|
On February 15 2013 23:50 iamperfection wrote:Show nested quote +On February 15 2013 23:43 marvellosity wrote:On February 15 2013 23:40 iamperfection wrote:On February 15 2013 23:26 marvellosity wrote:On February 15 2013 23:23 iamperfection wrote:On February 15 2013 23:14 jcarlsoniv wrote:On February 15 2013 23:02 iamperfection wrote:
jcarl what do you think of marv? I think his posting is a pain in the ass to read, (although I enjoy reading a nice Game of Thrones novel in the middle of a mafia game), but nothing so far has really raised any flags for me. Why, what do YOU think of him? And dandelion, for that matter. i stated before if he doesn't start pushing his agendas strongly he is scum. dandelion has been giving town vibes all game. -says he doesn't care but has been active anyways -cared about the lynch -etc Sadly, scamp, you are mistaken, as amply demonstrated by Keirathi's quotation, and perhaps you would like to examine my discourse in the establishment of 'MTG'. It should have been quite clear that I would not push any "agenda" hard, as this was not my motivation for entering this fine establishment. Indeed, it perplexes me that you continue to think this. This will be, however, the last I make mention of it. because it is bs if you were town the burning desire to catch scum would shine through. Then I'm afraid, scamp, you do not know me like you think you do. Perhaps you'd like to browse MTG, where I openly sheeped Day 1 because I did not have the desire to make a comprehensive case myself. how is that relevant at all. you didnt sheep in this game the point im making is you didn't try to push hard to protect your town read in me or push your scum read. you disappeared at a critical time which i know if you really wanted to win you wouldn't. You brought up "real life" stuff the last time you did that from what i remember was when you were scum.
Your point doesn't make much sense. Wouldn't scum Marv want to win just as much as town Marv? Last minute wagons can hurt scum just as much (or more, really) as town.
Anyways, I'm not particularly thrilled with Marvs play this game, but posting in gentleman-speak and disappearing a few hours before the deadline (remember, he's 5 hours ahead of you) on a holiday are not alignment indicative,
|
On February 16 2013 06:50 gonzaw wrote:Considering everybody else, you seem the most townie at the moment. I guess you could be scum like in Aperture (you were pretty active there), but considering some factors and you contributing quite enough on D1 and stuff I'm not going to bother taking that into account yet. This game is so frustrating to try and get into. Some players haven't posted anything at all since like 50 hours ago, and everybody else is in this cloudy null pile, some of them not doing much either. I cba to read everybody's filter too. From gut feeling I'd say Keirathi (didn't like him just throwing out "yeah lynch gonzaw" without even trying to justify it, and when he did he did so indirectly until I called him out), and maybe Sylencia or another lurker, and maybe another one of the active/semi-active like kita/Kurumi/Dandel/iamperfection/marv. I have a plan for tonight though. One thing my role creator did right lol. P.S: 2+2=5...? lol austin why do you post so much cryptic stuff
Don't be dense. I gave my reasoning for wanting to lynch you in the very first post that I ever talked about you.
|
On February 16 2013 06:54 gonzaw wrote:
You did?
...
Wait I checked and the first time you mention me is when you post the "Aperture 2 WLIIA" stuff
Yes. And that was my reasoning for wanting to lynch you.
"Hey guys, I want to lynch gonzaw. When he's town, he does X. But when he's scum he does Y."
Maybe I didn't specifically say "And here's some examples of Y in this game", but the only reasonably assumption from my post is that I think you are acting more like Y than X.
|
On February 16 2013 08:48 Dandel Ion wrote:
I will deliver what needs to be delivered in style.
I hope it's this kind of style:
![[image loading]](http://image.shutterstock.com/display_pic_with_logo/160669/160669,1307547180,2/stock-photo-smiling-gentleman-wearing-a-cylinder-hat-78951385.jpg)
|
On February 16 2013 08:53 Dandel Ion wrote:
You may or may not be disappointed in the style.
If it's style that involves me dying, then yes, I may be disappointed.
If it involves scum dying, though, it would be acceptable no matter how the look suits my tastes.
|
Oh yea, and on the off chance that I am killed, I remark on this word again for some sleuth to figure out: Zerg.
|
|
|
On February 20 2013 03:20 jcarlsoniv wrote:My role was fucking terrible. I had to wait until N3 to be able to do anything at all. Was prepared to shoot kita tonight though. Unfortunately, I didn't have enough time at my disposal the first 2 days because of things that kept coming up, so I couldn't actually be of any use. Sry guys. I blame my role creator. 
