The Macho Man wrote:

so you think hapa is town???????????????????????????????????????????????????

why dont you enlighten the rest of class

On February 28 2013 12:03 Oatsmaster wrote:
Nah.

Hey Iamp I also think hapa has been really fucking passive this game,

However, was it a bus on Keirathi?
His reasoning was suspect and I dont really know :/

Again, however, his posts leading up to the lynch where he blasted Acro for saying Adam was 3P were pretty townie.

On February 28 2013 12:09 Alderan wrote:


I don't know... I think if you, iamp, and Thrawn flipped it would not surprise me if there was one scum.

On February 28 2013 12:11 Acrofales wrote:

That's the point, he said it at the start.

On February 28 2013 12:15 Adam4167 wrote:
And if I take another scum with me, then Ill happily do it.