My intention was for you to be able to vig night 2.
|
On February 20 2013 03:28 jcarlsoniv wrote:Show nested quote +On February 20 2013 03:26 Keirathi wrote:On February 20 2013 03:20 jcarlsoniv wrote:My role was fucking terrible. I had to wait until N3 to be able to do anything at all. Was prepared to shoot kita tonight though. Unfortunately, I didn't have enough time at my disposal the first 2 days because of things that kept coming up, so I couldn't actually be of any use. Sry guys. I blame my role creator. My intention was for you to be able to vig night 2. Then it needed to be worded differently. I asked grey, morning of D1 I only had 25 energy. Believe me, if I had a vig shot N2 it would've gone I kita's skull.
You started D1 with 25 energy. When n1 started, you should have had 50. When D2 started, you should have had 75. When n2 started, you should have had 100.
At least that was the way I originally worded it, unless GreYMisT changed it.
|
From Obs QT:
GreY wrote:
So an interesting thing is that jcarlson, despite what he is saying in the thread, didn't make your role Oats
From spreadsheet:
jcarlson - Picking For (Oatsmaster)
WHY YOU DECEIVE US GreY!?
|
On February 20 2013 03:38 jcarlsoniv wrote:Show nested quote +On February 20 2013 03:32 Keirathi wrote:On February 20 2013 03:28 jcarlsoniv wrote:On February 20 2013 03:26 Keirathi wrote:On February 20 2013 03:20 jcarlsoniv wrote:My role was fucking terrible. I had to wait until N3 to be able to do anything at all. Was prepared to shoot kita tonight though. Unfortunately, I didn't have enough time at my disposal the first 2 days because of things that kept coming up, so I couldn't actually be of any use. Sry guys. I blame my role creator. My intention was for you to be able to vig night 2. Then it needed to be worded differently. I asked grey, morning of D1 I only had 25 energy. Believe me, if I had a vig shot N2 it would've gone I kita's skull. You started D1 with 25 energy. When n1 started, you should have had 50. When D2 started, you should have had 75. When n2 started, you should have had 100. At least that was the way I originally worded it, unless GreYMisT changed it. Welcome to Themed game Mafia! You are the Infestor! You start with 25 energy, and gain 25 energy per phase (with the daypost).Only got energy with the day post. Needless to say, it SUCKS not having a power in a game where everyone has ridiculous powers.
GreY didn't inform me of that change. My intention was for you to get 25 energy per day and night phase.
|
On February 20 2013 04:13 austinmcc wrote:Show nested quote +On February 20 2013 04:13 gonzaw wrote:Here: Welcome to Themed game Mafia! You are the Infestor! You start with 25 energy, and gain 25 energy per phase (with the daypost). 25 energy per PHASE, day/night. 50 per cycle. I've always been told that a cycle is day/night, and that also fits with the Infestor energy gains. POSTGAME EDIT: I see what you're saying with that, but based on that the creator said, it was supposed to be a gain of 25 per day and 25 per night, for 50 a cycle. That PM just says 25 energy per phase, that he GAINS at the daypost (as I read it). So he gets 25 per cycle, but is only given the energy at the daypost, so it only comes in 50 energy chunks, at least as I read that.
The thing is, the terminology is inconsistent. I meant for jcarlson to get 25 energy per day, and 25 energy per night. But GreY was only giving him 25 energy per day+night combined.
|
On February 20 2013 04:28 austinmcc wrote:
Definitely seems to be key to make it very clear how you want everything to work. I know, like Gonzaw, I included a section of notes to Grey on how things should work, and he notified me of anything that he changed (originally, I had it so that Cpt. Picard could choose scum for a first officer and that scum would still bodyguard him - kill a scum, but then you lose your first officer and the role doesn't get passed down).
In terms of lessons learned for future PTP games, being super clear on how the role works seems like a good idea, and adding some more healing/protective powers seems like a good idea. Most of us went for offense, or gave people the OPTION for defense (except the support role, which had pure defense built in. Any others?), and it meant a very, very quick end to the game.
I actually thought my role was clear, as I sent it in.
"You are an Infestor! You start with 25 energy, and gain 25 energy per cycle (So 50 energy at the end of day 1, 75 energy at the end of night 1, etc)"
Maybe the terminology was bad with saying cycle instead of phase, but I gave an example of what I meant, and GreY didn't comment on that in our PM's balancing out the rest of the role.
Meh whatevs.
You are right we could have used more protective roles, though!
|
On February 20 2013 05:08 GreYMisT wrote:
Thanks for playing everyone. I hoped you enjoyed it and I apologize for being absent for a few days and for not getting all of the signups filled that I wanted. In the next month or so I might host a simple PYP game with maybe a few of these roles if that is something people are interested in.
PYP was what I was most looking forward to, and it didn't even make it that far!
Thanks for hosting <3
(Also, I'm still confused why you told obs QT that jcarlson didn't make Oats' role when spreadsheet says he did :o)
|
|
|
|
|
|
EPT
